- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous Post"The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment "Blog Tour
- Next Post »Wisdom from John Adams
DVD Reviews on the Run
- 01/05/08
- 8
The War
The War is a new documentary series by acclaimed producer Ken Burns (best known for his series on the Civil War). Something of a unique take on a history of World War 2, the series tells the war through the eyes of four towns from across America. It deals both with the home front—the war years as they were experienced through the lives of the people who remained behind, and it deals with the war itself—the war as it was fought by men from those towns. The series is masterfully made.
Some people have argued that there is a little too much repetition in the footage used and others have said that there is perhaps a little too much emphasis in the films on the role of various minority groups. This is not to say that minorities were not involved or important in the war, but it seems clear that controversy surrounding the role of Hispanics led to what some feel is perhaps an inordinate amount of time being dedicated to particular groups. Personally I felt the balance was quite good and the focus on these groups has been very interesting to me precisely because they are too often ignored (though admittedly the footage appended to the first episode seems a mite forced). For example, it was very interesting hearing about the Japanese Americans who on one hand fought bravely on the European front while on the other hand their families were forced to remain behind barbed wire in internment camps. What a strange paradox.
Regardless of your feelings on those areas, the series is really worth your while. Even my wife, who is certainly no Word War 2 enthusiast, enjoyed the series since it emphasizes not just the war, but the stories of both groups and individuals. The series may well appeal to just about anyone. I definitely recommend it.
It is available at Amazon.
Still Standing
Still Standing is the most recent production from Franklin Springs Family Media. It tells the story of Stonewall Jackson, not primarily through his experience as a soldier, but through the legacy of his faith. With much of the story being told by historians, it describes him not just a military genius (which is certainly his legacy in history) but as a made of resolute Christian character. It takes the viewer from his orphaned childhood, through the Sunday school class he taught for African Americans, and into the Civil War where he played a pivotal role in the initial successes of the Confederacy. Shot in a variety of relevant historical locales, the production gives the viewer a sense of where Jackson lived and what his life might have been like. It certainly provides a challenge to understand the faith that made Jackson who he was.
It is also available at Amazon.
Inherit the Land
Inherit the Land is described as being “Adventures in the Agrarian Journey.” “This new DVD will cast a vision for your family by providing an introductory look at the blessings found when families work in an agrarian lifestyle. We've traveled across the US and captured stories of families experiencing the joy of working in God's creation.” The DVD introduces several families and the agrarian lifestyle they’ve chosen. On that level it is an interesting production and is well-made. On another level—the level in which it seems to subtly prescribe this as a superior lifestyle to middle-class suburbia (i.e. the typical Christian experience today), I found it disappointing. It seems to fall into several of the traps that may (sometimes) befall those who seek out such a lifestyle. It seems to teach that what is old is innately better than what is new and that there was a time in the past, perhaps 150 years ago, we ought to recover—a time when it was far easier to be a Christian. That is a fallacy, though a popular one, I’m sure. I am glad to see some Christian families choosing an agrarian lifestyle, but if all Christians were to follow suit, our witness to the world would be devastated. Many of us have no desire to do that and feel no pull from a biblically-informed conscience to do such a thing. Though the presentation is quite good, the message behind the presentation was, in my opinion, a wee bit disappointing. Still, it is an interesting enough production and one I enjoyed watching.
It is available at Franklin Springs.

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I worship and serve as a pastor at
Releasing on April 1, The Next
Comments (8)
“One could argue that there is … a little too much emphasis on the role of various minority groups (which is not to say that minorities were not involved or important, but it seems clear that political correctness and some controversy led to what is perhaps an inordinate amount of time being dedicated to particular groups).”
These “minorities” that you speak of would probably have preferred to be referred to as Americans - many of them died in combat for their beloved country. I find it eye-opening that the only taint you find on an otherwise “masterfully made” series is when “minorities” are at long last given their due place in American history. It speaks volumes about you.
