- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous PostA La Carte (11/9)
- Next Post »Enjoy Messiah this Christmas
Handel's Messiah: Comfort for God's People
- 11/09/10
- 19
I always feel like a bit of a poser when I say this, but I absolutely love Handel’s Messiah. Though I appreciate small amounts of classical music (to use the term in a broad sense) I am largely a rock ‘n’ roll type. Yet there is something about Messiah that grips me. I find myself listening to it throughout the year, again and again, year after year. I’ve listened to recordings hundreds of times and make it a habit to attend a live performance every Christmas season. I can’t get enough.
I was rather excited to see a new book releasing this fall titled Handel’s Messiah: Comfort for God’s People. Written by Calvin Stapert, professor emeritus of music at Calvin College, the book serves as a guide to Handel’s great masterpiece. As the publisher says in the one-sentence pitch, “If you want to enjoy and appreciate Handel’s beloved Messiah more deeply, this informed yet accessible guide is the book to read.” I’m inclined to agree.
While I love Messiah I have often struggled with the knowledge that I do not really understand it very well. I’ve always known that if I just knew a little bit more about this form of music, if I just understood the context a little bit more, the Baroque style, my appreciation of Messiah would necessarily grow as well. But I am not at all musical. The last time I played an instrument was in primary school and that instrument was a recorder. Any time I’ve sought to learn more, I’ve quickly gotten lost in the technicalities of the musical lexicon.
However, this book has finally helped me see Messiah more clearly. Here is how the author describes what he has sought to accomplish in his work. “The three sections of this book aim to increase understanding from three different perspectives. The first section traces three histories—the history of oratorio up to Messiah; the history of Handel up to Messiah; and the history of Messiah’s inception and reception. Although I think these histories can contribute something toward a greater understanding of the work, I tell them primarily because they reveal a series and confluence of remarkable and unlikely events that led to the making of Messiah and from there to the phenomenon that it has become.”
The second section of the book deals with what Charles Jennens hoped to accomplish in compiling the libretto of Messiah and what purposes Handel had for setting it to music. Here Stapert shows that Messiah acknowledges two masters—the theater and the church, which is to say that it was meant to be entertainment and it was meant to be sacred.
The third section looks to Jennen’s text and the music Handel composed to accompany it. Essentially it provides commentary on the music and the theology of the words. As he does this he largely avoids using technical language that will be meaningful only to those with a background in music or theology. In other words, he seeks to make this an accessible book that will appeal to any reader, whether one well-versed in such music or one who is entirely new to it.
The book weighs in at just under 180 pages. Just about half of the book contains the third part, which means there are about 75 pages of commentary on the music and the words. This is ideal to read through before attending a performance or to read through as you listen to a recording.
Particularly interesting to me was the author’s discussion about the purpose behind Messiah. Debates have raged (in rather closed circles, mind you) about whether Messiah was meant to instruct or whether it was meant to entertain. Stapert looks to the times to show that both were true; they were not mutually-exclusive. “However the relationship was viewed, teaching and delighting were not seen as incompatible, and neither one was seen as detrimental or inimical to art. They belonged together.” Though modern sensibilities may have swayed people to think that moral teaching weakens art, Stapert disagrees. “From the perspective of history, however, the view that art is amoral is the peculiar one. The normal view, taken by most people in most times and places, sees art as being closely related to ethics and morality.”
Centuries after it was composed, Messiah continues to delight. It beautifully combines the words of Scripture—words to teach and inspire—with music that causes the heart to delight in the One who gave us the gift of music. After all these years it continues to offer comfort, joy and peace to God’s people.
You can buy Handel’s Messiah: Comfort for God’s People at Westminster Books or Amazon.

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I worship and serve as a pastor at
Releasing on April 1, The Next
Comments (19)
Thanks for posting about this book. I teach music at a small liberal arts college and am looking forward to, not only purchasing the book myself, but also bringing it to the attention of my campus community. I will be posting a link to this page from a regular feature on my blog called “I Was Blogging and Found….” Thanks again.
