- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous PostA La Carte (2/10)
- Next Post »A La Carte (2/11)
Imprisoned in Haiti
- 02/10/10
- 18
Last spring I received an email from a reader of this site who asked if I would be able to send an inscribed copy of The Discipline of Spiritual Discernment to a young man who was just graduating high school. This would serve as a small graduation gift. I was glad to do so and sent the book to Silas Thompson. You may know that name now as Silas is currently in a Haitian prison, arrested and charged with child abduction and criminal association. He is there with his father Paul and eight other Americans. You have undoubtedly heard of the story through the media.
The details have been a little bit difficult to piece together and reading Christian publications provides a slightly different story than reading stories in the mainstream media outlets. What we do know is that shortly after the earthquake, a team of Americans headed to Haiti to attempt to take a busload of orphaned children into neighboring Dominican Republic. They were stopped at the border and arrested under suspicion of attempting to traffic those children. Beyond that, there seems to be a lot of confusion. Googling “haiti missionaries” and “Laura Silsby” turns up a wealth of stories from varied perspectives. But do read at least several stories since you’ll see that many of the details are disputed.

Click to view a series of photos
Yesterday I had the opportunity to interview Renee Thompson, wife to Paul and mother to Silas. I asked her what she knows and how her son and husband are faring in their Haitian prison.
Can you tell how your husband and son found themselves in Haiti so soon after the earthquake?
Paul has always had a heart for people who are hurting, and when the earthquake hit Haiti, he knew he wanted to go and help somehow. A sister church called our church to let us know about a mission trip that was being organized by one of their members. They said they needed some help, and asked if anyone from our church wanted to go. The purpose of the mission trip was to rescue orphans who were at a Haitian orphanage that had been destroyed by the earthquake and take them to a hotel in the Dominican Republic. The hotel, which was being leased by the mission’s organizer and was in need of repairs, would house the orphans while a permanent facility was being built. The mission volunteers would help to repair the hotel and take care of the orphans who were brought there. Paul decided to go, as did our youngest son, Silas, who had earlier talked about wanting to help in Haiti.
Tell me about the circumstances surrounding their arrest?
I wish I had details to tell you. We could only communicate through a cell phone and coverage in Haiti was sketchy at best, so we didn’t get to talk much. The last time I talked with him, the mission volunteers were at the border with the children, ready to cross into the Dominican Republic, when they learned that they were missing one bit of paperwork. The group leader was going to go back to Port-au-Prince early the next morning to get that paperwork completed, then once she returned, they’d cross the border into the DR. That was the last time I talked with Paul. The next morning, I got a call that they had been arrested.
Laura Silsby is generally being blamed for this situation, some suggesting she was well-intentioned but ignorant, others suggesting she was knowingly doing something illegal. What is your understanding of her role?
Actually, I’ve never met Laura, and I’ve only talked to her once on the phone. In the same way that it breaks my heart to hear people judging my husband and my son without knowing the truth, I just won’t judge Laura and what she has or hasn’t done because I don’t know what the truth is. And at this point, I am not willing to expend any energy or emotion on placing blame or being angry. I need a clear head so that I can help my guys, so that’s where my focus has to be.
It seems that this situation has been sensationalized, at least a little bit, through the mainstream media. Is that the case?
By nature, people are drawn to stories, especially when they’re unpredictable and have many different angles. While I would prefer to live our lives outside of the spotlight, I understand the public’s desire to know what’s going on, whether out of curiosity or concern. I do look forward to moving on without all of the attention.
How is the U.S. government involved at this point? Are they able to give you any hope or assurance?
A representative from the State Department keeps us updated on the situation as much as possible. When news reports were saying the men and women were put into separate prisons, the representative quickly looked into it and let the families know that the reports were untrue. I was so thankful they did that for us. We’re also in contact with our Idaho delegation—Senators Risch and Crapo and Representative Mike Simpson.
Are your husband and son (and the others) safe where they are now? Are you able to stay in touch with them at all?
We know through the situation updates from the State Department and our Idaho delegation that they are safe, they have food and water, and that they are together. And we can see on news reports that they still look okay. In fact, today I saw that Paul was wearing a different shirt!
We are able to get messages to Paul and Silas through the State Department, as well. All of the families have a designated email address where we can send notes to our loved ones. The State Department relays those notes to the embassy in Haiti, and the embassy representatives take the notes to the prison when they go for their visits. We can not receive notes back from them, but at least we’re able to encourage them and let them know we love them.
What is the latest on their situation?
It’s hard to know because so many things happen in the background that we don’t even know about. What we do know is that they are safe, they’re together, and there are a lot of people working hard to get them released.
What is God teaching you through all of this?
He’s teaching me to extol him at all times. Psalm 34 was the first place I landed after hearing Paul and Silas were arrested. These pages in my Bible are wrinkled from being wet with my tears. The first verse says, “I will extol the Lord at all times; His praise will always be on my lips.” The chapter goes on to talk about the Lord delivering his own, yet I always come back to the fact that I need to extol the Lord at all times, no matter my circumstances. Three days after the guys were detained, I heard a man on a show talking about taking God’s name in vain. He said that if you complain to God about a situation he’s taking you through, you are taking his name in vain because God is taking you through the current experience to mold you to be more like Him. My desire right now is to allow God to make me more like Him. In the last eleven days, I have faltered, struggled in fear, and cried out in frustration, yet I come back to my need to extol the Lord at all times.
Are there very specific things we can pray for on their behalf?
Please pray for endurance, courage, safety, and health for all of them. We’re hearing reports that some of them have required medical attention, and one young lady is diabetic. And please pray scripture.

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I write books and blogs for fun while doing web design and consulting for a living. I worship and serve at 
Comments (18)
Thanks Tim…General background information can help us discern what is likely to be true or false as we read news reports.
