- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous PostA La Carte (10/18)
- Next Post »A La Carte (10/19)
Reading Classics Together - Holiness ("Assurance")
- 10/18/07
- 16
“We know that we are of God.” (1 John 5:19)
Today we come to the final chapter of the first classic we’re reading together. You can read more about this effort here: Reading the Classics Together. Even if you have not participated in this effort, please keep reading. I'm sure there will be something here to benefit you. At the very least read the end to see how you can join in our next effort.
The book’s previous chapters have covered Sin, Sanctification, Holiness, The Fight, The Cost and Growth. The final chapter concerns itself with Assurance—the believer’s privilege of being assured that he is a Christian. This is a doctrine that today, like in Ryle’s day, was too often neglected or, if not that, was the cause of much dispute. It is a doctrine, he is convinced, that has much to do with holiness. He approaches the subject cautiously and humbly, acknowledging that “the road between truth and error is here especially a narrow pass.”
He defines assurance in this way: “A true Christian, a converted man, may reach such a comfortable degree of faith in Christ, that in general he shall feel entirely confident as to the pardon and safety of his soul, shall seldom be troubled with doubts, seldom be distracted with fears, seldom be distressed by anxious questionings and, in short, though vexed by many an inward conflict with sin, shall look forward to death without trembling, and to judgment without dismay. This, I say, is the doctrine of the Bible.”
Ryle follows this outline:
Summary
- An assured hope is a scriptural thing
- A believer may never arrive at this assured hope, and yet be saved
- Reasons why an assured hope is exceedingly to be desired
- It provides present comfort
- It tends to make a Christian an active working Christian
- It tends to make a decided Christian
- It tends to make the holiest Christians
- Probable causes why an assured hope is never attained
- A defective view of the doctrine of Justification
- Slothfulness about growth in grace
- An inconsistent walk in life
- Application
- If you are not a Christian, learn from the privileges and comforts of a Christian and come to Christ
- If you are a Christian and do not have an assured hope, then resolve today to seek it.
Discussion
As with one or two of the other chapters in the book, this one was perhaps a bit unexpected. I would not have thought a chapter on assurance would merit a place in such a book. But because Ryle does a superb job of showing the close connection between assurance and holiness and because he proves the importance of this doctrine, I can understand why it was good and necessary to include it.
Ryle is, in his own right, a master of illustration and analogy. Yet at one point he turns to another author to suggest why some true Christians never receive assurance of pardon. “‘A letter,’ says an old writer, ‘may be written, which is not sealed; so grace may be written in the heart, yet the Spirit may not set the seal of assurance to it.’” He goes on to speak of a child who is the heir of a great fortune, yet is never made aware of the riches and wealth that are rightfully his. In this way a Christian may never come to know that assurance is his birthright and that he may have full confidence in the validity of his salvation.
But the illustration that most gripped my soul as I read this chapter had to do with the importance of the doctrine of assurance. This is a doctrine that few people regard as having any great importance, but listen to what Ryle says.
Take, for an illustration of this, two English emigrants, and suppose them set down side by side in New Zealand or Australia. Give each of them a piece of land to clear and cultivate. Let the portions allotted to them be the same, both in quantity and quality. Secure that land to them by every needful legal instrument; let it be conveyed as freehold to them and theirs forever; let the conveyance be publicly registered and the property made sure to them by every deed and security that man's ingenuity can devise.Suppose then that one of them shall set to work to clear his land and bring it into cultivation and labor at it day after day without intermission or cessation.
Suppose in the meanwhile that the other shall be continually leaving his work and going repeatedly to the public registry to ask whether the land really is his own, whether there is not some mistake, whether after all there is not some flaw in the legal instruments which conveyed it to him.
The one shall never doubt his title but just work diligently on. The other shall hardly ever feel sure of his title and spend half his time in going to Sydney or Melbourne or Auckland with needless inquiries about it.
