The Unbearable Weight of Hell

Just thinking seriously about hell presses on my soul and presses upon my heart.

I find it difficult to think about hell. Though I know that hell is real and that God means for us to know at least something about it, I find it hard to read about it and to ponder it. I’m sure I’m not alone here. Randy Alcorn’s book Heaven has over 300,000 copies in print and there are another 200,000 Heaven-related products in print with it. I’m quite sure that he would have sold fewer than 3,000 had the book been titled Hell. Don Piper’s 90 Minutes in Heaven has sold millions of copies and has been on the New York Times list of bestsellers for months now where Bill Wiese’s 23 Minutes in Hell has not. We would far rather ponder heaven than hell. And for good reason, obviously.

It seems to me that a knowledge of heaven and of hell is innate in human nature. God has so wired us that we know there is life beyond the here and now. Ecclesiastes 3:11 says “[God] has put eternity into man’s heart” Every religion acknowledges something beyond, something outside of ourselves. There is something to come. But far more people acknowledge heaven than hell. While the majority of people believe there is a heaven and believe they will be there, very few believe in hell. Even fewer believe they will ever be in hell.

Even if people deny the innate knowledge of heaven and hell, our experience in this world it is harder to deny the experience of this world. John Blanchard says, quite brilliantly, “The judgments of God fall often enough in this world to let us know that God judges, but seldom enough to let us know that there must be a judgment to come.” We see God’s judgments in this world often enough to know that God does judge sin and that He is provoked against evil. Yet the scarcity of judgment shows us that there must be more. If God is a judge He must judge all sin, not just some sin. And so we know that more judgment is coming. It must come.

I recent received Edward Donnelly’s aptly-titled Biblical Teaching on the Doctrines of Heaven and Hell. The first half of the book discusses hell in all its fiery horror; the second part turns to heaven with all its beautiful glory. The first half is difficult to read and weighs heavily on the soul; the second is like a sip of cool water on a hot day. The first terrifies; the second elevates. Donnelly is not given to hyperbole or imagination. He does not present a fictionalized vision of hell that owes more to horror movies or medieval art and imaginings than to the Bible. Rather, he simply relates what the Bible tells us, both explicitly and implicitly, about this awful place. He does so under four alliterated headings: Absolute Poverty, Agonizing Pain, Angry Presence and Appalling Prospect.

The absolute poverty of hell is in its separation from God. All that people love and appreciate and enjoy in this life will be stripped away, not for a time but forever. Even all that makes you who you are will be destroyed. “You, as a being, will become ever more degraded, more contemptible, more lonely… Everything good in you will be taken away, and everything bad in you let loose. All your evil passions will burn, increasing and consuming you until you become utterly foul… Nothing good, nothing worthwhile, a horrible monotonous dreariness, unenlivened by a single ray of light as you fester and stew in your loathsomeness. This is what will happen to you.”

The agonizing pain of hell is the utter agony that will be in that place. “The undying worm is something foul, endlessly gnawing at hell’s inhabitants, eating at them continually, giving them no rest. This probably refers to conscience.” Imagine an eternity of a violated but re-sensitized conscience continually attacking, accusing and destroying. There will be weeping—an eternity of pouring out intense grief and anguish and intolerable misery. And there will be gnashing of teeth, perhaps a rage or insanity that will beset those in hell, and for good reason. And, of course, there will be unimaginable physical pain such that people will no doubt cry out for even the worst pain they knew in this life.

The angry presence is the presence not of Satan or of his minions, but of God. Many have been deluded into thinking that Satan will own and control hell, but the reality is that God’s is present in hell as much as He is in heaven. People in hell will spend an eternity in the presence of God, but in the presence of His just wrath against sin. “Here is the ultimate horror of hell; not the absolute poverty, not even the agonizing pain but the angry presence of God.”

And the appalling prospect is that all of this will never end. We all know the words of Amazing Grace where we sing “When we’ve been there ten thousand years / bright shining as the sun / we’ve no less days to sing God’s praise / than when we’ve first begun.” Just as those in heaven will be no further from the end when ten thousand years have elapsed, the same is true of people in hell. We cannot fully imagine eternity and thus cannot fully imagine what it would be like to suffer forever and ever and ever, age after endless age. Our minds cannot conceive; and I’m grateful for that limitation. At the end of this article I’ve excerpted some words of Jonathan Edwards that are worth reading.

