- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous PostHow I Got Here (Part 3)
- Next Post »A La Carte (10/26)
Contemporary Hymns
- 10/25/10
- 24
One of the happier musical developments in the Christian world over the past few years has been the resurgence of hymns. Though there are many contemporary worship songs that have excellent content and are ideal for congregational worship, we just can’t afford to lose the hymn.
There are two different kinds of contemporary hymn. In the first place, we have artists writing new hymns that come complete with new tunes. Alongside that we have artists who are finding old hymns and setting them to new music—either completely new melodies or contemporary adaptations of the traditional ones. In the list I’ve offered below, the first two seem to specialize in new hymns and new music while the others focus on the new music.
(Yes, there are many, many other artists writing new hymns or adapting old ones. I am focusing here on artists whose albums are predominantly composed of contemporary hymns)
Getty Music
Keith Getty grew frustrated with the songs his church was singing. He met up with Stuart Townend and together they decided to try to write something better. They ended up with “In Christ Alone.” The rest, as they say, is history. Keith got married to Kristyn, moved to America (he’s Irish by birth), toured the world, wrote many more great hymns, and recorded a handful of albums, most of which have a distinctly Irish feel. And the Christian world has been so much better for it. The most recent collection of hymns is titled Awaken the Dawn. Many of these songs are perfectly suited to congregational worship (already at Grace Fellowship Church we sing “By Faith,” “Creation Sings the Father’s Song” and “Communion Hymn.”).
If you want to learn more, it may be worth beginning with their YouTube channel. There you’ll be able to hear some of their best songs and hear them at their best through videos of their live performances. And trust me when I say it’s absolutely worth trying to catch their shows—their band is amazingly talented and they put on a very enjoyable, worshipful show (though somehow show doesn’t seem like the proper descriptor). If you want to learn about their tour schedule (try to catch one of their Christmas shows!) or buy one of their albums, visit gettymusic.com. I suggest you begin with Awaken the Dawn if you like albums, and each of the songs I’ve already mentioned if you prefer individual tracks.
Stuart Townend
Stuart Townend is the other half of the writing duo that has produced some of Keith Getty’s most popular hymns (including “In Christ Alone” and “The Power of the Cross”) but he has also written many without Keith’s help, including “How Deep the Father’s Love” and “Beautiful Savior.” Keith releases albums under his own name but also appears on other albums (such as Keswick Live, one I quite enjoy).
To learn more about Townend, it’s probably best to visit his web site (stuarttownend.co.uk). The site remains just a little bit underdeveloped, but still has lots of useful information, including a tour schedule and a blog. I’d recommend buying Keswick Live (if you can find it and if you enjoy live worship music) or Creation Sings if you prefer a studio album. If you prefer to just buy songs, go with “In Christ Alone,” “How Deep the Father’s Love,” “Speak, O Lord” and “The Power of the Cross.”
Indelible Grace
Indelible Grace is probably the granddaddy of these artists that write new tunes for old hymns. They have revisited such old favorites as “Abide with Me” and “For All the Saints” and have largely done so very well. They’ve also introduced us to old and long-forgotten hymns, drawing them out of obscurity. They have recorded 6 albums to this point and along the way have featured songs by a great group of artists including Sandra McCracken, Derek Webb, Jars of Clay, Matthew Perryman Jones and many others.
I have enjoyed each of their albums, but if I had to choose just one to recommend, I’d probably send you to Indelible Grace 3: For All the Saints. Jars of Clays’ adaptation of “For All the Saints” is just so good.
You’ll also want to take a look at the music of Matthew Smith who helped found Indelible Grace but who has recorded several independent projects as well.
Red Mountain Church
Red Mountain Church specializes in writing new tunes for old and all-but-forgotten hymns. They have released 6 albums to this point, many of them relating to a particular theme: Christmas, Heaven, the hymns originally collected in the hymnal of William Gadsby.
My favorite of the albums is The Gadsby Project. Be sure to listen right to the end to catch the song “Come Boldly to the Throne of Grace.” You can find one of their other albums, “Help My Unbelief” at NoiseTrade if you want to try it for free or trade some information for it.
Page CXVI
Page CXVI could probably use a catchier name (it’s taken from page 116 of a copy of The Magician’s Nephew by C.S. Lewis). But don’t let the name drive you off. They are a little bit more like Indelible Grace, writing new tunes for much-loved hymns (or creating slightly adapted but contemporary versions of the traditional tunes).
You can learn more and buy their 2 albums at pagecxvi.com. You’ll also find a tour schedule there in case you’d like to catch one of their forthcoming shows in CO, KS, OK or TX.