Which now of these two men will have made most progress in a year's time? Who will have done the most for his land, got the greatest breadth of soil under tillage, have the best crops to show, be altogether the most prosperous?
Anyone of common sense can answer that question. I need not supply an answer. There can be only one reply. Undivided attention will always attain the greatest success.
Those who dwell secure in their relationship with the Lord, taking confidence not in their own rightness but in the grip of the One who holds them—these people are free to focus on the things that need to be done. Rather than spending much of their time in deep concern that they may not be saved; rather than continually studying the Scripture to discern whether or not God has done His work in their lives, these people are free from the tyranny of uncertainty and are thus free to be active, working Christians. But for reading this chapter, I would not have considered the practical importance and the practical ramifications of getting this doctrine right and having it applied to my soul. That is my “take home” application this week.
Holiness has been a joy to read and has given me much to think about. It is a book I know that I will return to often. I’m grateful that it is more than a classic I can cross of my list—it is a book that is as relevant and as important today as the day Ryle penned it. And it spoke to me as it has spoken to generations of believers before. Thank you for reading it with me!
Next Time
Now that we’ve finished this book, I guess it’s time to choose another. I think we’ll begin the next reading project in a few weeks and, in all likelihood, will read some John Owen. Stay tuned for more information in the next couple of weeks.
Your Turn
I am interested in hearing what you took away from this chapter. Feel free to post comments below or to write about this on your own blog (and then post a comment linking us to your thoughts). Don't feel that you need to say anything shocking or profound. Just share what stirred your heart or gave you pause or confused you. I’d also be glad to hear your comments about the book as a whole.

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I worship and serve as a pastor at
Releasing on April 1, The Next
Comments (16)
A captivating chapter. One I wish I had read much sooner in my faith. At once comforting and confronting, something I grown to appreciate about Ryle.
“The river of death is a cold stream, and we have to cross it alone. No earthly friend can help us. The last enemy, the king of terrors, is a strong foe. When our souls are departing, there is no cordial like the strong wine of assurance.”The April 07 issue of CT had a wonderful little meditation about Martin Luther’s advice on facing death. Compliments and expounds upon what Ryle says here.
“Assurance will support a child of God under the heaviest bereavements, and assist him to feel ‘It is well.’” Thought of Spafford’s great hymn “It is well with my soul.” Perhaps they knew one another?
“The product of…no evidence required assurance is that people are taught to look at a prayer prayed twenty years ago as the reason to think they are saved…” (Dever and Alexander in “Deliberate Church”). Decisional regeneration is exactly wrong, and here Ryle has taught us that there are these “stages” in assurance. So is the late D James Kennedy’s first “spiritual diagnostic question,” “If you were to die today, are you 100% confident that you would have eternal life,” perhaps the very worst place to start in a witnessing situation?
I have benefited from this reading project and have also met once a week with a friend to go over each chapter of “Holiness.” (Full disclosure: we ended up one chapter behind this week! In 45 mins we’re meeting for lunch to discuss “Growth.” So we’ll actually finish next week - thanks for initiating this project.)
I was hoping to read Owen’s “Communion with God” or “The Holy Spirit” sometime over this next year, as I’d like to look at his Trinitarian theology/spirituality. (I’ve already read “The Glory of Christ.”) I realize you may choose another book, he has many classics, but I just thought I’d throw this out there!
Ken ShomoVirginia Beach
I got way behind on this project, but I have loved reading the summaries by Tim and comments by the rest of you. I feel like the whole book is a ready resource to me, even though I only read the intro and two chapters. The sense of timelessness and perspective is awesome. Nothing new under the sun. I think it is great to be equipped with classics like these. Keep it up.
Sorry. I am three of four pages behind in completing this chapter. It has been a difficult chapter to read, not because I doubt my assurance or not believe that people struggle with it, but because as Tim said, it felt out of place and I had to and still having to work through this chapter.
