Through the past week or so my wife and I have been working our way through the Extended Editions of the three The Lord of the Rings movies. I had seen Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers many times in the past, but had not yet had opportunity to watch the Extended Edition of The Return of the King. Aileen had seen only the theatrical editions of the first two. Three movies, each clocking in at three and a half to four hours is quite a commitment, but we made our way through an hour or two at a time after the children had gone to bed. I think I enjoyed them more than Aileen did, but she still seemed to get caught up in the story. Few movies can compare to a good book and these ones are no different in that regard. Still, they are stunning for their accurate creation of the world of J.R.R. Tolkien and for their great acting. They are always a joy to watch.
My favorite scene in the entire series happens near the end of the final film. As you no doubt remember (it has, after all, been fifty years since the books were first published!), Frodo and Sam have finally carried the ring to Mount Doom. Despite the months they have travelled and the dangers they have faced, Frodo still finds himself unable to part with the ring. The ring has thoroughly gripped his heart and now owns him more than he owns it. Frodo declares that the ring is his and puts it onto his finger for the last time. As he does so, Gollum leaps upon him, also desiring the ring. They struggle for some time and Gollum eventually bites off Frodo’s finger, steals the ring and rejoices in reclaiming it. A fight ensues in which Gollum maintains possession of the ring, but loses his balance and falls from a cliff. And here is the scene that has so often gripped me. Gollum, captured in slow motion, falls into the molten lava of Mount Doom. But as he falls, there is no terror in his eyes. No scream escapes his lips. Instead, he falls into the flame gently petting the ring, cooing to it, and delighting in his “precious.” His last word is “precioussss!” The evil ring that had first caused him to commit an act of murder and that had so long enslaved him is the object of his affection as he falls to his death.
That scene contains such a profound statement about human nature. Every time I see Gollum fall to his death, enraptured by the evil that has enslaved him, I think of the power of sin. I think of the power of sin that exists even in my own life. I know there are areas in my life that are precious to me even while they enslave me. There are areas in my life that I cling to and fight for even though they are wrong, even though they are evil. When I see Gollum fall, I see myself and the sin that enslaves me. I have to ask myself if there is sin in my life that grips me so much that I would cradle it and coo to it, even as it pulled me to my death. Often I have to ask not “if” but “where” such sin exists. It is a sobering time of reflection.




Comments (25) »
1. Blake
August 24, 2006
11:18 AM
profound. convicting. sin is a slave driver and a task master we all return to for more brutal misuse. it makes you start to see the reasoning behind the medieval definitions of freedom: a choice is freely made if it produces the greatest overal benefit for you!
2. blake
August 24, 2006
11:20 AM
… and therefore, complete suppliance and submission to God’s law is truest freedom!
3. Jabbok
August 24, 2006
11:54 AM
I can watch creatures and aliens and vampires, et.al. and have a good laugh but last night we watched “Misery”. When the woman took the sledge hammer and broke his ankles I thought I was going to throw up! That was really un-settling.
Anyway…
Have you seen King Kong yet? Gotta see the ape.
4. Eric
August 24, 2006
11:59 AM
Thank-you. Sometimes in life we need to be hit over the head with sobering realities. Thanks for the sledge-hammer upside my skull this morning. So much so that I may have to consider adding to the discussion later over at Renaissance Blogger.
I can always count on thoughtful, insightful posts from you!
Blessings…
5. Leslie
August 24, 2006
12:11 PM
I always thought, in the very last second, Gollum had a look of horror as he realized that his “precious” had betrayed him, even as it had all of its other bearers. The parallel still works, though. In my own sin-courting, my sins have always been revealed and left me exposed, and what I thought was going to be good, eventually deceived and burned me.
6. Carrie
August 24, 2006
12:19 PM
Very interesting analogy!
7. Jim Crigler
August 24, 2006
12:25 PM
With reference to your analysis of the particular scene in question: Kudos, well done.
But I can’t watch the movies without getting angry about the liberties taken with the story line. Worst addition: Arwen. Worst change: slaying of the Nazgul on the Pelenor (sp?) Fields.
