"The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment is a truly important work-one that should be required reading not only for church leaders, but for all sober-minded laypeople as well."

John MacArthur (From the Foreword)

"If you were more discerning you’d probably buy this book. If you do read this book, you will be! This book on discernment is simple, clear, well-written and well-illustrated...

Mark Dever

Welcome to the online home of Tim Challies, blogger, author and web designer. My first book, "The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment," is now available everywhere.

Read about the book, about the blog or about the author.

03/03/06
Comments (7)

Seminar 5 - Carey Hardy - How To Raise a Pharisee

This morning finds us at the fifth and final seminar. I have chosen to attend one led by Carey Hardy, which he has entitled How to Raise a Pharisee: Avoiding legalism in the home.� Carey is senior executive pastor at Grace Church and an adjunct professor at The Master�s College and Seminary.

The pharisees were the original legalists. �Pharisees� means �separated ones� and this is something in which they took great pride. They separated themselves both literally and figuratively and really did believe that their priorities were close to the heart of God. They desired to live out God�s Word, protect it and propagate it. They desperately wanted to protect God�s Word and did this by adding to it and building fences about it. These �helpful additions� soon became absolutely essential so that God�s laws were no longer enough. They developed another 365 rules that were passed orally from generation to generation. This law eventually became more important to them than the Law of God.

We have pharisees today. There are some who add their own rules and regulations and come to believe that these are equal to the Word of God. Legalists take away personal responsibility for thinking and living by conscience. They create rules and then judge themselves and others by them. Jesus described these men as yeast and leaven, because the yeast of the pharisees was hypocrisy. There was confusion that they caused among the people about what God wanted and expected. It is just as easy for a believer today to be confused by these spreading gangrene of legalism.

There is not a problem in traditions or local distinctions. But there is something wrong when we present personal preferences as eternal truth. So we have the pharisees who are judgmental, prideful and hypocritical.

Hardy has taken notice of practices that, if practiced, will produce pharisees. This is a twelve-step program to increase the probability of raising a pharisee. They all relate to one another and sometimes the line of distinction is not entirely clear.

  1. Majoring on external instead of internal issues: The Jews were thinking externally about the Law of God and Christ began to change their thinking to show that God is interested in the heart - in the inside. Parents need to avoid focusing only on the external without providing biblical exhortation and foundation. Adherence to external regulations in the home cannot be equated with a saving knowledge of Jesus Christ. Parents can be deluded into thinking their children are saved simply by seeing external conformity in their lives. Apparent change on the outside does not necessarily indicate true, lasting internal change.
  2. Excessive control: This points to the lack of balance between discipline and instruction. There may be too many rules or restrictions or rules that are pointless, harsh, too strict. �There are some parents who are walking minus signs.� This involves excessive control in attempting to micro-manage a family, telling a child everything he can and cannot do. We need to find ways of saying �yes� to our children and allowing them to pursue their dreams and interests. Enter into their world and don�t be so quick to point out how impossible or illogical something is. �Make your first response positive.� Be known as somebody who will listen and this means you need to think long-term. Fads come and go, so don�t get too concerned about every fad that comes and go with your child. Many parents become overly controlling on issues of preference and then never allow their children to make decisions on their own.
  3. Over-reacting to failure: That includes not allowing the freedom to fail. You�re treating failure as if it�s the end of the world. Maximizing instead of minimizing it. Failure is an amazing opportunity for teaching. It is the children�s failures that provide the best opportunities to share the gospel and provide the most teachable moments. Over-reacting to failure is performance-based love. Perfectionism - expecting perfection from our children - is not a good thing. It is not the same as the pursuit of excellence.
  4. Being unforgiving: This is that grouchy, irritable parent, frustrated over everything that goes wrong, who creates an oppressive, negative atmosphere in the home. There is no visible end to the consequences for sinful choices. Sin must be dealt with, but there has to be an end to the consequences. An unforgiving parent does not want to end the consequences but wants to remain grumpy and mean. �Deal with the issue, and be over it.� We have to teach what forgiveness looks like. The home is where encouragement and support needs to flourish. If you refuse to forgive your children, you are teaching them to be unforgiving.
  5. Elevating preference over biblical principles: Some parents may emphasize personal preferences over what the Bible clearly teaches. A child is expected to obey a house rule (for example, when a child is to do homework or when he may have a snack), but these are not to be confused with Scriptural truth. We need rules based on preference, but do not try to make your child believe that these are biblical rules. Admit that we are doing these things because this is the way dad and mom want to do it.
  6. Unnecessary separatism: This has become a huge problem with many homeschooling families. Hardy homeschooled his children when they were young, so he loves and affirms homeschooling. But he dislikes when some people attempt to make a biblical case for homeschooling but there is not one. What he has seen is some families pulling away from other families because the parents do not want their children associating with children who are not homeschooling. But separatism is no guarantee that children will grow to respect their parents or love the Lord. Children must be involved with other children for this is important to their development. Parents need to exercise some care and discernment in allowing their children to be around others, but it is important that they learn how to relate to other children. We must also be careful to interact with people within our neighborhoods and make sure that we are not so separatistic that we ignore the mission fields in our own neighborhoods.
  7. Judging others: (especially other families). Be judgmental about the things that are going on at church: roast a pastor for Sunday lunch. A constant rain of criticism will develop a judgmental spirit in them. You usually judge others by your personal convictions and preferences rather than Scripture.
  8. Being a fighter (or being belligerent): To this kind of parent, every issue is a fighting issue. Every issue is worth fighting for in church, home and the world. Kids are taught what to fight against, but not what they fight for. They are known for being only negative.
  9. Showing favoritism: (of one child or another child). It shows that a parent only likes to spend time with people who are like them. These leads back to separatism. When you prefer one child over another, you harm them both.
  10. No humor: You could also say, �no fun.� A parent needs to know how not to take himself so seriously, and sometimes not to take things in the world so seriously. �Let your hair down.� We need to teach our children to have a good sense of humor, but not crass humor. We need to make the home a place that is fun and where the children like to be.
  11. Building up their self-esteem: Nowhere in the Bible do you find the issue of self-esteem which is a worldly, psychological concept. Nowhere are you taught to love yourself. Our problem is that we love ourselves too much! This encourages children to focus on self and to build-up self. In encourages selfishness. We also need to avoid modeling a self-focus and we may do this by believing that our children exist primarily to make us happy. Finally, don�t use your child to bring glory to yourself.
  12. A lack of genuine spirituality yourself: Living hypocritically teaches hypocrisy. There has to be some level of pursuing Christ that they see in the parents. Our children should see us reading the Bible and praying in our quiet times. They should see and know the genuineness of our faith. Legalism in your life is a cheap substitute for spirituality

