Welcome to the online home of Tim Challies, blogger, author and web designer. My first book, "The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment," is now available everywhere.

Read about the blog or about the author.

Wednesday August 16, 2006

Shepherding A Child’s Heart

There are many things in life that are easy to do poorly but are much more difficult to do with excellence. It did not take me long as a parent to discover that it would not be difficult to raise children, but that it would be exceedingly difficult to do it with excellence. In the six years since my eldest child was born I have looked often for help and advice in becoming an excellent parent. Unfortunately my wife and I have received little mentorship in this area. Thankfully, there are many books written about this topic so we have often looked to these resources to provide the wisdom and training we know we need.

Shepherding A Child’s Heart by Tedd Tripp came to us highly recommended. In fact, I can’t think of a book on this topic that was recommended to us more often. It is a book that deals with speaking to the very heart of your children. Realizing that too many parents react only to symptoms of underlying sin, Tripp attempts to help parents look deeper, to see that all the things a child says and does flow from the heart, for as Luke 6:45 says, “…out of the overflow of the heart the mouth speaks.” If a parent can understand a child’s heart and shepherd that heart, he can deal most effectively with a child’s deepest needs. And through it all he seeks to keep the gospel central to a parent’s calling and to a child’s response.

The book is divided into two parts. In the first, Tripp lays the foundation for biblical childrearing. He shows that the heart of bad behavior is a sinful heart. He discusses a child’s development, showing that a child is shaped by various influences on his life and that a parent needs to help a child have a Godward orientation. He discusses authority and suggests that, despite our culture’s disgust towards authority, a parent must assert himself as being in a position of God-given authority over a child. A child must realize that parents speak not of their own authority, but of God’s. He also discusses goals, methods, communication and discipline.

Where the first part of the book lays a foundation, the second part guides a parent through shepherding a child through three stages of development: infancy, childhood and teenagers. For each of these periods he suggests the training objectives and then procedures a parent should use to attain these objectives.

A section I found particularly interesting, perhaps because I have young children, was the section dealing with punishment. Tripp advocates spanking as really the only biblical method of punishment (and certainly the only one that is specifically mandated by Scripture) for correcting young children. He lays out very clear circumstances in which children should be spanked and suggests many circumstances in which parents must not spank. He makes this type of corporal punishment very deliberate and very loving. He suggests that parents must be fully in control of themselves when they spank and must not be filled with anger. Parents do not punish their children out of anger, embarrassment or retribution, but to teach children that defying authority will bring about consequences. Children must know that God demands obedience to authority and that there are consequences for defiance.

In his endorsement of this book Edward Welch wrote, “Dr. Tripp’s material on parenting is clearest, most biblically framed, and most helpful that I have ever encountered. It has become the backbone of my own parenting.” I agree entirely. Throughout the book Tripp focuses on Scripture and on the gospel. He focuses on human nature and on the grace of God in providing a solution to the needs of our children. I would not hesitate to recommend this book to any parent, and especially to new parents. Read it now, pray about it, and let God direct you to His ways of shepherding the hearts of your children.

Amazon

Comments (27) »


1. Georges Larabie
August 16, 2006
10:31 AM

Hi, thanks for the post. My wife and I have just started reading the book ourselves (french version!). We were anxious too find something biblical and properly balanced.

We have followed Gary Ezzo’s, Raising kids God’s way, and have been greatly dissapointed and even quite surprised by some (most) off the stuff that’s in there. I do not reccomend it. I was talking about this with our church board last night. I mentioned to them that I believe we need to stop using GFI (Garry Ezzo) in the local church and look for something biblical and better. One of the books I mentioned to them was this one by Ted Tripp.

I am looking forward to reading it as we are also in the beginning of the learning process (3 year old boy, 1 year old daughter, and a baby boy coming in the next week or so!).

Anyhow, thanks for the post and the encouragement.

Georges


2. Paul Martin
August 16, 2006
11:11 AM

We had a similar experience to Georges with the Ezzo material. While much of it was of practical help, there seemed to be a large “missing link.” That link was, in my opinion, the Gospel.
Where Tripp’s book was so very helpful to us was in teaching us how to apply the doctrine of total inability (depravity) and sovereign grace to a child. Children need to be shown God’s standard and when they violate it. But the best part of parenting is pointing them to Jesus who is the solution to this failure (sin)!
That little point was extremely life-changing for us. We went from creating Pharisees to preaching Jesus.
Not that our parenting is perfect (“excellent”) or that our kids are the best on the planet, but as far as having a plan with what to do with the time they are under our roof, we were thrilled by Tedd’s book.
I would add that what the brother writes, he lives.
Reading this little book will reap big fruit in your family.