Hey, quick pop quiz - what is the most highly decorated military unit in the history of the United States Armed Forces (including 21 Medal of Honor recipients)?
Google this: 442nd.
“It seems to teach that what is old is innately better than what is new and that there was a time in the past, perhaps 150 years ago, we ought to recover—a time when everything was better and more godly.”
I am familiar with many of the folks moving (or have already moved) in this direction and I don’t know a single one that would make such this sort of superficial case for agrarian living. I also don’t know any who believe that everyone should pick up and move to the country either. For those interested there are a number of very good recorded audio conversations at Cumberland books which can now be downloaded for free at http://cumberlandbooks.com/plaintalk.php, many with the more popular agrarian minded bloggers. Hopefully Rick (the owner of the site) can handle the traffic.
“These “minorities” that you speak of would probably have preferred to be referred to as Americans”
Minority Man - To be honest, the focus on the minority groups (i.e. Americans) has actually been among my favorite parts of the series. I’ve found it fascinating. I merely meant to state what others have suggested as part of the “controversy” surrounding the series. Do some digging and you’ll see that Burns had to edit the series to add more footage about minority groups because of the reaction of viewers. Personally, I think it’s pretty balanced and have quite enjoyed it. I probably should have made that more clear. I’m going to edit the post to state that more clearly. Thanks for pointing this out to me.
Incidentally, one interplay I found very interesting was the story of the American Japanese soldiers who bravely fought their way across Europe, even while their parents were behind barbed wire in internment camps. It’s a bizarre and fascinating story, that.
I am familiar with many of the folks moving (or have already moved) in this direction and I don’t know a single one that would make such this sort of superficial case for agrarian living.
I don’t know that the people featured in this film would make a case that is so entirely superficial, but it seemed to be one of the emphases that the past was better and we need to get back to it. It may not be a primary motive, but it certainly seems to be in the minds of some of these people. That’s all!
“The War” was tremendous. i wish they would require this film in public schools. Would be a good way to compliment the History curriculum.This film shows war for what it is, sin. And it show righteousness and unrighteousness as well. Also humility, suffering, and thankfulness was so vivid in this documentary.
Tim,
Since you love books and good writing I am sure you love Chesterton, everyone loves Chesterton right? Anyway, Chesterton was actually involved in just such a movement. I guess Christianity Today discussed the topic recently but I didn’t read it so I am not sure if they articulated any of the reasons why one would do this or why one would encourage others to follow in this direction. I am currently reading Angels in the Architecture (http://www.canonpress.org/shop/item.asp?itemid=410) and there is an excellent (very balanced) chapter which addresses the topic. I would encourage you to read the book. This book makes the case that in many ways we need to recover some ways of life and thinking from the Middle Ages! A film like ‘Inherit the Land’ has a role but it is very limited in what it can accomplish and what it tried to accomplish. So to someone unfamiliar with the thinking behind the motivation for the film you might come away with the impression that it is a simple message of get back to the old way and everything will be better, but that is not the case at all. To be fair I will go back and watch my copy of the film and see if it would be easy to see it this way. The short coming in the film for me was that it sounded a bit too much like an infomercial. If you want to see films which really show some insights into the benefits of getting back to the land (and ultimately back to the family) I think ‘A Journey Home’ and the PBS series Frontier House are better bets. Keep up the good work, may of use appreciate what you do.
Ethan,
I haven’t seen Inherit the Land, but I did see the PBS documentary, Frontier House. What I thought was interesting was that the observer is able to draw their own conclusions through the many hours of footage.
At the end of the documentary, the rich family goes back to their mansion. The teenage girls are sitting in a hottub overlooking the ocean, and the bubbles are steaming. It’s a stark contrast of the hard, hard work of their frontier experience. She says this line, which I thought was classic….”There’s nothing to DO.”
All the railing against modern culture, video games, or whatever your pet peeve/vice is, couldn’t have been summed up better than with that scene.