Book Review - Meet the Puritans
Through the past few decades there has been a great resurgence of interest in the Puritans. This resurgence seems to have begun with Martin Lloyd-Jones who would often refer to their works in his sermons. People would then ask “Where can I get these books?” Banner of Truth began to reprint the books and soon other publishers began as well. Today there are so many available to us that few people could afford to buy or shelve even a fraction of them. This choice has led to confusion as many people, intrigued by what they have heard about the Puritans, hardly know where to begin in reading them. Into this void step Joel Beeke and Randall Pederson with their new book Meet the Puritans.
Meet the Puritans is a resource designed to guide people through the reprints of Puritan writings that have been produced since 1956. The book provides “a brief biography of each Puritan author whose works have been reprinted since 1956 and a short review of those books. We hope this will help purchasers of Puritan books, interest other readers in the Puritans, and guide those already immersed in Puritan literature to further depths of study.” It is more a reference book than one you would be likely to read from cover-to-cover, though if you wanted to, you certainly could.
The format of the book is simple. After a Preface explaining how to profit from reading the Puritans, a brief word about where to begin and a brief history of English Puritanism, there comes a long list of authors. Each author has his own chapter containing a short biography and a list of his books that have been reprinted. There is a review of each book along with publishing information and the number of pages. And that is the heart of the book and continues for some 800 pages. Five appendices deal with collections of Puritan writings, Scottish divines, Dutch further Reformation divines, secondary sources on the Puritans and a final word on Puritanism courtesy of J.I. Packer. In short, this is a one-stop-shop for all you could want to know as a beginner to the Puritans. And if you are already a fan of their writing, this book will lead you further and deeper, guiding you to the best books available.
One thing I would like to see in future editions of this book is a more thorough list of the best place to begin in reading the Puritans. The authors do offer a few suggestions, but they are only basic ones. I’d like to see a list of the top ten or twenty books they would recommend. Additionally, it might be nice to have a topical index of sorts, pointing to the best works on a variety of subjects so that a person looking for a Puritan work on worship or sin or other important topics could quickly and easily find the best resources.
Quite simply, if you are interesting in reading the Puritans, this is a guide you won’t want to be without! It is endorsed by a who’s who of Reformed leaders and authors (the back cover alone has endorsements by Sproul, Piper, MacArthur, Packer and Mohler and there are many more inside!) and deservedly so. Best of all, it promises to be a book that will be updated as time goes on and as these great writings continue to be released.
You can get it at Monergism Books.




Comments (15) »
1. Esau
March 22, 2007
10:52 AM
Tim,
Tony addressed this yesterday, neatly enough, with an article by Joel Beeke that contains exactly the information you were looking for, namely - a nice list of places to start for the overwhelmed novice.
http://spurgeon.wordpress.com/2007/03/21/joel-beeke-why-read-puritans/
E.
2. theophilus
March 22, 2007
11:11 AM
Tim, this is a great resource. Thanks for reviewing it so that others will know about it and attain it. I have it and have used it often.
My only complaint: Some prominent Puritans who have had works reprinted within the last two decades are not to be found (for example, Edmund Calamy and William Greenhill). I’m not sure why they were omitted, but I would like to see them included in the next edition.
3. Tim Challies
March 22, 2007
11:12 AM
Esau,
What Tony posted was basically the introduction to the book. This information is available in the book and, as I said in the review, I wish there was more information about where to begin with the Puritans. It’s not a big complaint, of course…
4. Tony
March 22, 2007
12:05 PM
Hey guys! An excellent topical index of Puritan works appears in the appendix of Reformed Confessions Harmonized by Beeke and Ferguson (Baker). And if you check out my blog and especially the Puritan Study Series, I outline some of the most helpful and useful Puritan resources that may be a great place to start. Also there is another excellent topical index to the Puritan sermons in A Guide to the Puritans by Robert Martin (Banner of Truth). Beeke is currently converting his massive and near-exhaustive topical index into digital format but probably wont be completed for a few years. Martin’s will work well until Beeke’s is complete and published. Martin’s topical index is helpful in showing which Puritans emphasized specific areas of study (prayer, meditation, evangelism, etc.) and will give you a good idea which Puritans will best suit your interests. Also, I’m currently being interviewed by Joshua Sowin on books and reading and you’ll find other helpful information to your Puritan questions when this is complete. Check out my blog Monday for a link.
