Reading Classics Together - The Next Classic (Round 4)

To this point the “Reading Classics Together” effort has gone very well, at least by my assessment. We’ve read J.C. Ryle’s Holiness, John Owen’s Overcoming Sin and Temptation and A.W. Pink’s The Seven Sayings of the Saviour on the Cross. We’ve had hundreds of people participate by reading the books together and discussing them each week. All along we’ve been reading some of the classics of the Christian faith—books many of us wish to read but books few of us have ever made time for. And now it is time to decide on the next classic we’ll read together.

There are two names that were continually in my mind as I pondered where we should go next: John Calvin and Jonathan Edwards. The potential trouble with both of these men is that their seminal works are, in a word, long. If we are to read a long work I wonder if I may just be reading alone by the end. Regardless, I have decided that works of this quality will be worth it. And so I am proposing that our next book be The Religious Affections by Jonathan Edwards (all 350+ pages of it).

Here is what the Jonathan Edwards Center at Yale University says about the work:

A Treatise Concerning Religious Affections stands as Edwards’s most penetrating interpretation of the awakenings of his time, not to mention one of the most penetrating of any time. As in Some Thoughts, he argued against the extremes of emotionalism on the one hand and intellectualism on the other. Affections were essential to true religion, but they had to be tested. First, Edwards lays out his religious psychology of affections, which encompassed both understanding and will and involved the total range of human faculties. Answering critics of the revival, Edwards then discusses at length a series of “negative” signs, or unreliable criteria for judging the graciousness of affections. Finally, and most famously, he provided twelve “positive” signs for self-examination. The twelfth sign, which Edwards gave the fullest treatment, was the importance of Christian practice as evidence of the state of the heart. Here, for Edwards, was the ultimate standard for visible sainthood.

It is going to be a demanding read, and something of a long one, but I know the payoff will be worth every second spent in the book.

I will be reading from the Banner of Truth edition of the work, but you can follow along in any of the unabridged editions (of which there are many available). For technophiles, there is a Kindle edition available for only a couple of dollars. For those who are not interested in spending money, CCEL has the complete text available in HTML, PDF and other formats right here.

If you wish to purchase a printed copy of the book, you can do so from Amazon, Westminster Books, Monergism Books or just about anywhere else good Christian books are sold.

We will target July 17 as our start date. That gives you three full weeks to secure a copy and to read the Introduction and Preface. Then, every Thursday following, we’ll read a portion of the text and discuss it together.

It would be a helpful gauge of participation if you’d post a comment on this post indicating that you’d like to read this book with us. So if you are going to read along, let me know, either with a comment or a quick email. I’m looking forward to reading this next classic with you!

Comments (101)

1
Anonymous's picture

I’d like very much to read this book with you all. I had to drop out of the last read because I had a lot of sickness and just couldn’t concentrate. Lord willing I will be healthier and able to keep up with the group!

2
Anonymous's picture

I read Religious Affections a couple of years ago - this is a great excuse to re-read it.Sounds great Tim!

3
Anonymous's picture

I’ve read Religious Affections already, but I believe I’ll join you this time around anyway. It’s a wonderful book and I can only think my reading experience will be enriched by the shared experience of reading it and discussing it with others.

The thing that has always kept me back from joining before is the commitment. Therefore, I commit to begin with everyone else and then to do my very best to keep up as faithfully as I possibly can and as ‘real life’ allows.

4
Anonymous's picture

I’m in on this one, Tim.

5
Anonymous's picture

Add me to the list.

6
Anonymous's picture

Kindle edition on the way. I look forward to participating.

7
Anonymous's picture

Cool. I would like to participate as well. It’s going to be tough reading the Religious Affections, but it’s one of those books that I always wanted to read one day.

8
Anonymous's picture

I’ve never read this work, but I’m in and excited.

9
Anonymous's picture

I think I’m going to give this one a shot

10
Anonymous's picture

I’d love to join you. It will start in the middle of my vacation and study leave time, so a good time to start a new book. I’m hoping we’ll keep a moderate pace, so that we can all keep up with Edwards thoughts, plumb the depths and not get lost in it all. It’s been a long time since I’ve read this great work. I did so with a group of pastors in Iowa. We called ourselves “The Dead Theologians Society”, largely because we’d only read “dead guys” books.

11
Anonymous's picture

Tim:

I’ve always wanted to read this - so your suggestion is a catlyst for me. I’ll do it!

12
Anonymous's picture

Ditto to Brain

13
Anonymous's picture

I’m in.

14
Anonymous's picture

I’m in. “Coincidentally”, I just got a copy of this book earlier this week. I hope I have the time to participate on this one.