3. Steven
August 16, 2006
12:01 PM

Thanks for the tip on the book. I heard Kirk Cameron heartily endorse it the other day, so its good to hear another fellow out there. I will consider checking it out. My firstborn, Simon, and my next child, due in February, could possibly benefit. In Christ, Steven

(Thanks for your honest blogs-with clarity and thought)


4. Mark Tubbs
August 16, 2006
12:59 PM

I’m so glad there is a continuing discourse on Christian parenting and a hunger to parent biblically and Christ-centeredly (if that is actually a word!).

Having raised a child using the Ezzo’s material, and having just brought our second child into the world, I would clarify a couple of things. By the way, I am also a huge advocate of “Shepherding.”

Firstly, there are enough anti-Ezzo forums on the Internet - I don’t think the reflections on Tim’s entry needed to delve into that area. That said, I don’t need to defend the Ezzos. What I will attempt to do is clarify how the Ezzo’s published material is categorised, as far as I know:

The “Babywise” books are the secular versions of the “Along the Way” series. The former stresses methods and practice, while the latter marries methods and practice to biblical underpinnings. In fact, before we ever used or had heard of “Preparation for Parenting” or “Growing Kids God’s Way,” a pastor friend of mine dropped off the tape series at my house, saying that our church (Reformed) might “go in for this kind of stuff.” He was referring to how “Preparation for Parenting” begins with the doctrine of original sin and proceeds to apply it to parenting. That’s just one example of how biblical the Ezzos are. Tedd Tripp focuses on correction, and how that is needed! But the Ezzos, from their background in theology and nursing, give more attention to some of the practical aspects of childrearing. Both books are fruit, but apples and oranges!


5. Jeri
August 16, 2006
1:20 PM

This book was also very helpful in my family, Tim. When I read it I had three grown children already and one just nine years old, but it is helpful in so many ways even if your children are grown! At the same time that I ordered Shepherding a Child’s Heart, I also bought A Heart Of Anger: Practical Help for the Prevention and Cure of Anger in Children by Lou Priolo. The title resonated with me and sure enough, it was a great book to read at the same time as Shepherding, a great book if there is any anger in your home. Might as well tell you about one more that I bought at the same time, (I ordered all these from Shepherd’s Press) it is titled “Come Back, Barbara” by C. John Miller and is the true story of a rebellious daughter and broken-hearted parents, and what God did for their family.


6. Tom
August 16, 2006
1:38 PM

My wife and I have likewise read and utilized the truths in this book for our kiddos (now 10 and 7).

I would also highly recommend Tedd’s brother’s book, Age of Opportunity: A Biblical Guide to Parenting Teens. Paul David Tripp’s Age of Opportunity is a wonderful companion book worth considering.

Blessings!

Tom
Doctrine Matters


7. Aaron S. Wilson
August 16, 2006
2:09 PM

I’ll also contribute my own gratitude for Tripp’s work (his brother, Paul David, had some great stuff too!).

My wife & I read most of this book together 6 years ago as we anticipated the birth of our first child. We also got to hear Tedd Tripp give his “Shepherding” conference at our church soon after.
I’m currently re-reading through much of this book and I’ve forgotten just how much of my parenting practices were actually shaped by Tripp’s book & conference back then! We still use the same suggested procedure for administering discipline to our children, such as - never doing so in anger, making sure they’re aware of the sin they’ve committed, hugging & loving them immediately after the spanking…etc.

In fact, that reminds me of a question I asked Dr. Tripp during the conference when I first heard of this “crazy” :o) idea of hugging on your children right after you spank them. I asked, “Won’t this confuse them…you know, giving discipline and then turning right around and loving on them?” Well, you can probably guess his response! (It was a kind and gentle answer) It was then that I realized that discipline is a means of love toward our children (Hebrews 12:3-11).

I’m in the same boat as all of you - my parenting is far from perfect - but it’s encouraging to see the Lord’s faithfulness to our family as we truly seek to shepherd the hearts of our quiver of 4. I can say that some of the sweetest times with our children is during times of discipline, when forgiveness is generous and the gospel is shared.

Excuse my rambling, and thanks for the reminder of this great book!

Oh, one other thought - Tim, I’m curious as to your thoughts on spanking in light of current efforts to outlaw it (isn’t Canada still considering it?) Perhaps that’s another post! :o)


8. Katie
August 16, 2006
2:26 PM

What do you think about the books “Grace-Based Parenting” by Tim Kimmel and “Sacred Parenting” by Gary Thomas? My husband and I are getting ready to be parents, and are wondering which ones to read besides Tripp’s book…


9. Georges Larabie
August 16, 2006
2:32 PM

Katie,

I’m not familiar with Grace-Based Parenting or Sacred Parenting but another good read for parenting that my wife and I have appreciated is John MacArthur’s, Successful Christian Parenting.

