- RSS FeedSubscribe
- « Previous PostThe Silence at the T4G Blog
- Next Post »Board (Not Boring) Games
Book Review - Signs of the Spirit
- 12/06/08
- 7
Recent years have seen a resurgence of interest in the writing of prominent Christians of days past. Christians have turned with renewed interest to church Fathers, to Reformers and to Puritans. One of the chief benefits of this interest has been the many "interpretations" and contemporary adaptations of classic books. Taylor and Kapic, working with Crossway, have edited two volumes of John Owen, giving us updated versions of Owen's classic texts on the Holy Spirit and on Sin and temptation. Also from Crossway comes Signs of the Spirit, Sam Storms' interpretation of Jonathan Edwards' The Religious Affections.
The book begins with a Preface serving as a brief apologetic for the book. Expressing his debt to Edwards, Storm writes of all the times he has recommended Edwards' works only to hear that people have given up, unable to plow their way through the dense texts. "Nothing grieves me more than to hear that yet another has started reading Edwards only to give up, frustrated by his style or overwhelmed by the complexity of his argumentation." Finally giving in to the need to create an interpretation of Edwards that can extend his reach to those unable to face his books on their own, and having read the Affections at least ten times, Storms wrote Signs of the Spirit. What he offers is something more (or perhaps something less) than a contemporary rendering. Instead, it is a succinct summary. Where Edwards may take five or six pages to make a point, Storms will try to make it in just a few paragraphs. And he will do so without much of the difficult sentence structure and archaic prose that marks Edwards' original.
The format of the book is straightforward. After the Preface and an Introduction that sets the context in which Edwards wrote The Religious Affections, Storms simply follows Edwards, offering one chapter for each chapter or section of the original. Sometimes summarizing and sometimes quoting directly, Storms captures the essence of each of the book's sections. At the end of it all, he does the same for Edwards' Personal Narrative, a book he says provides a "penetrating gaze into [Edwards'] own soul, together with his spiritual struggles and triumphs."
I read Signs of the Spirit alongside The Religious Affections and benefited from it. Where I found the original obscure, far more often than not I found help in Storms' book. It makes for a valuable companion to The Religious Affections and one that would be at home in the hands of anyone who seeks to read, enjoy, and benefit from the writings of Jonathan Edwards.



Comments (7)
Thanks Tim. I will have to recommend this book to people. I know many who have neither the time nor desire to wade through Edwards' (now) difficult-to-read prose but may have time for encountering the riches of Edwards through a book such as this.
I have long found Edwards' writings in this area quite compelling, deep, and (indeed) convicting. The Religious Affections is truly a classic. I wish it had been assigned reading at Westminster when I was there.
I probably won't get a chance to read this book, but I like the idea of writing short summaries. In the past, I've found that many writers tend to take forever to make their point.
Call me a product of the "low attention span generation," but I particularly like when books make their points quickly. This book sounds interested then in that it condenses the writing of others. I'm sure it's a great resource and a great reminder for me to be concise.
Thanks,
Marshall Jones, Jr.
From bondChristian
I purchased the book, but have not read it yet. Thanks for the review. I did read "The Experience That Counts!" in the last year. it is a Grace Publications effort. In their words: "It is an abridged version, re-written for today's readers, of the classic 'A treatise concerning religious affections' by Jonathan Edwards." I would be interested to know if you are anyone else you know has read that version and if so what you/they thought.
This is a wonderful idea. I hope that it will serve not as a short-cut, but a stepping stone to Edwards, as when I encouraged my daughter to watch a movie version of Much Ado About Nothing before trying to read the play. Understanding the framework of the story gives the mind something to make connections with and hold the interest.
I think part of Edwards impact comes directly from his style. He forces hard thinking, trudging, wading - strengthening mental and spiritual muscles. He studies the same points from many angles, like a scientist carefully observing his subject - gaining greater understanding from gradually increasing familiarity. One does not quickly forget lessons learned the hard way! So I hope this book will provide a warm introduction to Edwards thought that makes folks hunger to dive all the way in and soak there for a while.
Thanks for the review.
It's a great book, and you can tell how much Storms values Edwards from the way he writes. If everyone read this the church would be in much better health.
Edwards has risen to my top five favorite authors apart from scripture of which Paul is my favorite. Though I am not aware of the changes that would be present in this edition, I would suggest anyone who has a desire to read Edwards should invest in his complete works (2vol). Though many have stressed the point further than they should, Edwards is not far beyond the average reading level, sometimes some points must be reread several times in order to be fully grasped, it does not mean you should shy away, the wealth of wisdom in his words are too valuable to be missed. Nothing worth doing is done easy, this may apply to Edwards works, but you return far outways the investment.
Those who fully appreciate Edwards as a faithful servant of God who advanced the Word of God in his day will appreciate the way Sam Storms has dusted off this classic work with equal appreciation as a fellow servant for the cause of Christ.
He has not devalued or dumbed down Edwards work, but dusted it off for better effectiveness to this generation. I applaud Sam's work here.
Hushai