Blessings!
Tony
5. KC Armstrong
March 22, 2007
2:20 PM
Thanks, Tony, for mentioning Robert Martin’s compilation A Guide to the Puritans.
For those interested, you may access it here.
6. Scott Hughes
March 22, 2007
4:49 PM
I remember reading a lot about Puritans in school. I never read this book, though. Thanks for the review!
You might like the Book & Reading Forums.
7. lisa4given
March 22, 2007
6:53 PM
Books my boys brought back for me from the Ligonier conference are the 2 volume series by James Anderson called Memorable Women of the Puritan Times”
I am looking forward to reading them.
8. Mark
March 22, 2007
7:11 PM
Puritan scholar Dr. Matthew McMahon’s website, www.apuritansmind.com, is an excellent resource and provides a starter list along the lines of that which Tim requests in his post.
9. Armen
March 22, 2007
10:28 PM
I agree with Mark above. However, I also think that this book is an excellent idea, especially when there is so much rubbish lining the bookshelves of Christian book stores. This book will hopefully, and refreshingly, point people in a profitable direction.
10. Steve Burlew
March 23, 2007
12:37 PM
Tim - This book is definitely on my shelf (except for all of the times when I’m using it!); I say “ditto” to what you’ve put here. It is excellent, even though it doesn’t have a Banner of Truth logo on its spine! ;-) Based on the comments here, I think I’ll touch base with Sinclair F. and a few others, see what they think would be the top 10 books by Puritan authors that a Puritan-newbie should be steered toward. We’ll see how it stacks up with yours, Tony! Stay close, guys. Steve B. (@ The Banner)
11. Ed
March 24, 2007
7:30 PM
Please forgive me for being so naive, but I fail to fully understand what all of the commotion is about these writings. The couple that I have read have left me unimpressed as far as applying to anything remotely resembling my life. I realize that I am very ignorant of a lot of things, but it seems to me that since the “Puritans” seem to have died out or at least dwindled (hence the use of terms such as “resurgence” or “rekindled interest”), there must have been reasons. What I read came across very much works-sanctification if not works-salvation. I just can’t seem to get enthused about them yet … while I can learn from them and they have good things to say on occasion, so does just about every other historical Christian group. While perhaps misapplying slightly, the “old wineskins” of puritanism may not fit well the “new wine” of the church in the 21st century - and I’m not talking about Osteen, seeker-sensitivity, or anything like that. But we are not called to be “Puritans” - but Christians …
12. Mark
March 25, 2007
10:22 PM
Ed,
A question: which Puritan(s) did you read? I could go on at length about how Jeremiah Burroughs has often convicted me of grumbling and lack of trust, John Flavel has helped me better understand the glorious sovereignty of a great God, and Thomas Wilcox has caused Christ to shine more greatly in my eyes. Certainly Puritanism has little truck with pragmatism, so if you’re looking primarily for ‘what works’ then don’t look at the Puritans. But if you’re looking for ‘what is true’ then you can do a lot worse than the Puritans. And ‘what is true’ is what works in us towards our sanctification, which is of ultimate value.
13. Tony
March 26, 2007
12:07 PM
Mark, isn’t it amazing that our ancient religion is confirmed through every generation that struggles with sin and clings to the Cross! Same sins, same struggles, same Cross. The brotherhood of all generations around the unchanging Word is encouraging. -Tony
14. Tim Challies
March 26, 2007
12:20 PM
“Please forgive me for being so naive, but I fail to fully understand what all of the commotion is about these writings.”
I guess we tend to speak of the Puritan writings as if they were all good, but there are plenty of bad ones out there. A guide like this will help you find the ones that are worth reading and the ones that are most helpful to the soul. I’m sure there were as many bad books in those days as there are in ours. Fortunately many of the bad ones have not stood the test of time (just as most of the books in your Christian bookstore will never be heard of again ten years from now).
15. James
March 26, 2007
6:18 PM
At the back of Don Kistler’s little booklet “Why Read the Puritans Today?” there is a list of 10 books for beginners that may be helpful.