It is sometimes hard to believe that it has been only four years since AI became widely available. Few technologies have made so massive and rapid a leap into our daily lives, to the extent that AI now exists in the background of all of our lives and, for many of us, in the foreground as well. Few technologies have evolved as quickly, so that the latest ChatGPT model bears about as much resemblance to its debut as the latest MacBook does to a Commodore 64. If all this has happened in just four years, imagine what the next four—or the next fourteen—might hold.
As AI’s capabilities have increased, so too have the ways we can use it in our homes, churches, and workplaces. It seems like every month or two we read of a feature that can make a difference to our lives by adding a new ability or taking on work that used to be done by a person. The latest trend is the rise of agents—AI tools like Meta’s Muse or xAI’s Grok Bot that can carry out tasks, routines, and duties on an ongoing basis.
With all of the tools available to us and all of their capabilities, it can be difficult to know which uses are legitimate and which are not. We all know that just because AI can do a task doesn’t mean that it should. So how can we determine the legitimate roles AI can play in our lives?
I think sketching out a continuum of some of AI’s potential roles can help us. At the beginning are roles that most of us would agree are illegitimate, and at the end roles that most of us would agree are legitimate. Between them are roles that may be illegitimate in some cases and perfectly fine in others. These demand that we approach them thoughtfully to determine whether integrating them into our lives would be an act of wisdom or folly. As you will see, illegitimate roles tend to be those that require a who whereas legitimate roles tend to be those that require a mere what.
The Continuum
AI as God. There are some people, most of them deeply engaged in the tech industry, who ascribe to AI god-like qualities and who relate to it accordingly. They may believe it is an evil god that is likely to destroy humanity or a benevolent god that is likely to redeem humanity, but in either case, they treat AI as something far more than software. These people go too far and commit idolatry as they attribute to tech what rightly belongs to God.
AI as Friend. There are some people who relate to AI as a friend, and even a few troubled people who relate to it as a lover. While AI is capable of mimicking the kind of relationship one might enjoy with a fellow human being, it can only ever mimic it. To relate to AI as a friend is to anthropomorphize a mere technology and worse, to deprive oneself of actual friendship. Though AI can imitate friendship, it cannot be a friend in any legitimate sense of the word, for friendship depends upon personhood. Not only that, but friendship depends upon mutuality and both the blessings and risks that come with relationship. You cannot be friends with AI any more than you can be friends with a tree, a PlayStation, or any other non-being.
AI as Counselor. Many people today relate to AI as a counselor—a confidant who will listen patiently and counsel them with a trusted voice. Yet because AI is a what, not a who, it cannot offer answers based on a true understanding of their circumstances, true wisdom that comes from learning and experience, or true compassion that comes from sharing their humanity. It cannot empathize with them, pray for them, or plead with the Holy Spirit for wisdom in helping them. AI is capable of advising in many ways, but not of counseling, for counseling is inherently personal.
AI as Pastor. Increasingly, people bring to AI the matters of spiritual health, growth, and well-being that in the past would have been addressed to a pastor. Every Christian needs to be under the loving oversight of a pastor who will care for their soul, and such crucial matters must be entrusted not to AI, but to a pastor who is called and qualified. As with so many other areas, AI can mimic a pastor, but it cannot be one, nor can it replace one.
As we progress through this continuum, we come to uses of AI that may be either legitimate or illegitimate depending on the circumstance, and such legitimacy often depends upon whether we are being deceptive as we use it. When we determine a use may be legitimate, we still need to apply a well-trained mind to distinguish what is wise from what is unwise.
AI as Writer. There are some areas in which AI’s writing capacities can be a form of deception, yet others in which they can be legitimate. A student must not use AI to complete an essay as if she is the writer, and a pastor must not use AI to write a sermon as if he is the one who prepared it. In these ways, AI can be a kind of co-conspirator in the sin of deception. Yet there are many legitimate uses where AI can serve as a writer or co-writer and not deceive anyone. In many cases, technical manuals, policy documents, and many other forms of writing can be ethically written or co-written by AI. I will simply note that what is true of AI as a writer is also true of many other roles: artist, coder, and hundreds of others that can be done openly or deceptively. (Wise: use AI to create a draft of a policy document. Unwise: use AI to finalize a policy document you haven’t read carefully. Crucial: abide by the guidelines given in your school or place of business.)
AI as Editor. AI can be used to great effect as an editor. Of course, a writer will need to put limits on AI since its capabilities can be as basic as spellcheck or as advanced as completely rewriting a short article or full-length book. Some will use it only to edit spelling, grammar, and punctuation, while others will use it to provide feedback on ideas, structure, and argumentation. Writers need to create appropriate boundaries and ensure they are abiding by the guidelines of any organizations they write for. Provided they do so, AI can be a useful and capable editor. (Wise: have AI explain the grammatical errors in your essay. Unwise: have AI completely rewrite your essay.)
AI as Researcher. One of AI’s foremost capabilities is research. Because it has access to such vast amounts of information—vastly more than any human being could ever wrap their mind around—and because its capabilities increase as its access to information grows, it excels at research, provided you carefully verify its facts. It can answer questions or extract useful data with speed and efficiency that surpasses human’s. This may not be appropriate or sufficient in all fields, but in many it is. Remember, though, that research can be formative and outsourcing it to AI (or a human, for that) can deprive you of a process that can shape you and expand your knowledge. (Often wise: use AI in place of Google. Often unwise: use AI in place of Google without verifying its sources and citations.)
As we progress toward the end of the continuum, use cases become more specific to the individual, so I will stop suggesting uses that are wise or unwise. However, individuals will still very much need to make such determinations.
AI as Assistant. AI can fill the role of an assistant and often do it very well. In many people’s lives and work, AI can assist with writing, coding, researching, and a million other assistive tasks. Provided these are tasks an individual would otherwise need to complete himself, AI can free that person to focus on those areas in which he can bring the most value to the world.
AI as Busyworker. AI is increasingly capable of busywork, and this is fast becoming one of its most common uses. It can do the kind of busy work many of us would otherwise not do at all simply because it is too repetitive or annoying. AI agents excel at monitoring prices, detecting changes in documents, and so on. They can take on an almost endless variety of busy tasks and perform them at all hours and without ever growing tired or bored. As time goes on, this is where many of us are likely to come to rely on AI the most.
Conclusion
We are still in the early days of AI, and there’s little doubt that the models we are using today are the least capable we will ever use. The technology is not just growing in its capabilities, but accelerating. Those who wish to live wisely must determine whether they will integrate AI into their lives at all and, if so, how. This continuum can help us understand the difference between roles that require a who and those that need a mere what, and avoid those that involve deception. In that way, I trust it can steer us away from uses that are illegitimate and toward those that are legitimate and wise.