This was a very precious chapter to me. As mom of a son, and daughter of a mother who struggled with assurance and were the bruised reeds and smoking flax that Ryle, Sibbes and others (what great notes at the end of the chapter!) have written so comfortingly of, I found myself rejoicing in the gentleness of our Savior, both in giving assurance and in tenderly keeping those of His who do not have it. As so many others have expressed, I wish I had read and understood these things long ago. But now I have and do, and there is a whole church out there needing to hear the message of this book. Tim, this has been one of the best times of reading, devotion and growth in my life…I’m looking forward to the next book.
I would like to add these audios as exceptional audios to study. They are, once again, by Dr. Joel Beeke, President of PRTS, and Pastor at HRC.
1. Importance and Lack of Assurance2. Perseverance and Assurance3. Foundations of Assurance
Tim, et al.,Don’t scratch Holiness off your list until you have read the full version. In the longer version, Ryle adds multiple illustrations on the doctrines that you’ve covered so far. Lot Lingered is a chapter that many of my friends read repeatedly throughout the year. Ryle also goes deeper into the correlation between savoring Jesus Christ and growing in holiness. Everybody who has kept up so far and those who haven’t: Read the longer version! You won’t regret it.
Owen? Possibly “Communion with the Triune God”? That ought to make Justin Taylor happy.
Great read, but then again you can’t go wrong with anything from John Owen.
I lagged behind in reading “Holiness” and am still struggling to catch up. So many books (and distractions) so little time.
My favorite chapter, if that’s possible for this book.
“—it is a book that is as relevant and as important today as the day Ryle penned it. ”
Amen. I wish every seminary student would be required to read it. Then they would understand we need to pray that God would open our hearts to see sin for the evil that it is, and holiness as our calling, not happiness.
Thanks for taking us through this genuine classic Tim. I pray the Holy Spirit would enfold these teachings to our hearts and minds. Amen.
I would suggest that not just seminary students, but all that would claim the name christian should or would benefit. This has been an insightful and important read. I speak of and contemplate it often. I look forward to the next read, thanks again Mr. Tim.
J.C. Ryle wants you to sleep like a Calvinist…
I enjoyed every bit of this book! Each chapter is so rich; I know I’ll read it again. Thanks for choosing this one, Tim.
I haven’t counted or anything, but I think this last chapter had more scripture references than any of the others. I think that’s interesting since he writes early on in the chapter that there are many who would say that assurance is not a scriptural truth. Maybe he did that on purpose.
I think one “take away” for me is the importance of being diligent, always pressing forward, fighting spiritual laziness. This life of following Christ is rest and work at the same time.
Slightly tangential, but Ryle is a bit of a hero for me as a writer. His theolgizing and sermonizing are sound (as your summary again demonstrates), and he is readable today in a way that many of that era aren’t because he is so straightforward in his way of speaking. He is the master of ‘crucifying style’ for the sake of his readers.
He goes on to speak of a child who is the heir of a great fortune, yet is never made aware of the riches and wealth that are rightfully his. In this way a Christian may never come to know that assurance is his birthright and that he may have full confidence in the validity of his salvation.
This comparison, sadly, fails on the only point that matters. The child here is simply unaware. The Christian, however, does not lack awareness (he’s been told he’s “saved”); he lacks belief. He doubts the truth of what he’s been told. There is a huge difference between a) being entirely unaware of something, and b) finding something non-credible.
Just wanted to say that I joyfully finished the book. I am not excited simply to be done, rather I am pleased to have enjoyed both Ryle’s company and yours.
Thank you Tim and the many commenters for your diligence. May God achieve in you and and I Ryle’s hope for holiness.
Though I finished the book a week late, I thought it worth mentioning that this was my favorite chapter since the first. I think the tone of this chapter was different from many of the others, granting that someone may be a true believer without being an exemplary believer.
This chapter also seems an excellent stand alone study. I am going to use material from this chapter when speaking to a group of college students tomorrow.
Ken