Skip to content ↓

Book Review – Charismatic Chaos

Book Reviews Collection cover image

Before I begin a review of Charismatic Chaos it is only fair to point out that I have really come to appreciate John MacArthur Jr. I cannot think of many contemporary authors whose beliefs and theology line up so closely with my own. So having been challenged to discern what the Bible says about speaking in tongues, signs and wonders and other marks of the charismatic movement, it only made sense that I would read Charismatic Chaos. Though written over twenty years ago, this book is as relevant to the Christian world today as it was then. The edition I read is the second edition, which was updated and published in 1992.

In recent years the Charismatic movement has completely infiltrated the church. Aspects of the movement are visible in almost every denomination. And as the movement grows in strength and acceptance it becomes more and more bizarre. It is not unusual to hear about flat tires being healed, fillings in teeth being turned to gold and other baffling (and unproven) phenomena. Almost any time of day or night there is a channel showing a faith healer healing with a touch or knocking people to the ground. Left unchecked, the movement will continue to grow and spread, becoming ever more strange.

The main issues MacArthur focuses on are modern day prophecies, ongoing revelation, Biblical interpretation, miracles, healings, tongues, and the “health and wealth” gospel. Ultimately, his arguments against these are based on a few points of doctrine.

First and foundationally, MacArthur teaches that experience cannot be accepted as a valid test of truth. Experience is only valid if it conforms to God’s word. This is hardly groundbreaking theology, yet is theology that has been forsaken by many Christian churches. Experiences can never be held as co-equal in importance to the Bible. Where there is a conflict the Bible must always prevail.

Second, he teaches that God’s inspired revelation ended with the closing of Scripture. Though God still reveals Himself, He no longer does so in an inspired way. Therefore, no other revelation can be held equal to the Bible. This puts all other revelation in subjection to Biblical principles.

Third, he teaches that the signs and wonders done by the apostles ended with the end of the apostolic era. These were signs given by God to achieve a specific purpose. They were given to prove that the apostles were God’s messengers on earth and that they were trustworthy sources of teaching. MacArthur shows how even through the Bible we see the signs disappearing so that even before the close of Scripture with the writing of the book of Revelation, these signs and miracles had ceased. This does not mean that God can no longer perform miraculous deeds. It does mean, though, that God no longer uses men to initiate these miracles as he did in Biblical times. Speaking in tongues also falls into the category of gifts that were given by God for a short time and a specific purpose.

MacArthur deals lovingly yet necessarily harshly with the Charismatic movement. He pulls no punches in rooting out the teachings that he considers dangerous. He does this all from a very simple, Biblical viewpoint. He does not waver in his view that the Charismatic teachings go directly against the pure simplicity of the gospel.

A fantastic Biblical examination of the Charismatic movement, this book comes with my emphatic recommendation.

Title: Charismatic Chaos
Author: John MacArthur Jr.
Published: 1992

Key Words:

  • Charismatic movement
  • Speaking In Tongues
  • Miracles
  • Signs And Wonders

  • Would you support my work

    Would You Consider Supporting My Work?

    Challies.com has been free for 23 years and will stay that way. Once a year I ask readers to consider supporting the work through Patreon, PayPal, or by mail. Today’s that day!

  • thurs 3

    A La Carte (November 19)

    The hardest day you may ever face / For the ones like me / Praying to the God who rules history / Dear Gen Alpha, Claude wants to turn you into a toad / Old dogs and new tricks / Getting a handle on our emotions / Kindle deals and more

  • Demolition

    What Takes 20 Years to Build Takes 5 Minutes to Destroy

    I think we’ve all heard many variations of the adage, “It takes 20 years to build a reputation, but only five minutes to destroy it.” A good name that has been established through many years of honor, success, or skilled leadership can be ruined in a moment when an act of immorality comes to light.

  • A La Carte (November 18)

    Remembering John Allen Chau / How to experience gospel transformation / The quiet voice / What we get wrong about the tears of Jesus / I thought adultery had been approved / The singularity will never happen / Kindle deals, videos, and more

  • Christian Books This Week

    This Week in Christian Books (November 17, 2026)

    This is a big week, thanks largely to Christian Focus, which releases its whole November list in one go. It also brings a new edition of J. I. Packer’s Truth and Power, Matthew Westerholm’s Biblical Worship, Randy Alcorn’s major book on what the Bible says about animals, and the newest volume in the Reformed Expository…

  • A La Carte (November 17)

    Classroom apologetics / Can we legitimately judge a person’s faith? / Lord, why am I still here? / The world is always burning / Frank Peretti and the 40th anniversary of This Present Darkness / The best way to serve your local church / Kindle deals, new books, and more