Little wonder, based on these four points, that I find the subject almost unbearably weighty. Just thinking seriously about it presses on my soul and presses upon my heart. I would far rather think about heaven and about the reward that awaits there for those who know and love the Lord. But it is good and healthy to think about hell. It would not be healthy to think about it too much or to have a long and deep-seating fascination with it, but because God has revealed to us that there is such a place and because He has seen fit to give us a glimpse of it, it does us good to pay attention. Resources are few. We must, of course, turn to the Bible, the source of all we know about hell. But if we look further we will be surprised at how little there is. Books about heaven outnumber those about hell by a wide margin. Donnelly’s is a good one—short, accessible and biblical. Though it shares utter horror, it also shares hope. Though it describes the ultimate fate of those who refuse Christ, it shares the hope that they might turn to Him before it is too late.

I hate hell. I hate that it exists and hate that it needs to exist. I’m amazed to realize that, when we are heaven, we will praise God for it and that we will glorify Him for creating such a place and for sending the unjust there. But for now I am too filled with pride, too filled with sin to even begin to justly and rightly rejoice in the existence of such a place of torment. I cannot rejoice in such a place and do not gloat that even the wickedest of men with perish there. It is just too awful, too weighty. And I know that I deserve to be there.


This comes from the pen of Jonathan Edwards. To me this is probably the weightiest of all the horrors of hell—considering that it will never end, never ease, never cease. It will continue for all eternity with no hope for reprieve.

Consider what it is to suffer extreme torment forever and ever: to suffer it day and night from one year to another, from one age to another, and from one thousand ages to another (and so adding age to age, and thousands to thousands), in pain, in wailing and lamenting, groaning and shrieking, and gnashing your teeth - with your souls full of dreadful grief and amazement, [and] with your bodies and every member full of racking torture; without any possibility of getting ease; without any possibility of moving God to pity by your cries; without any possibility of hiding yourselves from him; without any possibility of diverting your thoughts from your pain; without any possibility of obtaining any manner of mitigation, or help, or change for the better.

Consider how dreadful despair will be in such torment. How dismal will it be, when you are under these racking torments, to know assuredly that you never, never shall be delivered from them. To have no hope: when you shall wish that you might be turned into nothing, but shall have no hope of it; when you shall wish that you might be turned into a toad or a serpent, but shall have no hope of it; when you would rejoice if you might but have any relief; after you shall have endured these torments millions of ages, but shall have no hope of it. After you shall have worn out the age of the sun, moon, and stars, in your dolorous groans and lamentations, without rest day and night, or one minute’s ease, yet you shall have no hope of ever being delivered. After you shall have worn a thousand more such ages, you shall have no hope, but shall know that you are not one whit nearer to the end of your torments. But that still there are the same groans, the same shrieks, the same doleful cries, incessantly to be made by you, and that the smoke of your torment shall still ascend up forever and ever.

The more the damned in hell think of the eternity of their torments, the more amazing will it appear to them. And alas, they will not be able to keep it out of their minds! Their tortures will not divert them from it, but will fix their attention to it. O how dreadful will eternity appear to them after they shall have been thinking on it for ages together, and shall have so long an experience of their torments! The damned in hell will have two infinites perpetually to amaze them, and swallow them up: one is an infinite God, whose wrath they will bear, and in whom they will behold their perfect and irreconcilable enemy. The other is the infinite duration of their torment.

Comments (19)

1
Anonymous's picture

Wow, what an article. Thanks so much, we need to hear these things. The quote from Jonathan Edwards should be read often.

2
Anonymous's picture

Thanks for this. I had the same weight and dread as I was preparing to preach last week on the pictures of the chaff and unfruitful branches burning (Luke 2). God granted the weighty revelation to press upon my heart like it hadn’t before - and thus the gospel shone all the brighter. Hell is horrible to consider; but we consider such ugly things, not because we like ugliness, but because we love beauty. It is the ugliness of hell which not only motivates, but provides the stark background for the glory of God’s gracious presence.

3
Anonymous's picture

An observation I have made is - generally speaking - the strongest adherents to the literal interpretation of hell are people who come from a strong lineage of Christian ancestry. That is to say, they are usually people whose parents, siblings, spouses and children are born-again Christians. Case in point is Jonathan Edwards (whose father was a minister and mother was the daughter of one, whose ten sisters were Christian, whose spouse was Christian, whose eleven children were Christian).

For those of us who come from a lineage which is decidedly non-Christian, and who have loved non-Christian parents, siblings, lovers, spouses, friends, and children, such adherence to a literal interpretation of hell does not come quite so easily.