The Songs We Sing
While we are on the subject of hymns, here are some good words from J.C. Ryle (drawn from J.C. Ryle Quotes):
Good hymns are an immense blessing to the Church of Christ. I believe the last day alone will show the world the real amount of good they have done. They suit all, both rich and poor. There is an elevating, stirring, soothing, spiritualizing, effect about a thoroughly good hymn, which nothing else can produce. It sticks in men's memories when texts are forgotten. It trains men for heaven, where praise is one of the principal occupations. Preaching and praying shall one day cease for ever; but praise shall never die. The makers of good ballads are said to sway national opinion. The writers of good hymns, in like manner, are those who leave the deepest marks on the face of the Church.
But really good hymns are exceedingly rare. There are only a few men in any age who can write them. You may name hundreds of first-rate preachers for one first-rate writer of hymns. Hundreds of so-called hymns fill up our collections of congregational psalmody, which are really not hymns at all. They are very sound, very scriptural, very proper, very correct, very tolerably rhymed; but they are not real, live, genuine hymns. There is no life about them. At best they are tame, pointless, weak, and milk-and-watery.

I am a follower of Jesus Christ, a husband to Aileen and a father to three young children. I worship and serve as a pastor at
Releasing on April 1, The Next
Comments (24)
Another example of the latter kind (new music, old words) is Ascend the Hill, who just released an album of hymns called “Take the World, but Give me Jesus” - named after the hymn of the same name, which is one of the songs on the album. Their style is more along the lines of technical yet sprawling indie rock (which may mean nothing to some of you), but the tone and the presentation are utterly worshipful and thoroughly enjoyable.
Best of all, you can download their album for free (or whatever you’d like to pay for it) at their label’s website http://www.comeandlive.com - definitely worth checking out, as the label releases all its albums on this “pay what you like, including nothing” format, since their focus is on releasing excellent, Christ-exalting music to as wide an audience as possible.
I agree. The trend to bring hymns back is a real delight.
Personally, I love Ashley Cleveland. She’s a rocker, blues-woman who has some chops.Listen to her sing “Gimme Shelter”http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=74qWOdNYjLc
But now she has rediscovered the hymns and now almost exclusively sings them…
I was at a Laity Lodge retreat earlier this month and she had us open the hymn books and we sang one amazing sone after another.
How about this one, “Revive us Again”http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vYY0z7hEh0Y
Davidwww.RedLetterBelievers.com“Salt and Light”
If you make lists of predominately “new” hymns or predominately “recycled” hymns you’ll miss out on Shane and Shane who do both of those incredibly well in addition to adapting Psalms to new arrangements. Definitely worth checking out.
Thanks for drawing attention to one of my favorite genres of worship music.
If you’ll pardon a bit of self-promotion on my part (since I couldn’t mention it otherwise), I just released an album called New Creation featuring some of my original settings of hymns by Luther, Torrey, Wesley, Watts, and even Charles Spurgeon. Details are at this post on my website.
There aren’t a great many contemporary Christian worship songs that work well for congregational singing. There are definitely a few I know of. Some churches like to use contemporary songs, which are often in the pop category of style and that may be good songs in themselves, but don’t realize how problematic they are for congregational use (for a variety of reasons). We have a lot of older and ailing folks in our congregation who really appreciate the singability of hymns (I do too). Thanks for the lists, I appreciate all those artists and albums as well.
Even better - check out the work of Matthew Curl at http://www.intownchurch.com/music/ - some of the very best of Psalms, Psalter, and “great old hymns” set to contemporary sound.
Hey Tim, Thanks for the kind words about Indelible Grace. I love that Ryle quote too. Any idea where that first appeared? I have a couple different editions of Ryle’s Hymnbook he edited too. So many of our “preacher heroes” spent much time and effort working on hymnals too you know: Spurgeon, Whitefield, Ryle, Bonar, are just a few.
@ Kevin Twit:
The J.C. Ryle quote that Tim provided regarding “good hymns being a blessing to the church…” comes from Ryle’s book entitled Christian Leaders of the 18th Century.
Visit the post below and click the link at the bottom of the quote:
http://jcrylequotes.com/2010/10/19/the-songs-we-sing-make-a-difference/
Hope this helps Kevin.
Soli Deo Gloria!
I personally do not see a need for “new” hymns, or “new music” to old hymns.I am at a loss to understand the reasoning for this?I cannot fully explain it, but it just doesn’t sit well with my spirit.
so people 200 years ago could write good music but we cant today?
The type of music people like has changed so we write new songs. We all so recycle great lyrics and put them to new tunes. How could this be a bad thing?
The folks over at Sovereign Grace Music have released several albums of contemporary hymns, including a collection of songs inspired by Valley of Vision:
http://www.sovereigngracemusic.org/albums
Berean,It’s more likely just that it doesn’t sit well with your ears. Your preference in music (which you’re fully entitled to!) simply differs from most of the rest of us. There’s nothing wrong with that.
That being said, for most of us, the music that accompanies the great words of the old hymns is something that we simply can’t enjoy, so the opportunity to celebrate the truths they proclaim set to music that resonates with us is something that we (with Tim) celebrate here.
