Skip to content ↓

When Should You Stop Praying?

When Should You Stop Praying

Sir Walter Raleigh filled many roles and wore many hats over the course of his life, among them politician, soldier, and writer. But he is best known to history as an explorer. In 1584, Queen Elizabeth granted him a charter to explore, colonize, and rule any “remote, heathen and barbarous lands, countries and territories, not actually possessed of any Christian Prince or inhabited by Christian People.” In return, he was expected to extend the reach and riches of the crown. The first region he claimed, he named “Virginia” in honor of Elizabeth, the virgin queen.

Over the course of his first illustrious and then ignominious career, he repeatedly came before the queen to ask for funds, favors, appointments, and opportunities, for all of this had to flow through the hands of the monarch. It all required her assent and her largesse. Many observed that the more she gave, the more he asked, and the greater her generosity, the greater his importunity.

It seemed inevitable that over time she would become weary of his constant requests and escalating entreaties. Sure enough, one day in exasperation she asked when he would finally stop being a beggar. His reply was simple: “When you stop giving.” Or more literally, “When, madam, you cease to be a benefactress.”(1)

What a wonderful illustration of our relationship to God! We need to express some caution, of course, when drawing a comparison between the perfect God and an impatient queen. But then again, we need to be cautious when reading Luke 18 and drawing a comparison between the perfect God and an unjust judge. The purpose of the parable is to conclude “If even an unjust judge will eventually grant a good petition, how much more a perfect God?” And the purpose of the comparison to Queen Elizabeth is to conclude “If we should stop making petitions of an exasperated queen only when she ceases to give, how much more the God who never grows impatient?”

We serve a God who commands us to bring our petitions before him. He commands us to ask for those things we need and even those things we long for. He commands us to pray without timidity, to pray without ceasing, and to pray without losing hope. But we are also to pray with patience and perseverance, trusting that God knows far better than we do what we actually need and when it would be best for us to have it. He knows far better than we do what he may need to accomplish within us so we can receive his gifts rightly instead of idolatrously. He rewards us for our patience, honors us for our perseverance, and sanctifies us through our endurance.

“I will stop asking only when you stop giving. I will stop praying only when you make it clear that you no longer answer prayer.”

God will never become exasperated with us and never snap at us. But if we ever lose our confidence and lose our hope, we would do well to echo the old explorer. “I will stop asking only when you stop giving. I will stop praying only when you make it clear that you no longer answer prayer.”

This means that the time for you to quit lifting your petitions is the time when God tells you that he will no longer listen. The day to give up praying is the day when God tells you that he has closed his ears and become deaf to your voice. The moment to stop pleading is the moment when God speaks to assure you that his heart is now hardened and his hand, once opened to supply your needs, is now closed to cut them off. Until that day—a day that will never come—continue to pray, trusting that God continues to listen and to provide.

Inspired in part by De Witt Talmage


  • A La Carte Collection cover image

    Weekend A La Carte (September 14)

    A La Carte: The Battle and the Blessing (a new song!) / Curved in upon ourselves / Pondering the passage of time / The allure and danger of WitchTok / Be a Christian in every situation / and more.

  • Free Stuff Fridays (RFPA)

    This week’s Free Stuff Friday is sponsored by Reformed Free Publishing Association, who also sponsored the blog this week with their article “What Is God’s Calling For Me?” They are offering a free copy of Finding My Vocation: A Guide to Young People Seeking a Calling to each of ten winners. How can I pick…

  • Grounded in Grace

    Your Kids Need You To Help Them Build Their Identity

    It has always been important that children establish their identity. From the time kids are young, they are being formed in a host of ways and gradually coming to terms with who they are and who they will become. Historically, identity arose from outside—from the people they came from, the place they were born, and…

  • A La Carte Friday 2

    A La Carte (September 13)

    A La Carte: Will God forgive my worst sin? / Seeing dignity instead of misery among the poor / Aging graciously / How edgy are you? / What Trump should have said to Kamala / Kindle deals / and more.

  • A La Carte Thursday 1

    A La Carte (September 12)

    A La Carte: Our greatest tool for reaching the West again / Ordained or allowed? / One for the misfits / If the Twin Towers fell after Twitter / How to get over it when you taught poorly / Kindle deals / and more.

  • Pastoral Prayer

    The Pastoral Prayer: Examples and Inspirations

    Of all the elements that once made up traditional Protestant worship, there is probably none that has fallen on harder times than prayer. It is not unusual to visit a church today and find that prayer is perfunctory, rare, or absent altogether. If that is true of prayer in general, it is particularly true of…