I read LOTR to my kids, finishing each book before the corresponding movie came out. The scene at the Pelenor Fields is incredible when read aloud, but the movie ruins it by your knowing already that Eowyn is there. The surprise to the audience is just as important as the surprise to the Nazgul.
” ‘[…] and no man can slay me!’ “
“Then Merry heard, of all sounds that day, the strangest. It seemed that Dernhelm laughed.”
When I knew that passage was coming, I actually practiced it in advance to be able to read it with the effect that JRRT (seems to have) intended.
8. Eric Zeller
August 24, 2006
12:27 PM
Tim - Funny you mention that, I’ve been doing the same thing over the last few weeks. You need to give the “making of” documentaries a try - to me they are almost more interesting than the movies in some ways.
9. bethany
August 24, 2006
12:41 PM
i’m one of the few people who has yet to watch LOTR… i continually told myself i wanted to read the books before… but i look forward to seeing and recognizing those analogies and metaphors mentioned!
10. Karl
August 24, 2006
1:08 PM
You know, we just went through those movies with our kids for the first time. We have all the extended editions on DVD and skipped the more graphic parts. It amazed me how well they were able to keep up with the story - better than some adults I know.
You know, when I was younger, I always hated that it took Gollum biting the ring off Frodo’s finger for it to be destroyed. It always seemed to me that after going through so much to destroy it that it didn’t make sense that he would change his mind. Now that I’m older, and the parallels to sin are more clear to me, I see not only how Frodo and Gollum (and we) crave the things that will destroy us, but how repenting from sinful things 98% of the time is still not enough.
But my favorite scene in all the movies is when the Riders of Rohan arrive on the Pellenor Fields and look down on the tens of thousands of orcs and realize that they have no chance, and then ride on into battle anyway. That scene brought tears to my eyes the first time I saw it. The fulfillment of their commitment to fight with Gondor when all hope seems to be lost is very powerful.
11. Donna
August 24, 2006
1:20 PM
I have read the books at least 5 times over the years and now own all of the extended DVDs. I feel a bit ashamed that I have never made the connection to the power of sin in our lives with Gollum’s reaction to being consumed with the fire while finally getting his “precious” back. Excellent and powerful point Tim! I don’t think I will ever see that scene without thinking about it.
I also think that the the arrival of the Riders of Rohan at the Pellenor Fields is one of the most powerful scenes as well. Funny as a few folks mentioned that scene. I thought I was probably one of the only ones who felt that way.
12. Phil
August 24, 2006
2:07 PM
Am I the only one who thinks that Peter Jackson made Gandalf too morose and pessimistic in his adaptation of Return of the King? In the movie, Aragorn is constantly having to reassure Gandalf, encouraging him to have hope that all is not lost and that Frodo will succeed. My recollection from the books is that the situation is reversed: Gandalf consoles and encourages everyone else to have hope. Also, I really hated Gandalf’s defeat by the Witch King. Gandalf laying defeated on the ground, his staff broken, about to be eaten by the wyvern, is just not my idea of Gandalf (nor Tolkien’s I expect). — It’s been a while since I read the book though, so that scene may be accurate.
Best part of Return of the King for me? Gandalf’s speech to Pippin about the land in the west. Gandalf’s face and eyes take on a nostalgic look. It’s a beautiful moment because it reveals to Pippin (and to us) that this life is not all there is. We are destined for something far greater, far more beautiful than we can imagine. We must face life with bravery, but never despair knowing the end has already been written.
Gandalf knows this because that land in the west is where he came from. He is for all intents and purposes an angelic being. … Which takes me back to why I find the movie Gandalf’s pessimism and defeated attitude to be so annoying.
13. Jabbok
August 24, 2006
3:02 PM
OK and if the Balrog was the embodiment of all sinful creatures then the most frightening words in the movie were, “You shall not pass”.
We could go on like this all day :)
I just liked the elephant looking creatures.
