Skip to content ↓

Best Commentaries on Ecclesiastes

This page is current as of September 2026.

For recommendations on other books and an introduction to this series, visit
Best Commentaries on Each Book of the Bible.

When I initially created a list of commentary recommendations, the options for Ecclesiastes were relatively sparse. The past few years, though, have provided some excellent new options.

Recently published — awaiting expert review
Ecclesiastes cover
Reformed Expository CommentaryPreaching
Ecclesiastes
Douglas Sean O’Donnell

The REC is based on sermons so easy to read and appropriate for any kind of reader.

Ecclesiastes cover
Hodder Bible CommentaryFirst read
Ecclesiastes
Eric Ortlund

David Gibson—whose Living Life Backward many readers of this page will know—calls it “a delightful commentary on a book of Holy Scripture which so many find incomprehensible at best and disheartening at worst,” and “a faithful guide to wisdom and joy in life with Christ east of Eden.” Ortlund is a trusted guide to the wisdom literature (his book on Leviathan in Job is superb), and this is the strongest new expository option on Ecclesiastes in years.

Philip Ryken – Ecclesiastes: Why Everything Matters (Preaching the Word). Similar to the REC, the Preaching the Word series is based on sermons and appropriate for a wide range of purposes.

Ecclesiastes cover
Mentor CommentaryStudy
Ecclesiastes
Richard Belcher

Both the commentator (Richard Belcher) and the publisher (Christian Focus) have a long history of excellence and faithfulness.

Expert recommendations
The Message of Ecclesiastes cover
The Bible Speaks TodayFirst read
The Message of Ecclesiastes
Derek Kidner

Ecclesiastes is a book that lends itself to varied interpretations. Kidner is one of my favorite commentators and I was glad to see that his commentary rated near the top for most of the experts. Jim Rosscup calls this a “lively, popular exposition of Ecclesiastes that relates the message, accurately given, to life today.” Written at a popular-level, this one will be suitable for general readers and pastors alike.

Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs cover
NIV Application CommentaryFirst read
Ecclesiastes, Song of Songs
Iain Provan

Provan’s commentary covers two books and is worth referencing for each of them. Tremper Longman says, “Proven has written one of the most interesting commentaries on these two intriguing books. Even though one may not agree with his final conclusions, his thinking is provocative and will lead the reader to think through old issues.”

Ecclesiastes cover
Tyndale Old Testament CommentariesFirst read
Ecclesiastes
Michael A. Eaton

Eaton’s commentary, also written at a popular level, is regarded as one of the best available, at least by those who don’t regard it as awful (a strange phenomenon I’ve seen with commentaries on Ecclesiastes). Mathison says, “Like all of the commentaries in the Tyndale series, Eaton’s work is clear and concise. Eaton views Ecclesiastes as an apologetic essay. It defends the life of faith in God by detailing how terrible the alternative is. Life without God, according to Ecclesiastes, is futile. With all of the different approaches to interpreting Ecclesiastes, I find Eaton’s particularly helpful.”

Coping with Change cover
Coping with Change
Walter Kaiser

In the 1970’s Walter Kaiser released a small, popular, but excellent commentary on Ecclesiastes titled Total Life. That book was much-loved and considering one of the best treatments of the Ecclesiastes. It fell out of print some time ago but has now been replaced by Coping with Change. Dale Ralph Davis compares the two and says, “the ‘bones’ are much the same but the whole has been updated and expanded. Perhaps the most helpful feature … is that he believes the book has a discernible plan and a traceable argument and that Qoheleth was not a cynical old goat who drank Drano and vinegar for breakfast.”

The Book of Ecclesiastes cover
The New International Commentary on the Old Testament
The Book of Ecclesiastes
Tremper Longman

Many regard this commentary with some caution, but it may still worth be consulting in parts if not in the whole. Keith Mathison says, “Like many, Longman argues that the monologue by Qohelet (the main speaker in the book) is framed by the words of a narrator. According to Longman, however, Qohelet is a skeptic with no hope. Longman argues that the narrator uses Qohelet’s monologue to teach his son about the dangers of such skepticism. The positive teaching of the book, then, is found in the words of the narrator. Not all will agree with his interpretation, but it is worth examining.”

Which one is for you?

Serious studyO’Donnell (Reformed Expository Commentary); Belcher (Mentor Commentary)
Preaching a seriesO’Donnell (Reformed Expository Commentary)
A first readOrtlund (Hodder Bible Commentary); Kidner (The Bible Speaks Today); Provan (NIV Application Commentary)

  • Would you support my work

    Would You Consider Supporting My Work?

    Challies.com has been free for 23 years and will stay that way. Once a year I ask readers to consider supporting the work through Patreon, PayPal, or by mail. Today’s that day!

  • thurs 3

    A La Carte (November 19)

    The hardest day you may ever face / For the ones like me / Praying to the God who rules history / Dear Gen Alpha, Claude wants to turn you into a toad / Old dogs and new tricks / Getting a handle on our emotions / Kindle deals and more

  • Demolition

    What Takes 20 Years to Build Takes 5 Minutes to Destroy

    I think we’ve all heard many variations of the adage, “It takes 20 years to build a reputation, but only five minutes to destroy it.” A good name that has been established through many years of honor, success, or skilled leadership can be ruined in a moment when an act of immorality comes to light.

  • A La Carte (November 18)

    Remembering John Allen Chau / How to experience gospel transformation / The quiet voice / What we get wrong about the tears of Jesus / I thought adultery had been approved / The singularity will never happen / Kindle deals, videos, and more

  • Christian Books This Week

    This Week in Christian Books (November 17, 2026)

    This is a big week, thanks largely to Christian Focus, which releases its whole November list in one go. It also brings a new edition of J. I. Packer’s Truth and Power, Matthew Westerholm’s Biblical Worship, Randy Alcorn’s major book on what the Bible says about animals, and the newest volume in the Reformed Expository…

  • A La Carte (November 17)

    Classroom apologetics / Can we legitimately judge a person’s faith? / Lord, why am I still here? / The world is always burning / Frank Peretti and the 40th anniversary of This Present Darkness / The best way to serve your local church / Kindle deals, new books, and more