| This page is current as of August 2026. For recommendations on other books and an introduction to this series, visit Best Commentaries on Each Book of the Bible. |
Moo’s commentary is widely regarded as the best treatment of James and is universally recommended by the commentators on the commentaries. You may recognize his name from the recommendations for Romans where his name also appears. Keith Mathison says it well: “If you can only have one commentary on James, this is the one to have. Highly recommended.” Do note that Moo has also written a volume for the Tyndale New Testament Commentary series; if you own this one (which you should) you will have no need for the other. (Be sure to get the fully revised 2021 second edition: , , . Craig Blomberg says of it, “Fully abreast of the latest scholarship on James, Moo here walks readers with remarkable clarity through even complex exegetical issues. Highly recommended.”)
Davids receives top billing from some of the experts. The NIGTC series is targeted squarely at the scholar or well-trained pastor, so you may struggle with this one unless you have some knowledge of the Greek text. Jim Rosscup says, “Davids writes in a style that often refreshes, and not only provides a verse by verse commentary that shows great awareness of literature and facets important to explain the text but in a special section develops seven themes of theology.”
I always find it valuable to have one entry-level, reader-friendly commentary for each book. When it comes to James, you may not do better than Motyer’s contribution to the BST. Carson says this volume “displays the strengths we have come to expect from this series, along with some thoughtful suggestions as to the structure of James.” Rosscup and Mathison also give it high praise.
This was the first volume in Zondervan’s Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament. Because it is relatively new, reviews are a little bit hard to find. However, those who have reviewed it, have reviewed it positively. The format and layout of the series is very helpful and that, combined with sound exegesis and helpful interpretation, make this a good purchase.
I was not able to find many reviews of Daniel Doriani’s James in the Reformed Expository Commentary series, but have read it personally with great profit. (Amazon, Westminster Books, Logos)
Which one is for you?
| Serious study | Moo (Pillar New Testament Commentary) |
| A first read | Motyer (The Bible Speaks Today) |
