Christmas Music Favorites
Every now and again I get concerned that people are going to think this blog is getting too commercialized—that I keep trying to sell you things. I’m not into blogging for that. But sometimes it’s fun to talk about things like this, so bear with me. Today I’m going to talk about Christmas music and offer up some suggestions.
A few of my favorite blogs have been offering Christmas music suggestions. I don’t think lists of favorites get much more eclectic than those for Christmas music. After all, there are so many available that people can search far and wide and far across genres to make their picks. David’s picks range from The Master’s College Choral to Nat King Cole. Zach’s picks are surprisingly mainstream for Zach (and include, to my great surprise, selections by both Michael W. Smith and Amy Grant). He also goes with Harry Connick Jr., Charlie Brown, and Kevin Max.
I am not a big fan of Sufjan Stevens and his rather weird music, but I do think his Christmas set Songs for Christmas (42 songs across 5 EPs) is an amazing set and one you probably haven’t heard before. He sings plenty of the traditional songs interspersed with some of his own. Songs like “I Saw Three Ships” (disc 2), “Once in David’s Royal City” (disc 2) and “The Friendly Beasts” (disc 3) are done very, very well. With five albums recorded over five years, there is something for everyone on these CDs. I love ‘em! The set comes with “a 42-page booklet with an original Christmas essay by acclaimed American novelist Ricky Moody, two essays, a short story by Stevens, a holiday sticker, chord charts, lyrics, comic strip, family portrait poster, photos, and an animated video.”
Christmas Songs is the latest album by Jars of Clay and one that showed up just in time for Christmas. The guys, who are among the most talented musicians in all of Christian music, provide fourteen songs, some of which are classics and some of which are originals.
Savior: Celebrating the Mystery of God Become Man was released last year by Sovereign Grace Ministries. You’ve probably seen ads for it running on this site. It offers twelve original songs by Bob Kauflin, Mark Altrogge, and the other Sovereign Grace musicians.
City on a Hill: It’s Christmas is an entry in the City on a Hill series and one that brings some Christmas favorites and a few originals by bands like Caedmon’s Call, Jars Of Clay, Third Day and Sixpence None The Richer.
If you’re in the mood for some lighter fare, Relient K’s Let it Snow Baby, Let it Reindeer is kind of fun. It has seventeen songs, some of which are the typical holiday favorites and some of which are Matt Theissen’s typical Relient K tunes. At the very least, it’s a fun album to listen to! If you bought 2003’s Deck the Halls, Bruise Your Hand you’ve already got half the songs. If you like that, you may also enjoy the Gloria EP by Hawk Nelson.
Of course it’s not Christmas if you don’t listen to at least one Trans-Siberian Orchestra album at least once. I’m kind of partial towards The Lost Christmas Eve. And you’ll need to listen to Handel’s Messiah at least one time as well. Better yet, read it and keep a Bible handy as you do so.
Those are my picks. What are your favorite Christmas albums?




Comments (33) »
1. Zach Nielsen
November 23, 2007
3:06 PM
Yeah Tim, I was thinking the same thing that you said about my list, but though I don’t listen to Amy Grant and MWS anymore at all, I was raised on them when I was a kid, thus Christmas being a time for traditions I found those hard to shake. I’ll stand by the MWS record more than Amy, but for some reason that Christmas record is tied to so many good memories that I couldn’t leave it off.
I would add the Sovereign grace CD as well. Great disc and production for indie musicians and production. They did a great job with that one.
2. Matthew Dalton
November 23, 2007
3:08 PM
Andrew Peterson’s “Behold the Lamb of God” is by far the best Christmas album I’ve ever heard. It tells the story of redemption from Exodus on. Check it out. You will not regret it.
You can find it at:www.andrew-peterson.com
3. brandon hoops
November 23, 2007
3:09 PM
One that has been a delight for me recently is Over the Rhine’s “The Darkest Night of the Year.” It’s not a conventional Christmas album, but their music isn’t conventional. If anything, it’s beautiful, inspiring, refreshing. Check it out.