For one, a literal interpretation of hell strips away the possibility of a literal interpretation of heaven. That is a good sentence, quite profound, actually, so I will say it again. A literal interpretation of hell strips away the possibility of a literal interpretation of heaven. When we one day walk through the pearly gates ourselves, how could heaven ever be that literal place of everlasting and supreme joy? Where, for every second of our blissful existence in the streets of gold, we’ll know that our loved one is at that very same moment undergoing an existence unimaginable for its sheer horror, pain, and loneliness? “In pain, in wailing and lamenting, groaning and shrieking, and gnashing your teeth - full of dreadful grief and amazement, with every member full of racking torture.”

No matter how much fun I might be having at a party, if I got a phone call that my child had just fallen into a bathtub of scaldingly hot boiling water … let’s just say that my fun at the party will come to a pretty quick end. In the same way, how can we be rejoicing in heaven with the knowledge of loved ones in hell?

4
Anonymous's picture

Hello Mr. Truth Cutter,

That is a problem which always bothered me, too. I began to wonder what could make heaven a place of no more tears if you recognized that some were missing.

My great-grandmother actually told my mom that we would have to have our memory banks erased and that she didn’t expect to recognize her husband. For her that was the only way around not noticing that some weren’t “there”

But I think that she made the same jump that you make, and it is a distinctly human jump, one which we all can and have made. That is to ignore the first commandment. So much of what Christ said regarding commitment to the Kingdom of God (deny yourself, who are my brothers and sisters, he who loses his life will gain it) had everything to do with pursuing a life in which nothing but God is at the fore. We pray and race and stirve to see God, not just in God’s terms, but to see God, and with our eyes on him, everything we see is illuminated by his glory and defined by his purposes.

That’s the goal, anyway.

Those who are called according to his purposes will be so busy loving God and worshipping the lamb, that nothing else will matter.

That may seem heartless, but there it is. Being a Christian isn’t about being saved, it is about Christ. That singlemindedness is quite absent from much of what goes for Christianity, and the what-about-me gospel rules, which, I think, hinders our view of Christ and nothing else.

Jason Ruzek

5
Anonymous's picture

thecuttingtruth,

I think the reason we wonder such things, as I sympathize with your quandary, is because we are not in the immediate, personal presence of God. We’re not like him, because we’ve yet to see him as he is. So no matter how hard we try, we can’t fully see things from God’s perspective - yet. The reason I can’t comprehend celebrating in Heaven while others are in Hell is because I don’t really believe those people deserve to be there. If I did, I would rejoice in justice. The reason such rejoicing seems arrogant is because I don’t appreciate just what Jesus Christ did in the atonement. The fuel of eternal worship is the knowledge that Christ paid what we deserve. When we are in the presence of God, we will fully know, even as we are fully known. Until then, I have to just believe the promises.

6
Anonymous's picture

The reason I can’t comprehend celebrating in Heaven while others are in Hell is because I don’t really believe those people deserve to be there.

This is well said. Even if we believe in hell on an intellectual level, affirming (as I did in this article) that such a place exists and that it is real and that we are deserving of such a fate, it is far different to believe in in our heart of hearts. That is, I think, because we do not see sin from God’s perspective. I suspect that the more we grow in our knowledge of God’s holiness, the more we will grow in our understanding of why hell is necessary and why hell is just. And when we see God face to face I have no doubt that we’ll have no doubts.

7
Anonymous's picture

Darby is right. Do we believe what the Bible says about man? That we are HATERS of the infinitely pure, wise, kind, perfect, good, righteous, just, holy, holy, holy God of the universe? That, given another crack at it, we would murder Jesus a thousand times over? That we are vile, wicked, evil hell-deserving sinners? That it is actually beautiful and praise-worthy of God to punish sinners with an eternal hell? Isnt this what we must believe to come to Christ for salvation? I believe that on judgment day, as hard as this will sound, God’s saints and all His angels will actually rejoice and “Amen!” God when He casts the wicked into hell. On that day His will shall be done to the glory of His justice and righteousness.

My friends, do not misunderstand me. Hell terrifies and saddens me. I also have unsaved family and friends. But the truth is that we deserve it. It is right of God and is something that we should praise and worship Him for (that He will punish the wicked). Knowing therefore the terror of the Lord we must persuade our unsaved family and friends and neighbors and strangers to “Be reconciled to God!” Because while right now we weep for them and plead with them, on that day, there will no weeping on the part of God, His angels, and saints but rather rejoicing and praising the Lamb who was slain. Again, knowing therefore the terror of the Lord let us persuade men to be reconciled towards God!!!

8
Anonymous's picture

It would not be healthy to think about it too much”

Amen to that.

