And There Was Great Rejoicing...
Yesterday afternoon I put the finishing touches on my book and sent it off to the publisher, one day ahead of my April 1 deadline. I had assumed that I would feel a great sense of relief after doing this but was surprised to find that my reaction was one of fear, wondering whether what I sent was in any way good enough or worthy of being published. This is probably pride rearing its ugly head. Thankfully I had little time for such worries as Aileen had asked a bunch of our friends over to celebrate. We had a good evening together before going our separate ways in order to watch the hockey game (it was, after all, a Saturday night near the end of the season).
This book has been the fruit of many years of study followed by nearly a year of writing. The book comes at a time that spiritual discernment is rarely emphasized in the church but also at a time that there seems to be a revival of interest in the subject matter. Unfortunately, very few books on this topic have been written and most of the ones that have are no longer in print. It has been a thrill to work with Crossway to attempt to fill this void.
I also sent the manuscript to potential endorsers, many of whom are among my modern day heroes of the faith. I am honored that these people would consider reading the manuscript and hope they prove willing and able to provide endorsements for it. There is something both humbling and terrifying about sending the unedited manuscript to these people!
Here is a short summary of the book:
The Discipline of Discernment turns to the Bible to seek what God teaches on the subject of spiritual discernment, a term I define as the skill of understanding and applying God’s Word with the purpose of separating truth from error and right from wrong. Written for the general reader and in a way that is suitable for a wide audience, the book teaches people to think biblically so they might act biblically. It provides a call for discernment, teaching the importance of this discipline in guarding the deposit God has entrusted to us. It leads the reader from the challenges they will face as discerning Christians to the Bible’s pattern for discernment, focusing on 1 Thessalonians 5:21-22 which reads “Test everything; hold fast what is good. Abstain from every form of evil.” It teaches what the Bible says about discernment in the context of the truth of God and the will of God, warns of the potential dangers that befall those who emphasize discernment and discusses discernment in the context of spiritual gifts. It is thorough, while not exhaustive, and seeks always to focus on the Word of God.
The ten chapters fall in this order:
- A Call to Discernment
- The Challenge of Discernment
- Defining Discernment
- The Heart of Discernment
- Truth and Discernment
- The Will and Discernment
- The Gift of Discernment
- The Dangers of Discernment
- Developing Discernment
- The Practice of Discernment

While I have been working on the book under the title of The Discipline of Discernment, I expect that it will soon have a new and better title. While this one does summarize the book’s contents, I’m not sure that it is the best choice from a marketing and thematic perspective.
I expect to receive the manuscript from my editor in seven or eight weeks. It will no doubt be covered in copious amounts of red ink. I will have a short period of time to make the necessary changes and corrections and, as I understand it, the publisher will then have the book typeset and I will then receive the proofs and make any final adjustments. After that we work out final details and it gets prepared for printing. At some point the publisher will work on cover art and page design. In the meantime, I will work on preparing a study guide. To this point I have written study questions but will attempt to write a more thorough expository-style guide that will be suitable for individual or group use.
The book is tentatively scheduled for release in January of 2008.
I’d like to thank those of you who read this site as in some ways it almost feels that this has been a community project. Without the interest in that web site this book would not have come about. I have enjoyed getting to know many of you either face-to-face or through email. I am indebted to you for your support, your input and your prayers. As you no doubt realized, there were several occasions that I used you as a testing ground for my ideas. I know this book is better because of your feedback. I hope it serves you and the wider church very well. I’d ask that you continue to pray for the book as the writing and editing process continues.




Comments (26) »
1. Neil
April 1, 2007
1:59 PM
Congratulations! I’m looking forward to reading it. Discernment is something the church desparately needs today.
2. Leslie
April 1, 2007
2:48 PM
Praise the Lord!! I am so excited for you, Tim! I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts regarding this project. I hope the Lord uses this to equip His people for the days ahead of us. Thanks for putting in the hard work of doing it and seeing it to it’s completion. I’m looking forward to reading and studying what you’ve put together with the Lord’s help.
3. Jabbok
April 1, 2007
3:52 PM
I had no doubt that you would meet your deadline and I have no doubts that your book will be well received.
Congratulations. Well done.
Tim
4. DavidR
April 1, 2007
4:08 PM
Tim wrote: “The book is tentatively scheduled for release in January of 2008.”
Wot?! Not on time for Christmas?!
;)
SHALOM! D.
5. rebecca
April 1, 2007
4:31 PM
I’m excited! I’m looking forward to reading the final results of your hard work and perseverance.
6. Dan S
April 1, 2007
4:55 PM
Congratulations, Tim. Will try to remember to keep for you praying on Fridays until the finished product is in my hands.
7. Jeri
April 1, 2007
5:10 PM
“While I have been working on the book under the title of The Discipline of Discernment, I expect that it will soon have a new and better title. While this one does summarize the book’s contents, I’m not sure that it is the best choice from a marketing and thematic perspective.”
I see your point in that. The folks you want to read the book might shy away from the title. It will be interesting to see what title you end up with.
Congratulations, Tim. Praise the Lord for His goodness in all this.
