I do not read a lot of fiction. Of the titles I receive, I read only a small number since most do not interest me. Still, when a book looks as good as Germ looks (the cover is really catchy!), when the description mentions that the author's previous book (Comes a Horseman) is being made into a major motion picture and when the current book had six Hollywood producers bidding on it before it was even completed, I thought it might be worth reading. The book promises to have "white knuckle intensity" and to be a "mesmerizing roller-coaster."
The book is based around three "facts," which may or may not be true. First, since 1962, all industrialized nations routinely administer the Guthrie test to their newborns. In the test, a sample is drawn from the baby's heel to check for certain genetic diseases. Second, most of these cards, which contain identifying DNA, are stored in warehouses and never destroyed. Third, with the advent of gene splicing, scientists are capable of encoding viruses with human DNA. This gives viruses--germs--the ability to find specific DNA, specific people. You know, people like you. And so the book tells a tale of a scientist who has created a ghastly disease that seeks out only specific people based on their DNA. The motive is never made perfectly clear, but seems to be world domination. What else would we expect, really?
There are some books that rely on clever twists and intricately woven plots. There are others that rely simply on brute force. Sadly, Germ is a book that relies heavily, and perhaps almost exclusively, on brute force. Whenever the story begins to slow down, the reader should not expect something surprising or clever to happen. Rather, he should expect blood, gore and splatter. The same scenes play themselves out time and again. This is a book that relies on implausibility - one man having access to the DNA of nearly the entire population of the United States, both government and non-government agencies having near-omniscience, and men and women able to withstand ridiculous amounts of injury and pain. It relies on computers that can hack into any database in the world, of people being able to pass unnoticed through high security and people easily being able to track others anywhere in the world. It is, of course, fiction, so the author can take whatever liberties he likes. But for a book that is positioned as "could be true," this goes beyond implausible into the realm of ridiculous.
Frantically paced and filled with gratuitous blood, gore and violence, Germ was intense, but also intensely annoying. While it begins with a bang, it ends with barely a whisper. By the end of the book I only wanted the story to end rather than having to endure another chase, another shooting, another round of bloodshed, another person disappearing into "a chunky mist of red and black" as he is blown away by a machine gun. It all got so tiresome, so over-the-top.



Comments (6) »
1. Jane
December 16, 2006
11:50 PM
Tim, Germ sounds awful. I just returned this very evening from viewing Apocalypto, the latest movie by that so called racist actor and director, Mel Gibson. An anti Semite he may be, but the man knows how to make a movie. The film captured the complete and undivided attention of both my husband and myself from beginning to end. Bloody and violent? Yep, sure is. Totally absorbing and entertaining? Yep, sure is. It features zero actors I’m aware of ever having seen before. The cinamatography is exquisite. I would even like to see it again so I can pick out all the beautifully crafted detail I’m sure I missed while gripping my arm rests and being caught up in this tale of a young couple thrust into an horrific adventure in an ancient society. Two thumbs up.
Jane
2. lisa4given
December 17, 2006
3:36 PM
Freaky Sci-Fi Pinky and the Brain spin-off? but obviously too bloody and so not funny.
Sounds like you would have been better off baking gingerbread cookies and decorating them with your neighbors.
3. Leslie
December 17, 2006
4:05 PM
“Frantically paced and filled with gratuitous blood, gore and violence, Germ was intense,”
explains
“the current book had six Hollywood producers bidding on it before it was even completed”
4. francisco
December 17, 2006
5:55 PM
“Frantically paced and filled with gratuitous blood, gore and violence, Germ was intense,”
the quick way to become rich in this world?
5. Ann
December 18, 2006
10:20 AM
Tim, thanks for reviewing another fictional book. I love the genre, but am glad to know what not to waste my time on! Reading the first part of your review, it sounded Crichton “esk.” …reminding me slightly of “Prey” which I really enjoyed. But. I can do without all the gore you describe in “Germ.” And, I love complicated story twists. Thanks for the review; I’ll skip that one.
Have you seen “The Nativity” yet? I’m waiting for your review… from what I’ve heard, it sounds like the story is told well enough, but I’m hoping it is not “sappy” by trying cheap shots for tears.
Ann
6. Tim Challies
December 18, 2006
1:00 PM
“Have you seen “The Nativity” yet? I’m waiting for your review… from what I’ve heard, it sounds like the story is told well enough, but I’m hoping it is not “sappy” by trying cheap shots for tears.”
Not yet. I really do need to get out and see it, but I have trouble blocking off that amount of time. And next time I see a movie it will probably be “Charlotte’s Web” with my kids!
Post Your Comment Here »