14. Dallas Pymm
August 24, 2006
3:41 PM
Best character. Sam! No doubt. He was the real hero. Seriously. Frodo wouldn’t have gotten far without Sam. Best part of ROTK, when Sam said “I can’t carry this burden, but I can carry you!” And picks him up and runs him up the hill. C’mon, does not get better than that. Great example for Christian fellowship or something to sound spiritual.
15. Tim Challies
August 24, 2006
4:51 PM
I think you’re right, that Sam is the true hero of LOTR. I believe Tolkien pretty well said as much…
16. yes2truth
August 24, 2006
5:11 PM
Sir,
You said:
I have to ask myself if there is sin in my life that grips me so much that I would cradle it and coo to it, even as it pulled me to my death. Often I have to ask not “if” but “where” such sin exists. It is a sobering time of reflection.
It only exists in your body of sin and if you are Born Again you are no longer your body. Born Again sons of God are just that - sons of God, where the Holy Spirit dwells in our hearts. Jesus Christ and The Holy Spirit would never dwell with sin, it’s impossible.
Jesus Christ overcame sin and death and that means that sin has no hold over Born Again believers even though their bodies sin. Hence we have these Scriptures:
1 John 3:6 “Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not: whosoever sinneth hath not seen him, neither known him.”
This means you are either Born Again or you’re not Born Again.
1 John 3:9 “Whosoever is born of God doth not commit sin; for his seed remaineth in him: and he cannot sin, because he is born of God.”
Born Again believers are new creatures living in their body of sin. Our bodies are no longer us as we are new Spiritual beings. When we die the body will be gone forever.
Romans 7 For that which I do I allow not: for what I would, that do I not; but what I hate, that do I. 16 If then I do that which I would not, I consent unto the law that it is good. 17 Now then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me. 18 For I know that in me (that is, in my flesh,) dwelleth no good thing: for to will is present with me; but how to perform that which is good I find not. 19 For the good that I would I do not: but the evil which I would not, that I do. 20 Now if I do that I would not, it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.
Paul clearly tells us here that it no longer him who sins but his body and he tells us twice to help us understand. This in turn means that his body is no longer him!
“1 John 3:3 “And every man that hath this hope in him purifieth himself, even as he is pure.”
If we keep our hope in Jesus Christ we are as pure as He is, sin or no sin.
y2t
17. donsands
August 24, 2006
8:00 PM
2truth,
I agree that the power of sin is broken, and that we are no longer a slave to sin, but a slave to righteousness.
And yet the struggle is going to be intense for the genuine child of God. For those who are unsaved, the power of sin has them in it’s grip, and righteousness has no part of their life. they may even think they are spiritual, and have no problem with sin. The born again believer is no more dominated by sin, though we do have to contend with it daily. We need to die daily. And yet the sweet mercy of Christ has in fact taken each and everyone of our sins, and nailed them to the Cross! Hallelujah!
At the end of chapter 7 of Romans Paul says: “So then, with the mind I myself serve the law of God, but with the flesh the law of sin.”
With our mind we love Christ. And this is “I myself”. And with the flesh we love sin. This is “I myself”.
We are at the same time a sinner, and righteous.
This was a great post. I love listening to all the comments about LOTR. I read the books, and the films are incredible, though not as good of course, but excellent just the same.
I am amazed at how Gollum looks so real. It is astounding film making. I enjoy watching the scenes with Gollum the most.
18. Brian Thornton
August 24, 2006
9:47 PM
I knew I shouldn’t have read this post!
I have only made it through the first movie…planning to watch the other two in the near future…thanks for spoiling what is apparently one of the final major scenes in the last movie!
Oh well…I’m sure I will still enjoy them both.
It sounds like you have made a good analogy…though I would remind every true child of God that those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified the flesh with its passions and desires (Gal. 5:24).
But, though it has been nailed to the cross…it still continues to spit and hiss at us and tempt us until the day we die.
19. Randy
August 24, 2006
10:21 PM
I have lost track of the number of times I have seen all three of the extended versions of LOTR. I think Return of the King is the most exciting of the three, but I don’t know if any one of them could be called my favorite.