As a final exhortation, Hardy challenged us to keep parenting simple. Discipline children when they disobey and give them lots of love. Live life with and before your children.

Seminar 5 - Carey Hardy - How To Raise a Pharisee

Comments (7) »


1. OBUTiger99
March 3, 2006
4:46 PM

As the father of one 8 month old daughter, this is wonderful advice. I have been so apprehensive over the last several months over the issue of being a good father. The final exhoration to keep it simple— discipline for disobedience and give lots of love— is great. Thanks for blogging the conference.


2. Sara
March 3, 2006
5:05 PM

It’s good to hear someone come out and say something against teaching our Christian children “self esteem.” I am always having to fight this point amongst Christians more than any other issue. The church has bought this one hook, line and sinker. I am so glad to hear someone else saying the same words I find myself repeating time and again, “Our problem is that we love ourselves too much.”


3. Davey
March 3, 2006
7:36 PM

Amen to that, Sara. Last time I brought that up to a church youth leader (where we used to be) I was met with a blank stare and a total dismissal of the issue.

It is an issue some people buy into because the world and, sadly, many churchs accept without question.

And it’s totally unbiblical.


4. GL
March 3, 2006
10:28 PM

Fascinating. Thanks, Tim, for writing this up.

How was this received? Do you surmise that there might a perception by Handy or other leaders that some of the attendees live contra this message?

The sociologist in me notices what leaders of a group think their following needs to hear. In PCA circles I hear exhortations to abandon idols of perfectionism, success, materialism, respect. Sometimes to be evangelistic, not just concerned with doctrine.

In other circles where I’ve attended retreats or conferences I heard exhortations to surrender their hearts to the Lord, to be pious.

I wonder (in a speculative, purely wondering way) if Handy or others perceive some of their following to have a problem with legalism like PCA leaders perceive their folks have a problem with worshipping success.


5. DLE
March 3, 2006
11:41 PM

A good list.

I blogged last Autumn about the fact that homeschooling is used as a bludgeon sometimes in Christian circles; I caught a lot of flack from people who said that never happens. Glad to see that someone else feels this way, too.

What is more interesting about this list is how it might be applied beyond raising children. What if you applied this list to how we should relate to unbelievers? What about to our brithers and sisters in Christ? Or our spouses?

For example, when we relate to unbelievers, how many times do we focus on externals rather than internals, on the way people dress or the music they listen to? How often is the Church known for its negative responses rather than its positive ones? Or on the issue of control, how do some churches press the control issue with their congregants? The possible applications here to the rest of life are very interesting.

Just something to think about.


6. Hope
March 6, 2006
5:02 PM

I wish I could have read something like this when I was raising my kids. Realistically though, I probably wouldn’t have really heard what you were saying. I was so sure that separation and teaching certain things would guarantee right behaviour. Wrong, wrong, wrong!


7. sean
July 9, 2006
1:26 AM

Hi, I am a musician who has been impacted by Keith Green and I would be honored if you would check out my music, all music is free to download. I just wanted to share my music with People who love Jesus. www.SeanDietrich.com

I don’t want to be a pest, so if this really annoys you, please delete it and accept my humble apology.

Thanks so much, -Sean

www.SeanDietrich.com “All my music is free.”