Book Review - Incomprehensible Demoralization

It’s probably not a good idea for a drug addict to work as a pharmacist. Actually, I’d say it’s definitely not a good idea for a drug addict to work as a pharmacist. And yet, in 1996, when Jared Combs graduated from school and became a licensed pharmacist, he was heavily addicted to all kinds of drugs—any kind of drug, really.

As is so often the case, Combs had to be brought low—very low—before he could see any substantial change and healing. In his case, Combs had to spend time in prison for stealing and consuming drugs. He was twice arrested and twice fired from jobs he loved. And yet today he is a testimony to grace. He has been sober for several years and once more practices pharmacy, this time at the University of Kentucky Medical Center. He is the father of three young children and is a committed husband. The strangely-titled Incomprehensible Demoralization is Jared Combs’ story of addiction and recovery. It is a story of one man’s transformation from a hopeless alcoholic and drug addict on the fast-track to a lifetime behind bars to a sober, church-attending family man.

Incomprehensible Demoralization is a self-published work but one that is quite well-done, at least as far as self-published works go (I’ve long since learned to lower my expectations for such books). Though it definitely could have benefited at times from an editor’s pen, it remains readable and well-written. Combs does a good job of sharing the trials and cravings of an addict. He shows well what it is like to be willing to do anything or give anything for one more fix. He shows that not even a clean-cut person working a good job is exempt from this kind of temptation.

The difficulty in writing a book of this nature is properly balancing the “before” and the “after.” In some ways, a person’s life as an addict is more interesting to the reader than his life after addiction. And this is, sadly, the undoing of Incomprehensible Demoralization. Though I truly did want to be able to recommend this book, I do not feel that I can do so in good conscience. I base this on several concerns. First, where Combs gives goes into great detail about his life as a drug addict, he gives far less attention to life in recovery. He describes sin far more than he describes grace. Second, and of greater concern, is the fact that the gospel is almost entirely absent from this account. While Combs ascribes his victory over drugs and alcohol to God’s grace, never does he describe the power of the cross or the power of God’s forgiveness. Never does he preach the gospel as God’s power over sin. He turns often to Alcoholic Anonymous’ Big Book but never does he quote the Bible. Third, mostly below the surface but sometimes in plain view is an understanding of his addiction as being somehow tied to genetics—that the disease of alcoholism is the cause of moral deficiency. A look at Scripture, though, reverses this, telling us that moral deficiency is the ultimate cause of alcoholism and any other kind of sin and addiction. Fourth, never does he adequately deal with the spiritual implications of living the way he did—as an alcoholic, drug addicted thief. And finally, the book is sometimes crude, using expletives needlessly and relying too much on sarcasm that, at best, borders on rudeness.

The book is interesting as a biography and as a story of recovery. But as a spiritual biography it is disappointingly lacking. While Combs rightly ascribes his victory over addiction to the power of God, never does he really prove this or describe how it came to be. This could almost as easily be a story where the hero is Alcoholics Anonymous rather than God.

Comments (9)

1
Anonymous's picture

The book isn’t trying to be a spiritual autobiography, a Bible study, or a theological exposition of some particular doctrine, so why would you judge it against that standard? People go through recovery all the time with God’s help but using something like the AA manual instead of going deep into Scriptural exegesis. It seems like since he’s giving an honest account of his experience, your criticism is leveled less at the book and more at how he came out of his drug addiction and got his life back together. When you read a history book (it seems like you’ve reviewed some David McCullough books), you don’t fault them for not going into the spiritual applications of everything or presenting a plan of salvation in the back. Why should this one be any different?

2
Anonymous's picture

The hero of Alcoholics Anonymous is God.

3
Anonymous's picture

Thanks for the review. I have heard many testimonies where the emphasis has been on sin rather than grace and where the gospel has been almost entirely absent. If this book falls into that sort of category then your review is fair and honest and I commend you for it.