Tim, do you have a favorite recording of Handel’s Messiah?Or does anyone have one they like and recommend? Thanks!
Interesting reading. I love classical music (but I have trained as a ballerina and now teach ballet so that is most likely why). :) Thank you for bringing my attention to this book.
Kindest regards,Brookwww.Matt5verse6.blogspot.com
Wow, this sounds like a great read. Thanks for the recommendation! Most people know only the “Hallelujah Chorus,” but the whole of Messiah is so wonderful. I look forward to reading this.
BTW, if you are interested in learning more about “classical” music, check out The Teaching Company’s “How To Listen To And Understand Great Music” lecture series by Robert Greenberg. I listened to the entire thing over several months while commuting to and from work every day. Some of the most enjoyable, educational commuting I’ve ever done. :-)
Tim,
Forgive the momentary digression, but your use of the word “poser” struck me as I was not familiar with this particular connotation of that word. As the perpetual logophile (lover of words) I just had to look it up!
From: www.dictionary.reference.com
poser -n
1. a person who poses (knew that…!)
2. informal a person who likes to be seen in trendsetting clothes in fashionable bars, discos, etc
3. (Slang) someone who pretends to belong to a group only by affecting the attributes of the group. (See also mod poser.) : What’s he doing here? He’s just a poser, looking for dates.
Interesting!
Handel’s Messiah, well done, in its entirety, is simply heaven on earth!
Regarding the best recording question above? Here’s an opinion: http://www.classical.net/music/comp.lst/works/handel/messiah/mozart.php
In Christ,
Dan…
Funny you should post this today, as I just saw a glorious rendition of the Hallelujah Chorus performed at a Macy’s in Philadelphia by seemingly random people. The crowd was delighted and awed. I pray that everyone there listened to the words as they gave glory and honor and praise to THE KING OF KINGS and LORD OF LORDS forever and ever! Hallelujah!
Enjoy!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wp_RHnQ-jgU&feature=player_embedded
I love Handel’s “Water Music” as well. You’ve maybe heard it a thousand times and perhaps never realized it was Handel. A true Baroque masterpiece. Also love Vivaldi’s “The Four Seasons,” maybe the best known pieces from the period.
“The popularity and success of the Baroque style was encouraged by the Roman Catholic Church, which had decided at the time of the Council of Trent, in response to the Protestant Reformation, that the arts should communicate religious themes in direct and emotional involvement.”
What a treat this book will be.
May the knowledge and love of the score abound, but may it’s regenerative work restore the nations even more.
I’ve been so looking forward to this book! Last year I posted some reflections on each of the movements from Messiah (which anyone interested can find here: http://honeyandlocusts.wordpress.com/messiah-blog-table-of-contents/), but I’m REALLY excited about a book-length treatment. I’ll be reading it in a few weeks before I attend a performance of the oratorio.
Mary Ann,
I really enjoy Handel’s Messiah and have been listening to it for years. I would recommend two versions of the piece.
The first is titled “Messiah” by the Boston Baroque with Martin Pearlman as the director. It is produced by Telarc. This is a more traditional Baroque style.
The second is “Messiah” by the London Philharmonic Orchestra directed by Karl Richter. This is a much more traditional full orchestra rendition. It’s a little difficult to find but worth the effort.
I really enjoy both and they are different in their style but they still lift my heart to praise God for His marvelous grace!
Mary Ann:
I’ve sung the Messiah a few times and we were recommended to purchase the album by the group The Sixteen with Harry Christophers. I own it and it’s a fantastic rendition.http://www.the-sixteen.org.uk/recordings/coro_62.php
You’ve found a lot of Messiah-lovers, Mr. Challies! Listening to it is such a wonderful devotional experience.
I own the Robert Shaw recording, and am mostly happy with it (except for the alto soloist).