When these movies first came out, we as a family had a sort of mini tradition of going to the movies on Christmas day to see the new LOTR realease. Now days we must settle for such ordinary fare at the movies comparitively speaking.
20. pilgrim
August 24, 2006
10:25 PM
I was struck by the same thing when I finally watched them all recently. (I think I soread it out over a week—it was kind of like a mini series)
We do hang onto what destroys us.
Some well made and visually stunning movies.
21. Mike
August 24, 2006
11:13 PM
Certainly the One Ring represents sin, but what sin? What is the power of the ring? Understanding that sheds light on the spiritual struggle that takes place throughout the book, including the temptations of Boromir, Gandalf, Galadriel, Faramir, and even Sam. The allure of the Ring is our desire to be lord, to control our own destiny, and to dominate all others and subject them to our will.
Gollum’s fate was sealed on the stairs of Cirith Ungol, a moment that Tolkien deeply regretted. In one moment, any hope for his salvation was destroyed. The plot involving Shelob, the attack at the base of Mt Doom, and the battle in the Cracks of Doom were the result of what happened earlier.
BTW, Gollum fell while rejoicing, not fighting.
IMO, the greatest travesty of the movie was the failure to include “The Scouring of The Shire,” where we see Frodo, Sam, Merry, and Pippin fulfill Eru’s purpose for including them in the Fellowship. Boys became men; Englishmen emerged from their isolation.
Yes, Sam is the central figure, as Tolkien says in his letters. And the central theme is not power, as it first seems, but actually death.
The Silmarillion and The Lord of the Rings are two remarkable Christian works. The real world, i.e., the spiritual, is demonstrated to be the unseen, moving force and power behind all that transpires.
22. Sara
August 25, 2006
10:45 AM
Insightful post. For me, the most compelling scene is in the Twin Towers where Gollum is fighting with himself to be Frodo’s friend. He believes Frodo to a good and kind master, but his other self argues that Frodo is bad. When Gollum yells that he doesn’t need his other self, the other self seems to go away and Gollum thinks he’s won. In reality the power of the ring is far greater and it waits for the opportunity to come back and tell more lies. The opportunity comes when Gollum believes Frodo was hurting him rather than saving him when the men captured Sam and Frodo.
It makes me think of time when I’ve had to take my soul to task and remind myself of God’s goodness and kindness. It also reminds me that sin is always waiting and crouching for the opportunity to dishonor God and doubt his goodness. I need to be prepared to expect those battles and be ready for them with the Word of God.
Sara
23. GWilly
August 25, 2006
11:47 AM
Brian,
Sorry you won’t be as surprised. You will still enjoy the movies, I’d bet. Btw, do you think you could ship me an FO, some rings, and a Chili Burger from the Varsity on Jimmy Carter?
“My precious” has been, and in some ways still is, illicit sex. I never believed in premarital sex, but I did it anyway. Since I’ve been a believer, I’ve known that porn, allowing my mind to wander about past or potential liasons, or allowing my eyes to dwell on a woman or image, are slow ways of destroying my “soul” and hardening my heart. I know in my head that true life is found in obedience, and that obedience can be obtained thru faith in Christ, but still the allure of sex is sooo strong. Why does a clean dog love to roll in vomit or guts? It’s just his nature. Thank God the new nature of Christ is being infused into us. Part of me longs for the time when the infusion will be complete, part of me still longs for the temporary thrill of what I know I should not have.
24. The Aspiring Theologian
August 25, 2006
12:41 PM
Very good post. I always thought it was interesting how Frodo goes through an entire journey intending to destroy the temptation of the ring, but when he finally has the chance, he can’t. Even after he has seen what it will do to him (Gollum) and how evil it is (Sauron) and how it corrupts the noblest heros (Boromir), he still gives in. Such is the power of sin. We can’t defeat it on our own - we need God’s help.
25. Tim Challies
August 31, 2006
10:06 AM
Because of a whole lot of off-topic discussion, most of which I’ve erased, this topic is now locked.