4. Mrs. T.
November 23, 2007
3:17 PM
The best Christmas album I own is Bebo Norman’s newest, “Christmas: From the Realms of Glory.” It’s just about as perfect as an album can get.
For pure cheese factor, I’ve always loved Dean Martin’s “Making Spirits Bright.” When I’m feeling down in the middle of summer, I pull it out for a pick-me-up! It’s full of classics, delivered as only Dean could sing them.
5. Anna
November 23, 2007
3:22 PM
Chris Rice has a beautiful instrumental Christmas album called “The Living Room Sessions: Christmas.” Very peaceful and nostalgic.
6. Dave @ Banannery Public
November 23, 2007
3:25 PM
Here’s my favorite.
7. Eric
November 23, 2007
3:31 PM
Sufjan is my fav. Everyone, you must check out Sufjan. http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=4221164594405566437&q=sufjan+austin&total=30&start=0&num=10&so=0&type=search&plindex=3
If you can’t handle the wings, just close your eyes and listen.
8. Tim Challies
November 23, 2007
3:34 PM
If you can’t handle the wings, just close your eyes and listen.
I may try wearing wings next time I do a speaking engagement…
9. dt
November 23, 2007
4:30 PM
Andrew Peterson’s “Behold the Lamb of God” is by far the best Christmas album I’ve ever heard. It tells the story of redemption from Exodus on. Check it out. You will not regret it.
I have to second that one. Great CD, both lyrically (all the songs are Christ-centered and focused on the story of redemption), and musically (similar to what you hear from Caedmon’s Call or Derek Webb). Besides, how can you not like a CD that features a song taken from the first 17 verses of Matthew?
10. Tim Challies
November 23, 2007
4:34 PM
Andrew Peterson’s “Behold the Lamb of God” is by far the best Christmas album I’ve ever heard. It tells the story of redemption from Exodus on. Check it out. You will not regret it.
Sounds like a great one. I absolutely loved his previous one (“Love & Thunder”).
11. David
November 23, 2007
5:13 PM
One of my favorites is a lesser know album by Don Hejny called “Unto us a Child is Born.” You can listen to the whole album on his web site, which is a great resource if you are trying to actually spend less during the holidays! http://www.donhejny.com/
12. bchallies
November 23, 2007
5:25 PM
Showing my age, Tim - I vote for golden oldies - ‘Noel’ by King’s College Choir, ‘Christmas Carol’ by James Galway, and ‘Christmas Oratorio’ by Bach!
13. Brian @ voiceofthesheep
November 23, 2007
5:55 PM
Great suggestions, Tim! I needed some new music for this time of year. Now I only hope I get enough iTunes gift cards for Christmas to allow me to cover all of these great new albums. You are absolutely right, everyone should listen to Handel’s Messiah at least once this Christmas.
I must be honest and admit that two of my favorites are Harry Connick’s When My Heart Finds Christmas, and Mariah Carey’s Merry Christmas.
14. Reg Schofield
November 23, 2007
8:32 PM
I love Christmas music and in fact its not uncommon fro me to listen to some in July!!! I know I’m crazy!! But anyway here are a few of mine. The Charlie Brown Christmas Album , I just love its cool jazz theme . Bing Crosby , no one does White Christmas like Bing ,Steven Curtis Chapmans Christmas albums , I don’t think anyone in Contemporary Christian music can touch this guys song writing craft and the warmth on his Christmas cd’s are what I love, The Kings Choir form Cambridge , I love well done choral music and they are amazing and for newest entry , Bebo Normans , it is excellent … there are many more but like I said I love Christmas music….RWS
15. Tim Challies
November 23, 2007
9:06 PM
Now I only hope I get enough iTunes gift cards for Christmas to allow me to cover all of these great new albums
Along with Amazon gift certificates, I think these are among the best gifts you can get these days! :)
16. cameo
November 23, 2007
9:43 PM
suprised no one has mentioned Phil Spector’s Christmas album…definitely the most essential christmas record…
17. Pat Boettner
November 23, 2007
10:37 PM
If I were on a desert island ANY time of year, I would take this Christmas CD with me. It is called Gaudete (The natural state of man is JOY) and is put out by Soli Deo Gloria Cantorum, SDG Records Absolutely SUBLIME choral peformance. It is glorious.