Georges


10. mike
August 16, 2006
5:09 PM

GREAT BOOK! The parents of school aged children in our church went through Shepherding A Child’s Heart two or three years ago. It is the best out there.

If any readers are in the Glen Rose area (60 miles sw of Fort Worth Tx), I would like to invite you to our church this saturday. We are having a parenting conference featuring John Younts who is the author of “Everyday Talk”. This is another great book written from a reformed perspective.
For more information check out our web site at http://www.gccministries.org/


11. Mark Fox
August 16, 2006
5:58 PM

Thanks for the good recommendation Tim. I ummed and ahhhed about posting but thought I will - just wanting to clarify some thoughts on the Ezzos that have been mentioned.

I am one of those kids who has been on both sides of the fence when it comes to the Ezzo material and teachings. My parents came across it and when they applied the principles our family turned around. Mum and dad ended up teaching it. Now I am a father twice over (second born on Tuesday!) and Jay and I have decided to bring up our children using not only GKGW methods but also any others that we find useful. We are also teaching it. Tedd’s book is one of those. In fact the Ezzos will say quite often both in their videos and in their introductions to their books say that they are not the ‘be all and end all’ of parenting techniques and encourage those taking the course to look not only vertically at God but also horizontally at others. I’ll finish with one particular comment from one of the participant’s in our course who had done the first three course (Prep for Parenting, Prep for Toddler Years and GKGW) who said that he has never come across material more consistent, Christian and free flowing in any of his studies.

The second; as Mark Tubbs said earlier, the Babywise, Toddlerwise, Childwise etc series is written from a secular point of view, while the actual courses they have written are the Biblical basis of it.

Sorry about the length, but I wanted to clarify that the Ezzo’s do say look around at other parenting resources (Tedd’s book IS excellent and complements the Ezzo’s), and that there are two sets of materials that the Ezzo’s have written - one secular and one for the Christian community. Check out www.ezzotruth.com and www.gfi.org for more.


12. dprocket
August 16, 2006
6:27 PM

After reading this review, I noticed that it sounds very similar to a book in my library (which I have not yet read) called “Parenting is Heart Work”. Has anyone read this book and how does it compare? Thanks.


13. 4ever4given
August 16, 2006
8:52 PM

Louis Priolo also has a good one called “Teach Them Diligently: How To Use The Scriptures In Child Training.


14. Lynn
August 16, 2006
10:02 PM

I second 4ever4given’s recommendation of Lou Priolo’s book “Teach Them Diligently: How to Use the Scriptures in Child Training.”

I think it’s better than “Shepherding a Child’s Heart,” although that was a good book too. I think Teach Them…….actually gives concrete examples of how to apply Scripture.

You can get Priolo’s book here at Amazon:

http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/1889032204/sr=8-1/qid=1155780074/ref=pd_bbs_1/104-1295890-6571134?ie=UTF8


15. 4ever4given
August 16, 2006
10:12 PM

The Heart of Anger by Lou Priolo, John MacArthur, and Jay E. Adams is an excellent book if you have a child that deals with anger issues. I have found this to be helpful with our adopted children.


16. julie
August 17, 2006
7:11 AM

It is a great book. We have 3 children and we never have a copy! I keep giving it away to other parents and I’ve lost count of how many times we’ve bought it. It certainly changes the whole way you look at parenting and gets down to the real issues we should be dealing with. Thanks for recommending such a great resource.


17. Drew
August 17, 2006
7:15 AM

Props for mentioning “Everyday Talk” by Younts - excellent. This and another book (whose name escapes me) are very helpful, and they build off the foundation of Tripp’s book. My one regret over “Shepherding a Child’s Heart” is on the application side. It helps the parent make a philosophy change, but a lot of my friends needed a little more info to understand what such thinking looks like in real life.


18. Joe
August 17, 2006
8:02 AM

Sadly, I was one of the world’s poorest parents. If I had had me as a father, I would have shot myself (either me the father or me the kid).

In spite of me, my children grew into fine, God honoring people.

God’s a better Father than I was.


19. TulipGirl
August 17, 2006
8:35 PM

Tim, I bet you were just waiting for me to show up here. *grin* Knew I couldn’t stay away…


While I agree with Mark that a Challies post on SACH isn’t the place to go into great discussion about Gary Ezzo’s teachings, I believe it is important not to let this statement stand without providing another viewpoint:

“…saying that our church (Reformed) might “go in for this kind of stuff.” He was referring to how “Preparation for Parenting” begins with the doctrine of original sin and proceeds to apply it to parenting. That’s just one example of how biblical the Ezzos are…”

The sloppy Biblical hermeneutics is one of the key issues people have with Ezzo’s parenting teachings. An example of this can be found in Dr. Kent McClain’s review of GKGW. An article published by the Christian Research Institute included discussions of the problems with Ezzo’s theological confusion and emphasis on extrabiblical revelation. And you might find this short course on hermeutics, which uses examples from Ezzo’s teaching, to be interesting as well.