Those who love the Messiah may want to check out other great oratorios, such as “The Creation” by Haydn and the “St. Matthew Passion” by Bach.
Pardon me, I was wrong. I have John Rutter’s version. Anything by Robert Shaw would probably be good, since he was one of the best choral conductors of the last century.
I was just thinking how I want to listen to the Messiah…have so many good memories of mom playing it on Sunday morning! Wonder if there is a performance is Chattanooga.
Yes, I love the Messiah. I have to admit, though, that I wish there was less emphasis on “The Hallelujah Chorus.” Its lost some of its connotation to me, as I’ve heard it in too many contexts that are not particularly Christian, and sometimes emplyed in a sarcastic context (“Hallelujah” being used equivalent to Homer Simpson’s “Woo-hoo!”). Of course this is hardly Handel’s fault or the music’s. I’ve decided that my favorite is “For Unto Us a Child is Born”. Also, I have accompanied the Messiah before as an orchestra player (amateur). Its not particularly hard as orchestra pieces go, but the crossing strings part for violins in “O Thou that Tellest Good Tidings to Zion” is a bit difficult to get cleanly.
I have the same problem with “Toccata in D” by Bach. My mom used to (and may still) play it in church once in a while, but “Circuit City Midnight Madness Sale” and various Halloween type motifs have taken any worshipfulness aspect out of it for me.
It has been my privilege to direct a choir and professional orchestra performing Messiah (minus the Christmas portion) every Easter season for the past dozen years. I own various recordings and have heard many other renditions. My favorite has always been the recording by Sir Georg Solti and the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and Chorus. It was recorded in the 1980’s and was one of the first recordings released on the then new media of compact discs. Too many recordings have tempos so slow that you will likely fall asleep or be bored to tears. Most are of choirs that sing in a style more in line with compositions of the 19th century Romantic Period. Find the recording by Sir Georg Solti and the Chicago Symphony Orchestra and you will have a near-perfect rendition!
I would like to draw people’s attention to an older book, entitled “Understanding Handel’s Messiah” by Mariano Di gangi, a former senior pastor of both Tenth Presbyterian in Philadelphia and Knox Presbyterian in Toronto. (Understanding Handel’s Messiah written by Mariano Di Gangi reprinted in 1995 by Lancelot Press limited).
It is a book of excellent and succinct theological meditations on the texts used in Handel’s Messiah (with occasional references to the music). In our church choir’s presentation of Messiah, I have had paragraphs read from this book before we sing various numbers from the Oratorio. It has enabled people to listen with understanding. (Paul tells us to sing with the Spirit and with the understanding also - we just apply the same principal to hearing worship music as well.)
The book is a bit hard to get a hold of these days, but well worth it if you can. If you are interested, we have a few extra copies lying around Knox Toronto (where I serve as Music Director), and we might be able to send some out to any who request it. Contact me through knoxtoronto.org.
I would like to draw people’s attention to an older book, entitled “Understanding Handel’s Messiah” by Mariano Di gangi, a former senior pastor of both Tenth Presbyterian in Philadelphia and Knox Presbyterian in Toronto. (Understanding Handel’s Messiah written by Mariano Di Gangi reprinted in 1995 by Lancelot Press limited).
It is a book of excellent and succinct theological meditations on the texts used in Handel’s Messiah (with occasional references to the music). In our church choir’s presentation of Messiah, I have had paragraphs read from this book before we sing various numbers from the Oratorio. It has enabled people to listen with understanding. (Paul tells us to sing with the Spirit and with the understanding also - we just apply the same principal to hearing worship music as well.)
The book is a bit hard to get a hold of these days, but well worth it if you can. If you are interested, we have a few extra copies lying around Knox Toronto (where I serve as Music Director), and we might be able to send some out to any who request it. Contact me through knoxtoronto.org.
In December 2010 ChristianAudio.com is giving the audiobook for free. Go and get it. It also contains music inside :-)See http://christianaudio.com/handels-messiah-calvin-r-stapert