Peace & Blessings,Simple Mann

15
Anonymous's picture

I’m interested in reading Religious Affections, but next time, can we go something a little lighter? It also might be healthy to read a non-Calvinist (or pre-Calvinist).

16
Anonymous's picture

I’m game

17
Anonymous's picture

I just finished “Jonathan Edwards On Knowing Christ” and have never read Religous Affections. I will also particpate. Thank you as always for great suggestions.

18
Anonymous's picture

Wow, Tim - swinging for the stands with this one, huh? Should be a good read - I’ll do my best to keep up.

19
Anonymous's picture

I’m in. Thanks, Tim.

20
Anonymous's picture

Count me in! I haven’t chewed on something this weighty in quite a while. I’m excited!

21
Anonymous's picture

I started off well with Seven Sayings, but I fell behind and am just now finishing it up, but I still greatly valued the discussions and input of you and everyone else. I “read” Religious Affections when it was the free download at christianaudio, and that just made me want to go through it more in-depth. What a great opportunity! Plus I’ve been telling myself I need to buy a copy of it for the longest time. It looks like now is the time!

22
Anonymous's picture

What a great way to be diligent about completing a very difficult yet edifying book. I look forward to starting it with you all.

23
Anonymous's picture

I’m in.

I have never read Edwards and I have a feeling that I’m going to have to buy another bookshelf after we are through.

24
Anonymous's picture

I would definitely like to take the challenge with you Tim! It’s always good to tackle a massive work like this with other folks, looking forward to it! Ron Reffett

25
Anonymous's picture

I’m in.

26
Anonymous's picture

Sounds great. Looking forward to it.

27
Anonymous's picture

I’m in!

28
Anonymous's picture

I can’t wait!!!! Great choice. It’s always good to challenge people.

29
Anonymous's picture

Yea! I’m in too! :)

30
Anonymous's picture

I’m in. Read it in high school, but I’m not sure if I finished.

31
Anonymous's picture

i’m in. sounds like a good time.

32
Anonymous's picture

I’m in. Will secure a copy asap.

33
Anonymous's picture

Count me in!

34
Anonymous's picture

I’m in - can’t wait!

35
Anonymous's picture

You can count me in too! Thanks for the challenge to read these great works…

36
Anonymous's picture

I’ve only recently subscribed to your blog Tim. I came in too late on your last “reading classics together” session, so I’m eager to engage in this one. I’ve wanted to attempt a go at Edwards in the past, but have been a bit too intimidated. This will be great having you and this community of believers to help me wade through the supposedly deep waters of Edwards’ classic work. Can’t wait to get started!

37
Anonymous's picture

Count me in! My son has gone through a couple of books with you. We’re both looking forward to tackling Edwards together.

38
Anonymous's picture

i am new to this site but count me in!! am looking forward to reading such a book with others.

39
Anonymous's picture

I’ve got a 1959 Yale copy sitting on my nightstand right now just waiting for the right moment to start reading it. I guess this is it. Count me in.

Due to my vacation, I missed the discussion of last two chapters of the Seven Sayings, by Pink. But I really enjoyed the part I was able to participate in.

40
Anonymous's picture

I’m in. Looking forward to it.

41
Anonymous's picture

In!

42
Anonymous's picture

Greetings from Freeport, IL.

I am new to your website and have enjoyed reading your bookreviews and such these past few weeks. I recently purchased your book, “The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment” and am enjoying in very much and finding it helpful. My husband wants to read it next.I would like to join in on reading classics with you, so I am going to purchase “Religious Affections” by Johathon Edwards. Thanks!

Grace!Linda Rios

43
Anonymous's picture

oddly enough, we’re beginning a breakfast discussion group on “The Religious Affections” tomorrow morning here in Newfoundland.

I’m in (though I’ll already have read much of it by your start date)

44
Anonymous's picture

I’m in!

45
Anonymous's picture

You had me at “To this point the…”

I just finished reading Signs of the Spirit (Storms) and was planning on reading this soon anyway…so this is perfect…

You’re by far my favorite Canadian blogger.

46
Anonymous's picture

also remember that you can read it in the Banner of Truth Edition (2 vol set), or the Hendrickson edition, The “offical” yale edition, plus the audio download.

47
Anonymous's picture

Does any of you know whether “Religious Affections” has been printed out in a language other than English? Specifically Spanish? Thanks!

48
Anonymous's picture

I’d definitely like to join this time!

49
Anonymous's picture

I’m definitely joining. Its sounds great.

50
Anonymous's picture

I’ll be reading with you, really looking forward to it. Hope I can keep up, the internet is a bit dodgy in this part of Zambia!