18. Pat Boetttner
November 23, 2007
10:41 PM
The most glorious Christmas CD I own is a sublime choral performance entitled Gaudete - The natural state of man is JOY. Performed by Soli Deo Gloria Cantorum/ Almeda Berkey - Music Director for SDG Records. It is simply glorious.
19. Kyle
November 23, 2007
10:44 PM
I listen to Christmas Music all year long. It’s my absolute favorite music. Here are my picks:
Big Band Christmas, by The Chris McDonald Orchestra Big Band Christmas Swing, by The Chris McDonald Orchestra A Christmas Album, by James Taylor and Dave Grusin Savior, by Sovereign Grace Ministries Fresh Aire Christmas, by Manneheim Steamroller An A Capella Christmas, by GLAD Christmas Caravan, by Squirrel Nut Zippers Messiah!, by Georg Frederic Handel
And Dave@BananaRepublic, thanks for your contribution. That particular rendition of “O Holy NIght” has been a part of my annual holiday celebrations since 2002.
Kyle
20. Kyle
November 23, 2007
10:47 PM
Not sure why the format of my previous comment is so spectacularly jacked up. Sorry if you can’t read it.
21. stephen cavness
November 23, 2007
11:06 PM
Andrew Peterson’s “Behold the Lamb of God” is by far the best Christmas album I’ve ever heard. It tells the story of redemption from Exodus on. Check it out. You will not regret it.
You can find it at:www.andrew-peterson.com
before starting seminary and then becoming a pastor, i used to play music for a living in nashville. i even opened for derek webb a couple of times. i say that only to make a point that as much music as i have been exposed to (christian or “music not sold in christian markets” music), andrew peterson’s “behold the lamb of god” is by far one of the most amazing albums i have ever heard in my life and would be on my desert island list no doubt. and it is not a collection of christmas ‘favorites”, it is all original material written by andrew himself. the best song you have never heard is “labor of love” from this album. the theology is sharp, the music is heart wrenching, and the lyrics themselves are some of the best songwriting i have ever heard. and not just a few of the songs.. the whole album is a work of literary art. (appearing on the album with peterson are such artists as derek webb, sandra mccracken, andrew osenga, randall goodgame, jill phillips, among others)
every music loving believer needs this album. it will make you listen to “christmas music” all year long because you can’t get enough of it.
22. Greg Denney
November 23, 2007
11:48 PM
My all-time favorite Christmas album is Michael Card’s “The Promise.”
“Of course it’s not Christmas if you don’t listen to at least one Trans-Siberian Orchestra album at least once.”
Though I play and enjoy tons of different music, I must admit that TSO makes me go running, screaming into the night… just my $.02
23. Michael Clark
November 24, 2007
9:19 AM
I love so much Christmas music, but the memories of Vince Guaraldi’s Charlie Brown Christmas top my list. I also run several Internet radio stations that play only Christmas music year round. http://www.christmasmusic247.com
Tim, your comment form doesn’t work on Safari 2, OS X 10.4.10.
24. Shannon
November 24, 2007
9:53 AM
I also have to recommend Andrew Peterson’s Behold the Lamb of God! If you are able to see the concert….it is incredible! I would even say, get the DVD and make it your annual Christmas Eve tradition…yes, it is THAT good!
I can’t wait to hear what you have to say about it after hearing it :)
25. John Jordan
November 24, 2007
9:57 AM
I was so disappointed to not see Andrew Peterson’s “Behold the Lamb of God” not on the list. It is so good, I can barely listen to any other CD without disappointment during the season. Tim you need to get this CD immediately! O.K., the Sovereign Grace one is good too.