Am I the only one that thinks it seems very providential that we find another “Paul and Silas” in prison? I wonder ….Jodi
I read you every day Tim. I am so pleased you did this interview. I want to tell you that coming from Idaho this has been hard to read about in the local news. They go after people relentlessly instead of screaming let them out of prison. Go figure, have to have a villan in the story. I too would not judge Laura Silsby. We do not know the details and I find it repugnant to go after any or all of these imprisoned people without their ability to speak and defend themselves. It is all irrelevant anyway. I did not go to Haiti. They went to help! Sheesh!!! Praying for their safe release.
The thing I find most interesting/disturbing is the fact that the Haitian government seems disabled at every level except this one.
Let’s just hope that at least God doesn’t send a great earthquake to free them…praying the Haitian jailer believes, along with his whole household! And that they would not lose heart and be used of God to witness to many!
My 70 year old Grandmother was hoping to be with this group on their trip, but her passport was expired so she had to stay here in Idaho. She has a heart for orphans and the needy, and was so excited about this trip. I, selfishly, am beyond grateful to God for detaining her here.
But that is the heart of those who went…..the impulse to serve, to alleviate pain, and to help those in need.
The media has crucified them, (even our local media). Pray for their release, and for God’s power to be demostrated to everyone who is watching these events.
I have been following this story and annoyed with much of the mainstream medias reporting . To be honest having read much about Haiti even before the quake , I’m suspicious of all forms of policing and government. I simply don’t trust a word that proceeds form any authority . Even after the quake the leader of Haiti looked overwhelmed and still has offered little leadership in this situation.
Thanks for the info Tim , we will keep praying for the truth and hopefully the release of people I think were misguided or caught in a country that lacks any clear central authority. Haiti justice and law are not known for fairness .
Dr. Richard Bacon: I have had the exact same thoughts. MarieP. : I like your whit and truth.
Thanks for this excellent interview Tim. I pray for justice and grace for all involved.
Praying Proverbs 21:1.
I praise God for you, Renee. Continuing in prayer for your guys, and all the missionaries.
Thank you Tim for this interview, the truth needs to be told.
Like Dr. Bacon, I too find it disturbing how the Haitian government is dealing with this while private security firms are shooting looters in the streets.
Tom
I am a friend of Paul and Silas and it breaks my heart to hear the judgements that most people are casting upon these people. If only the rest of the world would see these people as everyone that knows them see them. They are of the world’s finest. They are upstanding americans and we could all learn something from their character. I am thankful for media outlets such as this that do not search for truths that simply aren’t there. We all need to pray instead of judge. Hold mercy in our hearts instead of condemnation. How are we to be the light of the world if we are spewing darkness out of our mouths? Praise God for all things! He will cause ALL THINGS to work together for His Glory!
Outstanding interview, Tim. And may God bless Renee and her family.
It seems many of the commenters here have not been pleased with the spin of most media.
I have a hard time believing any unrelated group of ten with no history of child endangerment, neglect or exploitation went into Haiti to conspire together to victimize children. At worst it seems they were not properly documented. Most people in Haiti are probably not properly documented at this point.
The nastiness hurled at this group in the main stream media, and particularly by commenters on stories on the internet, has been a revelation to me.
None of the commenters critical of these folks indicated they had started any orphanages or helped any orphans themselves.
I will weigh in on a couple of things, hopefully objectively for all to see.
These people are not in prison for their faith. They would be in prison if they were muslim, hindu or whatever. The bold truth is that they are in prison because they tried to take children outside of their country without proper documentation. That is the objective truth. They are not in prison because they are Christians. Let’s not make the martyrs.
These people are not missionaries. They are volunteers who were working with an orphanage. You are misidentifying them. If you want to call them orphanage workers. That would be closer to the truth.
I will not try and weigh the motives of any of the people in the prison.
Thank you so much for posting this. How can we get that out? That is what we need to hear. I am a friend of the Thompson family and is hurts my heart to hear what they are going through.
Rick,
I find it hard to believe that muslims or hindus would be jailed for the same offense, much less suffer the same journalistic rush to judgement. The media has pushed them towards martyrdom more than these comments.
Respectufully,Tom
From Reuters today:
“A Haitian judge said on Thursday he had ruled in favor of the release of 10 U.S. missionaries accused of kidnapping 33 children and trying to take them out of the earthquake-stricken country.
“I just signed the request for the release of the 10 Americans submitted by the lawyers and I have sent it to the prosecutor’s office,” Judge Bernard Sainvil said.
Under Haitian law, the prosecutor can formally comment on the judge’s decision but he cannot overrule it.
Sainvil earlier told Reuters that once the prosecutor had given his opinion, he could formally issue a release order.
“They can go directly to the airport if they want and leave, but they should provide a guarantee of representation if further questions need to be asked,” he said.”
Rick, I think that they were persecuted, not just for being Christians, but also for being Americans. The hostility against American by officials and the UN folks has been widely reported.
Their largest mistake was probably not giving bribes when they were trying to cross the border. Our hopsital sent a team of Dr.’s to Haiti a few days after the earthquake. They flew into the Dominican Republic and when they came to the first fence they handed out beer to the guards only to come to a much bigger fence- the one that mattered. They had already distributed “the contribution” and the border guards made them get out of the vehicle (packed full of medical supplies) and had them sit next to a guard who pulled out his gun loading and reloading- probably for intimidation. All of this occured while Secretary of State Clinton was on the phone trying to convince the border guards to let the Dr.’s and nurses come into to help the Haitian people. After hours of negotiation the group was finally allowed to pass. Sadly, even admist the disaster there are plenty of Haitians trying to make a profit. I wouldn’t be suprised if this group of volunteers had the same issue. Perhaps the guards were using them to get bribes.