Welcome to the online home of Tim Challies, blogger, author and web designer. My first book, "The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment," is now available everywhere.

Read about the blog or about the author.

Friday December 8, 2006
15 Comments

Friday Ramblings

I feel I should apologize about the relatively low quality of the articles I've posted this week. I decided to take a week's "sabbatical" to focus on writing the book. I thought of calling this a vacation, but that didn't seem quite right. In the end I settled on sabbatical since I like the sound of the word and since it makes me feel very professional. I wish I had had the opportunity to take more than a week, but this is about all I can reasonably fit in with the volume of clients and web sites I am dealing with now.

I have never dedicated a complete week to writing before and must say that, on the whole, I really enjoyed it. There have been moments of frustration, but I really have enjoyed myself and am looking forward to taking another week in the near future. In fact, I think I could gladly write all day every day and be perfectly happy doing so. Unfortunately I have not found a way of paying the bills doing that. Maybe in the future! Of course if you are filthy rich and would like to sponsor me to do so, I'm all ears!

But seriously, thanks to all of those who have been praying regularly for my labors on this book. I've said so before, but please know that these prayers are making a difference and I am grateful for them. If you are wondering about the book's progress, here is a very brief update. Essentially I have until March 1 to write some 60,000 to 80,000 words (which should bring the book in at between 150 and 200 pages). I don't quite know what will happen if I don't submit the manuscript on the agreed-upon date, but I assume it will involve Justin Taylor (or another Crossway employee) flying up to Canada with a bullwhip and a baseball bat. As per the statistics below, I am probably heading towards the mid-way point of my writing if we are to measure purely in quantity. I feel the quality of the book still leaves a lot to be desired, but my approach to this point has been mostly to plot out and expand upon ideas. Later sweeps through the book will refine the quality, writing style, and so on. I've never been told how to write a book and have not had opportunity to confer with any previously-published authors to learn from them, so I am really just making this up as I go! I assume this is what most authors do their first time around.

So here are where things stand at this very moment:

dod_update.jpg

Manliness is not Godliness

A reader sent me an article that appeared yesterday in the L.A. Times. It sure seems that the media is expressing a growing interest in the general weirdness of evangelicalism. There have been multitudes of articles in recent months dealing with all that is wrong with Christianity and a lot less dealing with what is right! This article, entitled "Manliness is next to godliness," deals with "GodMen" and other movements seeking to recapture a masculine Christianity. "Stine's daylong revival meeting, which he calls "GodMen," is cruder than most. But it's built around the same theory as the other experimental forums: Traditional church worship is emasculating."

Hold hands with strangers? Sing love songs to Jesus? No wonder pews across America hold far more women than men, Stine says. Factor in the pressure to be a "Christian nice guy" -- no cussing, no confrontation, in tune with the wife's emotions -- and it's amazing men keep the faith at all.

Cue up the GodMen house band, which opens the revival with a thrashing challenge to good boys:

*
Forget the yin and the yang
I'll take the boom and the bang...
Don't need in touch with my feminine side!
All I want is my testosterone high.
*

This is all part of a movement, which I have seen through the multitudes of books I receive from publishers, to capture a picture of Jesus that is distinctly masculine. And, of course, Jesus was masculine. The image of Jesus that arose from the middle ages and that has seemed to stick around is what guys like Mark Driscoll are preaching against. As Driscoll says, "It's hard to worship a guy who you can beat up." But this new movement goes to far.

"'Jesus was a very bad Christian,' [Paul] Coughlin declares. After all, he says, the Son of God trashed a temple and even used profanity -- or the New Testament equivalent -- when he called Herod 'that fox.'" Uh huh. Coughlin wrote a book called No More Christian Nice Guy in which he tried to convince men to stop being prissy. A noble goal, but one that doesn't necessarily require a cussing Jesus.

And so these conferences encourage men to head into the wilderness (though not necessarily to talk about their "father wounds" with John Eldredge) and to act like real men. And apparently real men swear. "Stine, a born-again Christian, shouts that it's OK to cuss -- and then demonstrates with a defiant 'bull....'"

So whatever happened to meekness and humility? These were traits Jesus valued and exemplified. Somehow it seems that these men's movements, these virility crusades, confuse masculine with obnoxious. Cussing doesn't make anyone more masculine. More obnoxious? Yes. More masculine? No. More godly? Certainly not. This movement, like so many before it, seems premised on the idea that God is most pleased with us when we act most in accord with our desires, as if God desires authenticity more than godliness and submission to His Word. From what I see in Scripture, this simply isn't the case.

You can read the article here.

And Finally, A Video

I don't know how I missed this (actually, I do. Bob, would you fix your RSS feed already!) but Bob Kauflin posted the video of the George W. Bush impersonator who appeared at the WorshipGod06 Conference. Here is what Bob said about it:

Last August at the WorshipGod06 conference, I wanted to welcome Irish singer/songwriters Keith and Kristyn Getty to the conference in a special way. If you didn't know, Keith and Kristyn write theologically rich, musically appealing contemporary hymns for the church, and are good friends. So, I got in touch with John Morgan, a guitarist in the Sovereign Grace church in Orlando and also a professional George W. Bush impersonator. I asked if he would introduce the Getty's at the conference and he was kind enough to say yes. This video was taken the night he welcomed them. He did such a good job that I received a letter from one attendee wrote me to say how thrilled they were to finally see George W. Bush in person. They were serious.

However, this video isn't. Enjoy.

Here it is for your viewing pleasure. And in case you're interested, this is John Morgan's site.

And just like that, I am going to get back to my book. I trust you will enjoy your Friday and look forward to spending a weekend to the glory of God.