Aside from that… I want to address the idea that Ezzo’s teachings are compatible with Reformed theology—which they are not. Now, there are dear and wonderful Reformed families who may have implemented Ezzo’s ideas to some extent, but his teachings have flaws that are disturbing to those coming from a Reformed perspective. Writings from this website, for example Ezzo and Calvinism, provide some food for thought in how Ezzo’s teachings and Reformed theology are not in sync.


Pastor John MacArthur and the elders of GCC even issued a public statement undergirding concerns related to Ezzo’s teachings and Reformed theology, “A corresponding effect of the stress on non-biblical issues is that important biblical issues, particularly the doctrine of depravity and the child’s need for regeneration, do not, in our opinion, receive sufficient emphasis. When the doctrine of human depravity is dealt with, it is sometimes handled in a confusing fashion.”


And not just a Reformed perspective, but those throughout the broader Church community have voiced concerns about whether these materials are truly as Biblical as the author asserts them to be.

Even Tedd Tripp has commented on Ezzo, “I think the big difference between Shepherding a Child’s Heart and the Ezzo’s material is that they are much more concerned with controlling and constraining behavior, whereas I am far more concerned with the heart issues that push and pull behavior. Prov 4:23.

Not wanting to hijack Tim’s blog, I’m instead going to invite anyone interested in discussing the nuances of helpful and harmful in Ezzo’s teachings to AwareParent.Net.


20. Mark Tubbs
August 18, 2006
1:50 AM

Hmmm…simply let me say that I am concerned that Post #19 links to some (not all, but some) slanderous and gossiping webpages. I clicked on them because the aforementioned post had specifically responded to my Post #4 and I would simply warn readers to think before they click…

Redundantly and reluctantly I will quote myself:
“there are enough anti-Ezzo forums on the Internet - I don’t think the reflections on Tim’s entry needed to delve into that area.”

That’s all from me.


21. Todd
August 18, 2006
7:35 AM

Tulipgirl?
Does that make me acronymboy?

The above mentioned book is a useful tool.God’s Spirit, and His wisdom teach us what to take and what to leave.

Its good to see people still hold to sound doctrine.

Solo gratia, solo fide, sola Christos!!!

Todd


22. Tiffany Johnson
August 18, 2006
8:52 PM

Has anybody read “Don’t Make Me Count To Three” by Ginger Plowman? Her book (by her own admission) takes “Shepherding a Child’s Heart” principles and expounds on them. Written by a mom, this book is fun to read and very biblical and PRACTICAL. I too, have desired more mentoring in parenting, and this is one book that has helped alot. It’s a great complement to many of the books listed above.

Another very practical tool for using scripture in training kids is “For Instruction In Righteousness” by Pam Forster. She itemizes sin problems that children face and lists appopriate scripture passages and applications for each one. This is a great reference tool to grab when you need to quickly remember scriptures to teach your kids with.


23. Tiffany Johnson
August 18, 2006
9:00 PM

PS-If you are interested in “Don’t Make Me Count to Three” and would like to read a review by my husband, click on the link below. I think he also has reviewed almost all of the other books mentioned above, on his site. It might be helpful to you if you want to get a bit more info on these books before picking the first to buy.

http://completeinchrist.net/DontMakeMeCounttoThreeAMomsLookatHeartOrientedDiscipline.html


24. forgiven_grl
August 19, 2006
9:04 AM

I would recommend George Barna’s book “Transforming Children Into Spiritual Chapians”. I am not a parent yet but I am in the Christian book industry and that one is HIGHLY recommended!

:)
Kelly


25. forgiven_grl
August 19, 2006
9:12 AM

Oups… the book is called “Transforming Children Into Spiritual Champions”

See below…

http://www.mitchellfamilybooks.com/MFB/Browse/Product.aspx?Catalog=BK&ProductID=0830732942Catalog=BK&ProductID=0830732942


26. 4ever4given
August 19, 2006
6:40 PM

I want to gently caution the readers on the recommendation of the “Transforming Children into Spiritual Champions” book.

The author of the book is George Barna and he is the founding leader of the Barna Research Group. THis is a marketing research firm that has provided research for churches, parachurch ministries, non-profit organization and for-profit businesses. Another book he has written is called “User Friendly Churches.”


27. Virginia Youmans
August 23, 2006
3:07 AM

Thank you for this excellent review of Shepherding a Child’s Heart. I have found this book to be very Biblical and practical. It is helpful to us as we attempt to shepherd our children, with God’s help, through this life to the next.

Ginny
http://ReformingMinds.com