8. DavidR
April 1, 2007
6:27 PM
Tim wrote: “… I expect that it will soon have a new and better title”.
Just to save you time and trouble, here are a few sure fire winners:
The Discernment Driven Life
Everything You Wanted To Know About Discernment* (*but were afraid to ask)
Mild at Heart: The Romance of Discernment
Desiring Discernment
The Joy of Discernment
Go ahead. Take your pick.
:)
9. Jer
April 1, 2007
6:42 PM
Hey Tim, I’ve been lurking here for a couple months now and I’ve been encouraged and challenged by your blog (blogging daily is hard enough, blogging substance daily is much more difficult!). Congratulations on finishing your book, it’s a daunting task to any writer, and one that many only dream of and never actually set hands to.
Looking forward to picking up a copy (definitely a prime subject!), Jerry
10. David Fisher
April 1, 2007
7:54 PM
CONGRATULATIONS, Tim! I’m glad you stuck with this project. We will all benefit from your labour of love. Can’t wait to read the finished product. Thanks for your edifying presence in cyberspace, dear brother!
11. Alex Chediak
April 1, 2007
8:20 PM
Another title - and you need a subtitle, btw:
A Call to Discernment: Recovering a Neglected Discipline
12. NJC
April 1, 2007
10:44 PM
Let’s not forget Discernment and Jabez… that’s a surefire winner! I wasn’t sure whether to believe this initially, considering what date the post fell on, but I’m assuming it’s all true, and if so, shall be an interesting read indeed!
13. Blake
April 1, 2007
10:59 PM
aww shucks, Tim, there’s no need to thank us—we couldn’t have done it without you!
14. lisa4given
April 1, 2007
11:42 PM
I like the title. I hope they keep it.
15. Barb
April 2, 2007
1:02 AM
Congratulations, Tim. I enjoy your site and had told a friend about your blog. She just sent me a blog post from David at Pilgrim Scribblings congratulating you on sending your book to the publisher. Hope all goes ell with the book publication.
16. Jake Aharonian
April 2, 2007
1:05 AM
well done, Tim. I know the Lord will use your gifts for His great glory! I see the Sunday School classes swirling around this topic even now!
Jake
17. Karen
April 2, 2007
1:12 AM
I enjoy your website, and will look forward to getting the book when it comes out. It surely is a topic that needs attention. I was going to say “more attention” but most Christians are so lacking in discernment (or even knowledge of its importance) that it’s not so much a question of “more” but of “any”, in too many cases.
I hope all the things that are left to do, go smoothly and are not burdensome to you.
18. DavidR
April 2, 2007
3:29 AM
In #12 NJC wrote: “Let’s not forget Discernment and Jabez… that’s a surefire winner!”
My own take on this one was The Prayer of Challies but…. :)
Joking aside, I join in the prayers that Tim’s work, with its encouragement to turn to the Word, to “test everything, [and] hold fast what is good” will bless many.
David Reimer
19. Tim Challies
April 2, 2007
10:19 AM
Thanks to all of you for your support and encouragement. Any further title suggestions are more than welcome! :)
20. Kyle
April 2, 2007
10:35 AM
Here’s the title:
“Your Best Discernment Now.”
End of debate. ; )
Tim, I’m so pumped about reading this book. Not looking forward to the wait, but it will be worth it. We’re starting a young couples small group, and I’m going to insist that we go through your book together when it’s available.
Good work.
21. Blake
April 2, 2007
10:37 AM
What’s your middle initial, Tim? In fact, have you ever shared your middle name with us?? I think you will sound a little more austere and important if the author credit appears like this:
Discern or Die (or whatever title) by T. A. Challies
22. Josh
April 2, 2007
10:44 AM
Rejoicing indeed, and probably something like, “I’m never drinking a Coke again…
…at least until I write my next book.”
Josh “…the word of God is not bound.” —2 Timothy 2:9
23. DLE
April 2, 2007
11:33 AM
Congratulations, Tim!
Now comes the crazy part.
Yes, your manuscript will come back filled with red ink. It may even come back with some of the theology questioned. Be prepared to pull your hair out.
And yes, once the marketing department gets ahold of your title, chances are high they’ll try to pump it up to be more eye-catching. Get ready for a subtitle, as that’s all the rage right now. I wouldn’t be surprised if the current title becomes the subtitle.
24. Ren
April 2, 2007
11:45 AM
Just wanted to add my congratulations to the finishing of your book. I am also very much looking forward to reading it.
25. Jim Swindle
April 2, 2007
12:52 PM
I join in the others in congratulating you. I’m confident that the book will be worth reading. For the past few months, I’ve been increasingly realizing my need for discernment. I have more than before, but need to increase. You have amazing discernment for someone in your situation, so I look forward to your book. May the Lord use it in many lives.
26. Derek R. Iannelli-Smith
April 7, 2007
2:37 PM
Tim, I am looking forward to the release of your book. Up until now the only book on this topic was by Jay Adams, “A Call to Discernment” and like the other postings, I agree, a much needed topic in the church today. I am considering teaching a class on this topic in the future, and I would like to possibly include your text as a resource. Keep us posted on the publishing date!