Comments (15) »


1. Bibliomaniac
December 8, 2006
10:43 AM

Tim…if you miss your book deadline, you’ll be surprised at how compassionate we editors can be. If it’s any encouragement, though, I doubt you’ll miss it by much (if at all). Anyone who has the discipline to blog every day has the discipline necessary to finish a book in a timely manner.


2. Brian at voiceofthesheep
December 8, 2006
10:49 AM

I saw that “Bush” video a few days ago…it was hilarious.


3. David
December 8, 2006
11:22 AM

Love your title.


4. Tim Challies
December 8, 2006
11:52 AM

“Love your title.”

Thought you would! ;)


5. donsands
December 8, 2006
11:53 AM

Blessings on your book.

Brad Stine said at the end of the article he will be softening the GodMen thing that he’s doing. I pray he does, for he is so out of balance, he resembles the world more than the kingdom of heaven.
Another case of not being Scripturally rounded out.

Man, that guy is President Bush! Thanks for sharing that. Very uplifting.


6. Bill Burns
December 8, 2006
12:16 PM

This GodMen thing (which I’ve yet to encounter out here in the hinterlands of Missouri & Kansas), appears to just be another rehash of the “Muscular Christianity” movement, about which there are a number of books available. It seems to recur every few years or so.

Its most notable legacies are the creation of the sports of basketball & volleyball (thanks, YMCA), and a fair amount of roller-coaster preaching on manliness vs. sensitivity in males.

I know there was an article in a past issue of The Mars Hill Audio Journal a year or two back (www.marshillaudio.org), but searching their site turned up nothing. But I did manage to find an article on the subject located here. Don’t know much about the host site, though, so be advised it’s not necessarily a Christian-run site.

http://www.infed.org/christianeducation/muscular_christianity.htm


7. lisa4given
December 8, 2006
12:59 PM

I needed a good laugh!!! Hilarious video.


8. Brendt
December 8, 2006
3:04 PM

re Manliness: Kinda disappointing to hear that about Stine. He’s a pretty funny comedian. What I’ve seen of his comedy is occasionally a bit brusque, but I kinda put him in the same category as Driscoll — “I wouldn’t have said/done that in that way, but it’s not wrong”.

Ken Graves, IMHO, has the manliness thing in proper balance. As I wrote about him:

… he speaks with equal reverence and admiration for the Jesus who wielded a whip to drive the moneychangers from the temple and the Jesus who wept over Jerusalem.


I link that, not as a traffic generator for my blog, but because of my admiration for Pastor Ken.


9. WES
December 8, 2006
3:26 PM

1246 cokes and your writing a book on discernment?


10. Morris Brooks
December 8, 2006
4:34 PM

Wild at Heart is another one of the take offs on the manly christian issue, and is way off in its protrayal of both God and men.


11. Mike Perrigoue
December 8, 2006
8:44 PM

That’s about 19.5 words per Coke. Nice.


12. Doug Mitchell
December 9, 2006
1:57 PM

I’ve heard good things about Stine in the past from good men I trust. I am also reluctant to use the LA Times as an authority on things Christian.

That said, do not discount this movement. There is something significant happening with many men in the church. My sympathies, stated previously, are with W@H and Eldredge. The path of heart change for some men will be lasting and have a permanent impact. If it continues, the church will be a more welcoming place for the unchurched man. That unchurched man, now in relationship with his Father, will be a beacon for generations who come behind him.

Movements such as PK and what is written above tend to flounder on the rocks of shallowness and become fads. The argument about JEs theological correctness will continue, I’m sure, but I have experienced and seen for myself the changed lives of men, who will influence their families for generations.

Any ministry to men that leads them only to their base instincts, (even though those instincts were created in them) without pointing them to the Savior and their proper purpose is only scratching the surface, and its lack of depth will be its undoing.

Those who read Morris and Eldredge and only see the controversy of redefining “church” or the need for casual adventure miss the point. Hate to see this stuff dismissed as all part of the same movement, but I suppose that is unavoidable, even in learned circles.


13. Josh
December 9, 2006
3:42 PM

It’s not Coke its finger fuel. Type on Tim, Type on!

Josh
“…the word of God is not bound.”
—2 Timothy 2:9


14. Daniel Devine
December 10, 2006
5:54 PM

I don’t at all think the premise of the masculinity movement—at least what I’ve seen of it—is based on feeding all of our manly inner desires. If it were it would be promoted by carnal men and rejected by godly men and women, which is not what I’ve experienced. I’ve seen the opposite.

Godliness and submission to the Word involves another thing: stark obedience. This, ultimately, is what gives the masculinity movement fuel. Godly obedience isn’t sitting in your reserved spot on the pew each week, writing the offering plate check, and dropping the kids off at school and making sure your wife has gas to get to her Bible Study. Godly obedience isn’t making sure your kids get to Sunday School on time or graciously allowing your wife to lead family prayers and devotions. Obedience is turning off the TV, getting up off your duff and leading your family the way God expects you to—loving your wife, teaching her and the children theology, looking out for their well-being. It’s about fearlessly laying down your life (whether in the short-term or long-term) for the sake of the gospel and the church. If there’s a reason we need a masculinity movement, that’s the reason. Can the American church survive another generation of male church members who are given no spiritual responsibility?

Please forgive my preachiness, everbody. Great site you have here, Tim!


15. shelah
December 12, 2006
8:55 AM

is this “men” in the plural form or is this book specifically for men? just curious… hope its going well. (and have you ever tried gummy bears? We used to buy them in 5 pound bags for exam prep…)


Post Your Comment Here »