Yet this post was good to read, and even ponder. Thanks. We need to think of hell sometimes. Serious stuff, to say the least.

That’s why our Lord said, “If you hand or foot would cause you to go to hell, then cut it off. And if your eye causes you to sin, pluck it out.”

10
Anonymous's picture

My main basic problem with Hell is that I know that of my own accord I am bound to to be there.

11
Anonymous's picture

Sorry - back at the back - doesnt mean they are in teh closing pages of the book - rather they are the sermons that were turned into the book.

That said, if you havent heard Prof Donnelly - he’s worth listening to - you can hear the compassion in his voice - this is no ‘fire and brimstone’ preaching. This is preaching with heart and tears.

12
Anonymous's picture

Sorry - still cant type - that should have read “lie at the back of”

13
Anonymous's picture

Many have been deluded into thinking that Satan will own and control hell, but the reality is that God’s is present in hell as much as He is in heaven. People in hell will spend an eternity in the presence of God, but in the presence of His just wrath against sin.

I raised this issue not too long ago, whether hell is eternal separation from God, or only eternal separation from the blessed presence of God.

So thanks Tim for making this clarification, which I am now confident is the soundest Biblical understanding of hell. My concern arises as I believe that by misrepresenting the Biblical hell in a gospel presentation by suggesting it is eternal separation from God, that it can do serious damage to the messages clarity, especially in regard to the understanding of divine judgment, and it can also leave the unregenerate looking forward to hell (after all, in their opinion the presence of God is the last thing they desire).

14
Anonymous's picture

Sam Storms has a good four-part study on “Hell and the Happiness of Heaven” here:http://www.enjoyinggodministries.com/studies/theology-of-jonathan-edwards/Storms aims mainly to answer the objection that hell deniers would raise:”The sight or knowledge by those in heaven of the eternal suffering in hell of loved ones would destroy or at least seriously undermine such joy. Would not heaven be a “hell” for all who must spend eternity observing or thinking about the indescribable suffering of their unsaved friends and family members?”It is a good read…

15
Anonymous's picture

Ted Donnelly’s little book is in my top 5 best books I’ve ever read, and I’m really glad that Heaven and Hell is being read.

Nath, you reminded me of a story someone told me of an evangelistic experience he had. He once described hell to a nonChrisitan, as a place of separation from God - a place where he isn’t. The nonChristian replied with the news that he wasn’t aware of God with him now and that he felt totally separated from him, but life wasn’t too bad. He had to conclude that hell can’t be that bad if it is just an eternal version of now, and so being saved from that eternal future wasn’t a big deal. My friend later found out that this chap had been killed in a car accident. He doesn’t know if he ever came to faith.

I guess the lesson is that we can’t be economical with the truth when it comes to hell. We have to tell it plain, and tell it as it is, in all it’s gruesome detail, even though the temptation to play down this doctrine is so strong. Subtle change of emphasis is the enemy of the church, and perhaps the most devious and well-hidden enemy there is.

16
Anonymous's picture

perhaps we should all take a step back.

what did the jews believe about an afterlife? exactly. for hundreds of years they DID NOT BELIEVE in an afterlife.

look at the sadducees. they were pretty solid fundamentalists, they ONLY took the early jewish writ. and the law of moses did not pass down the idea of heaven/hell.

the jews didn’t assimilate a belief in the afterlife until after captivity.

hopefully you can tell where i am going with this.

comments?

17
Anonymous's picture

Hell is an almost unbearable thought to me! I have unsaved family including an 80 year old mother in law. My husband and I have shared the gospel on many occasions with these loved ones. The god of this world has truly blinded the mind of the unbeliever. One reason I am a convinced calvinist is that no amount of emotion, tears, begging and sharing scripture has ever convinced these people of their lost condition. Unless the Lord draws them and regenerates them, they will never come to Christ.I used to believe that if only my presentation of the gospel were compelling enough surely people would believe!The only way I can deal with my horror at the thought of hell is to trust my Sovereign loving Lord! It’s all too much for me! Victoria

18
Anonymous's picture

Tim Keller’s “Preaching Hell in a Tolerant Age”, with it’s delightful (if one can use such a phrase for such a context) subtitle, “Brimstone for the broad-minded”, is well worth a read. It can be found on-line here.

19
Anonymous's picture

Tim, where is the Edwards quote taken from? Dwelling on the thought of a real hell is an uncomfortable experience, one that we, or I, in the self-centred and self-serving comfort of our existence run from. I needed to be reminded, thank you brother.