It's Not Fair!

A couple of months ago I was having one of those mornings. I was in a grumpy mood to begin with and was grumbling as I headed downstairs to find that the children's lunches remained unmade. With just a few minutes before they had to be out the door and on the school bus I set to work on one of my least favorite routine jobs. As I did so I grumbled, "It's just not fair!" And in that very moment I had a little epiphany. Nothing's fair. Fairness is not a concept that has any business in the Christian life. I gain nothing by focusing on fairness. I repented and got to work with a whole new attitude. The day got better. The more I've thought about it the more I've realized that there was something to my thought that day. Worrying about fairness is a spiritual and emotional dead end.

It was not long after this little episode that a new book showed up in my mailbox. Written by Wayne Mack and Deborah Howard it is titled simply It's Not Fair. Mack deals with the very attitude I had fallen into. "From years of personal and counseling experience," he writes, "I know that nothing is more damaging to us spiritually, emotionally, mentally, and behaviorally than responding to the unpleasant, unwanted, and (in our judgment) undeserved attitude of life with the 'it's not fair' attitude." We fight against this attitude with a properly knowledge of who God is. "Nothing is more helpful to us in overcoming the tragic results of being infected with the 'it's not fair' attitude than possessing the knowledge of who and what God really is and the implications of that knowledge."

In this book, Mack focuses on four aspects of God's character that he thinks are the most useful in counteracting and destroying the devastation brought about by the "it's not fair" attitude. He looks to God's wisdom, love, sovereignty and justice. These characteristics, taken individually and together, counter an attitude that we are somehow getting less than we deserve. "Sometimes we are angry at other people, and sometimes we're angry about situations or circumstances. Ultimately, we are angry with God, regardless of how well we disguise it--even to ourselves."

And so he turns to God's omniscience and wisdom to show that God knows all that is happening and that he makes no mistakes; he turns to God's love to show that he loves us deeply and to encourage us to see God's character not through our feelings but through the lens of Scripture; he turns to God's justice to show that God will not and cannot do anything that is unjust or unfair and that God is committed to giving us what we need, not what we want; and he looks to God's omnipotence and sovereignty to show that God is in control of all of life's circumstances and that nothing happens outside of his will. Final chapters focus on practical application and case studies.

This book had its genesis in a biblical counseling class. The origins are visible throughout. There are vast amounts of Scripture included in the book and long studies in the character of God. Each chapter concludes with an appropriate hymn and with questions for study and application. It is an eminently practical book and one that looks always to the heart. It is a book that answers sin with gospel. I am glad to recommend it to you. I think it is a valuable read for any Christian and one that may have a useful place in a church library.

Comments (8)

1
Anonymous's picture

I agree that all too often we scream "its not fair" not because there is a break in justice, but because we are taken out of our normal selfish attitude. But what about when we see people in the world dying from hunger? Or what about those within North America, one of the richest places in the world, who cannot afford food and shelter?

I wonder if our "It's not fair" attitude could be an indication that this world is broken and not filled with the justice that God intended it to have. When we see these things and cry "its not fair", we express the heart of God for justice, for righteousness, for shalom. We join with the prophets in calling people to make things right. We join with those in the psalms who cry out time and again to God that "its not fair".

While I see the value of ignoring our natural tendency to cry foul when our own selfishness is challenged, I am not convinced that it is never right to cry "its not fair."

2
Anonymous's picture

Chad,

You're probably right. Perhaps I should have stated that I'm referring primarily to the "interpersonal" kind of it's not fair attitude. Certainly what you're talking about does clue us into the fact that all is not right in the world. Though even then the concept of fairness may not be quite the right way of thinking about things.

3
Anonymous's picture

Hey Tim,
I loved this book, it came to me as well at a very appropriate time. I lost my first wife to breast cancer back in 2004, since that time I have remarried but still struggle with the feeling that "it's just not fair". She was only 35.
The book came at a time when these thoughts were almost overwhelming. I always am amazed at how God uses great books to speak to our hearts and to speak to us in our dark days. Thanks for posting this today.
Blessings
Ron Reffett

4
Anonymous's picture

Wayne Mack is a favorite author of mine, and am working towards a biblical counseling degree, so will be ordering this book today. Thank you for this post.

5
Anonymous's picture

Good (and convicting) post... actually what would be "fair" or "just" would be for all of us to go to hell. Thankfully, Christ took that punishment for us. We have been given the gift of salvation through the grace and mercy of the triune God. One should not complain about fairness when one has been saved by God's grace!

The Aspiring Theologian
The Knight of the Living God Blog

6
Anonymous's picture

When I was younger, there were things which happened in my family which I thought were very unfair, and for too many years those unfair things were a stumblingblock to spiritual growth. One of the things which helped me to get past unfairness was applying Genesis 50:19-20: But Joseph said to them, "Do not be afraid, for am I in God's place? As for you, you meant evil against me, but God meant it for good.... (NASB).

I've read Wayne Mack's books with great profit for a number of years. I didn't know about this one, but it will be one of my next book purchases. Thanks.

7
Anonymous's picture

Thanks for the good review and recommendation. A lot of years ago someone either told me or I read that, pertaining to marriage, you should take the word "fair" out of your vocabulary. That advice really helped me and I've shared it with other wives through the years. But...do I apply this to my other relationships? Hmm...food for thought. B.

8
Anonymous's picture

I'm almost finished with D.A. Carson's "How Long, O Lord".

Every Christian needs to be prepared, undergirded with the theological foundations of evil and suffering, so that when the hard times hit he or she will be in a place to still give God glory and be in righteousness, peace, and joy.

http://underdogtheology.blogspot.com/