4
Anonymous's picture

I’ve spent the past 4.5 years of my life as a “recovered” addict. Although in the beginning, it was rocky. I leaned heavily on AA and NA to guide me along, I even spent much time developing relationships that kept me strong and still do to this day. However, I’ve longed to give an account of how great grace is in the life of a 2-bit junkie like myself. Now, I am merely a pilgrim and no longer an anonymous street person.

I will be going to a recovery center this very week (Christmas Eve) to share my hope in God and Christ for recovery with those who are just now checkin in..

5
Anonymous's picture

Well Tim.. you mentioned the need for a bit of EDITING .. you have that skill .. you found enough interest in the book to read and review it - why not invest in it? I’m not thinking money, I’m thinking time and skill and a godly hand!You are right - folks love to read the ugly - even nice Christians still get some secret kick out of NOT being THAT kind of person. I was asked to speak on Changes of the Heart several years ago, and I did, totally biblically - and was given an unfavorable report becuase I didnt’ tell the grim ugly gross filthy stories of my old life! Hellllo!!! Cr^p sells! Just yesterday I was given time to chat with a guy going to a new Christian Sober Living home.. he was excited about the change and was believing he could still go forward. I belive he can… gave him my phone number, and he was so sweet in his thanks! I am not a recovered druggie, but I have 3 adult children in various stages of recovery.. it’s never done, it’s always a process.. thanks to those who give of their hearts and t ime to be a warm hand in a cold world.As for the review, thank you very much, I’m glad you gave it as I’m sure I will t ry to find a copy, fix it up, and pass it on ..

6
Anonymous's picture

Imho you’re too quick to dismiss genetic predisposition toward addiction. Does predisposition mean the urge can’t be resisted? Not at all. But it’s silly to ignore the fact that some people are built in such a way that puts them at special risk for certain sins. So the causes of alcoholism are two fold. One, man’s inherent sinfulness, but also the specific genetic makeup of many alcoholics which may predispose them to that particular sin.

7
Anonymous's picture

Hello all! Jared Combs here…author of Incomprehensible Demoralization. I just wanted to weigh in my two cents:

I couldn’t have said it better than Mike. My story is not meant to be a spiritual biography- it’s just my story and nothing more. I’m not sure how my recovery memoir ended up getting a somewhat slighted review for not being what it was never meant to be. I do attribute my recovery to God. Until I handed it over to Him, I kept failing.

Much of the book was about my drug use, bad behaviors, and the consequences. But I think Tim’s review is misleading when it says I spent far less time discussing my life in recovery. That’s simply an oversight on his part. I spent 67 of the 177 pages discussing my recovery. To read Tim’s review you’d think I just threw in a chapter at the end about it. I adore my life in recovery. I could go on and on about how my life has been blessed in recovery, but that would probably get boring after awhile.

I believe that AA and the book of Alcoholics Anonymous are God-inspired. God is mentioned generically in the AA text, but that was done on purpose to allow everyone, not just Christians, to have the opportunity to find recovery. I thank God for AA. It has been a lifesaver for me. God is my soul saver. AA has given me a support group and true friends that have been there in dire times. Without that support, I would not have made it where I am.

Now about those expletives Tim mentioned. I can’t find them. If there’s more than 3 in the whole book, I’ll eat my shoe. I wrote the book with my mom and my children in mind, so I purposely left out as much of that type of thing as possible.

I hope you folks will give it a read and let me know what you think.

jared

8
Anonymous's picture

Jared.. good to hear from you .. I am very interested in finding a copy of your book. After reading it, I’m trusting it will be suitable to pass on to a Sober Living home that has helped my own kids.If you saw my comment - you know there are those of us who recognize that UGLY sells .. sort of a dangling carrot.God Bless you and your family and may He continue to use you in the growth and maturity of others.Thank you for your response,SandieMcF

9
Anonymous's picture

It is available at www.jaredcombs.com God bless you and your family.jc