26. Peter Bogert
November 24, 2007
10:12 AM
I enjoy this time of year, studying in my office with a Yankee Candle burning and Christmas music on. I find Paul Jones (10th Pres in Philly) CHRISTMAS IMPROMPTU a nice background. As much as New Age can rhyme with sewage, some of the Windhall Hill Winter Solstice series is great too.
27. Carol Blair
November 24, 2007
10:18 AM
For those who love traditional Christmas music:
“Songs of Angels, Christmas Hymns and Carols,” by the Robert Shaw Chamber Singers. Telarc, 1994; CD-80377. The Robert Shaw Chorale (alas! no longer in existence; Mr. Shaw died in 1999) will always be the “gold standard” of choral music. The RS Chamber Singers is a group of about 60, culled from the chorale, that put together this totally a cappella selection of 29 hymns and carols. The baritone soloist is unforgettable—especially in “Good King Wenceslas.” Available at Amazon.com
“A Festival of Carols,” by the Robert Shaw Chorale and Orchestra. RCA, 1987, BMG Music, 6429-2-RG. Recorded in 1957 and 1963. Fifteen selections; some are medleys. Most selections have the full orchestra accompaniment; a few are a cappella. My favorite is “We Three Kings,” which features the men of the chorale, and they sing all 5 verses—rarely found or heard anymore. The verses of this carol explain the significance of the gifts of the Wise Men: gold (for a King), frankincense (for a god [God]), and myrrh (a burial spice). Available at Amazon.com
“Joy to the World”: Eugene Ormandy and the Philadelphia Orchestra and Chorus. RCA, 1987, BMG Music, 6430-2-RG. Nineteen selections; concludes with two selections from Messiah: “Pastoral Symphony” and the “Hallelujah Chorus.” Available at Amazon.com
“King of Glory”: A Men’s Choral Christmas Celebration by the SMS (Sacred Music Services) Chorus. 16 selections; some virtually unknown to us today. My favorite is “Lo, How a Rose E’er Blooming.” The second verse begins, “Isaiah t’was foretold it …” — the only mention that I know of, of a Bible book in sacred song. Their website is smsrecordings.com, where they offer many other recordings of traditional sacred music.
Carol Blair Longview, TX
28. Mark@DR
November 24, 2007
10:46 AM
At the risk of sounding shallow in light of previously-mentioned favourites, one of the best-produced Christmas albums I’ve heard in awhile is Peter Cetera’s “Just Gotta Love Christmas.” Bargain-basement price @ CDUniverse.
29. Dustin Battles
November 24, 2007
12:31 PM
Another good traditional/conservative Christmas CD for those who like it:
Long Time Ago by Steve Pettit Evangelistic Team http://www.sacredaudio.com/productinfo.php?productsid=409
Very folkish in nature. Lot of acoustic guitar, violin, banjo, pennywhistle. Very enjoyable CD. I recommend the “Pettit Team” and all of their CDs which are excellent. spea.org
30. Joel
November 24, 2007
2:15 PM
My sole (well, almost) loyalty is still to Handel. Much to my wife’s annoyance.
31. Jeri
November 24, 2007
9:11 PM
This is a very helpful post at Christmas time, with great additions by commenters. I’ve bought several of the cd’s recommended…thanks Tim and others! (The Andrew Peterson cd is every bit as good as claimed.) Merry Christmas!
32. Elizabeth
November 24, 2007
10:50 PM
Like others have recommended, Andrew Peter’s “Behold the Lamb of God” is amazing. I saw it in concert in 2005 and bought the cd right away. It has since become my all-time favorite Christmas cd.
Another good one is “Your King Has Come,” featuring Derek Webb. Andrew Osenga, Sandra McCracken and a host of others. You can hear decent-sized clips from the cd at www.yourkinghascome.com
33. Justin
November 26, 2007
4:55 PM
Holiday! by Crystal Lewis with a jazz trio.