My friend Pete Andrews and the good folks at Outreach Red Bank here in NJ have been putting out quality music featuring old hymns to new music. Give a listen to The New Ancients at http://www.theorb.org/
This may sound like a really crazy question, but I’m actually unsure:
How do we know what to classify as a “hymn”? I tend to think of hymns as older, more traditional songs, but that definition doesn’t cooperate with songs people like Getty and Townend are writing. Yet, I agree they do feel much more like whatever the vague notion of a “hymn” is!
Before people decide what kind of hymn music they like they should read “A Call For Reformation In The Contemporary Christian Music Industry:by Steven John Camp.” A copy can be found at: http://www.solideogloria.org/about/beliefs/steve-camps-107-thesis/
Do not put words in my mouth, I did not say that good music cannot be written today, or that said music is a bad thing.
Great post, thank you. I love spicing up old hymns with new arrangements. They are soaked in doctrinal meat that you can sink your teeth into and such a contrast to the “love songs to Jesus” fluffy stuff…
All of the folks you mentioned are GREAT, highly recommended.
I have also recently discovered Enfield - http://www.resolved.org/music/ and have introduced a few of their arrangements…”Jesus Shall Reign” and “Jesus I My Cross Have Taken” good stuff!
Thanks again.
M
I’m wondering if what you mean by, “it just doesn’t sit will with my spirit,” is that you simply do not prefer the “new” hymns. There are many things that we don’t prefer or even like. And really, it’s OK to not prefer something. It’s just important not to mistake that preference for a non-negotiable, spiritual absolute. Scripture doesn’t ban Christians from writing new songs. And unlike Scripture, the hymnic canon is not closed. We should heartily welcome any finely crafted, biblical lyric [new or old] that helps to stir up our affections for God and his gospel.
@ CS, it’s not a crazy question and there is a lot of varied opinion on what constitutes a hymn. I remembered an article from reformedworship.org that tries to paint a picture of what a good hymn is and does. Here are two points from it that I like:
2. Good hymns have words of beauty, dignity, reverence, and simplicity. Whether their theme is one of lofty exultation or a simple expression of trust, good hymns are chaste, precise, and lovely in their utterance. Their language is clear and concise. They are never glib, never pat, never extravagant, never trite; they are always true. Emotionally warm and fervent, they are never sentimental. They speak beautifully, feelingly, compellingly, and with restraint of the things of God. They do not transgress the limits of good taste in concept, word, or setting. They cannot give offense.
3. Good hymns are adult in word and tone. They do not insult intelligence by requiring us to sing immortal truths in childish or unsuitable modes of expression, or to sloppy, sentimental tunes. While remaining true to the Gospel, they contain nothing to embarrass or bewilder outsiders, but rather will speak to them of a deep, sincere, vital experience of God. Their figures of speech will be in keeping with the worth-ship of God and will have meaning for the contemporary Christian.
The article also talks a little about composition, meter, etc. You can read it at http://www.reformedworship.org/magazine/article.cfm?article_id=201
And here are some really helpful articles by Kevin Twit to further help us think about what we’re singing: http://www.igracemusic.com/hymnbook/other.html
I’m not sure there is an official definition of exactly what constitutes a hymn, as opposed to another type of song.
@ Berean Gal :
We are told multiple times in the Psalms to sing a new sing to the Lord. It does not mean we jettison the old, but that we, as creative beings, are to be expressing our love for God in fresh outflowings of worship in song. Does not a God of infinite glory deserve and demand new songs that mine the inexhaustible depts of greatness?
song; depths (sorry)
My last comment did not get posted. Maybe this one will not either? I came across this quote from C.H. Spurgeon a while back and it stuck with me, and then when this article came up it seemed apropos to send it on. (The Treasury Of David)
“Song should be founded upon search; hymns composed without thought are of no worth, and tunes upon which no pains have been spent are beneath the dignity of divine adoration. Yet when we meditate most, and search most studiously, we shall still find ourselves surrounded with unknowable wonders, which will baffle all attempts to sing them worthily. The best adoration of the Unsearchable is to own Him to be so, and close the eyes in reverence before the excessive light of His glory. Not all the minds of all the centuries shall suffice to search out the unsearchable riches of God: He is past finding out; and, therefore, His deserved praise is still above and beyond all the we can render to Him.”
I have heard it said that the words are the most important thing. Well, if that is true then the music they are written to should not matter as much, or better yet, ditch the music altogether and just recite the words.
“My last comment did not get posted.”
It got posted, and deleted. Frankly, it was the comment of a troll. I think it’s time for you to let this go.
I agree - Ashley Cleveland far outclasses most of the “worship” music that’s available. Her songcraft has definitely matured, and she’s taken on some pretty ambitious hymn and spiritual projects. Would that more of the CCM artists would follow her cue!